If this is what "high quality discussion" is to you, what does mid level discussion look to you? Just a slur as a response?
>Mesopotamians needed complex mathematics for taxes long before even Mycenian Greeks came into picture. You are talking about classical Greeks. Naturally there were advancements in mathematics during the Greek period, but that does not undermine the achievements of Mesopotamians.
I am stunned by your knowledge. You really know that? That is breathtaking information. Genuinely thank you for posting this novel information that I was totally unaware of. Bringing that to my attention was extremely relevant and has radically changed my position.
Seriously fuck off, you still haven't even bothered to read my OP.
I am perplexed by the notion that time does not play a role for you when talking about the "history" of something.
Just like the fact the Phoenecian alphabet was modified by the Greeks, there would have definitely been transfer of knowledge.
I don't understand what's wrong with rusticpenn original post and I don't think they argue in bad faith. Maybe you are right, but because of all the personal attacks you make, it's hard to see your point, and you also come of as very rude. I don't write this to criticize you - I'm just saying that if you change the way you argue, you will probably convince many more people to your ideas. Constructive discussion is, in general, a very useful skill in life.
the worst case, from my point of view, is when they're actually just dumb and you yell at them for their intellectual limitations. that's sad