Re:Z-Library Admins "Escape House Arrest" After Judge Approv...
by User23 on Monday July 08, 2024 @08:10PM
(#40911203)
That is an hilariously authoritarian view and wrong to boot.
You are confusing rights that are created by the threat of violence, such as copyright, and rights that are protected by the threat of violence, such as the right to not be killed for no reason.
Needless to say there is no inherent right for an author to profit from copyright. It is a wholly constructed right. They do not "deserve" it. Perhaps a society chooses to organize itself that way and perhaps it doesn't. On the other hand, innocent people really do deserve to not get murdered.
Re:Z-Library Admins "Escape House Arrest" After Judge Approv...
by root_axis on Monday July 08, 2024 @08:33PM
(#40911370)
Am I understanding correctly that your position is that the enforcement of property rights is authoritarian? Or is your position that copyright is not a form of property rights, and thus authoritarian?
Re:Z-Library Admins "Escape House Arrest" After Judge Approv...
by lmm on Monday July 08, 2024 @08:30PM
(#40911354)
For the vast majority of recorded human history there was no copyright. We have records of Roman senators semi-complaining about how rude an acquaintance who wouldn't let them copy their book (not a book they had written, a book they had come into possession of a copy of) was.
Re:Z-Library Admins "Escape House Arrest" After Judge Approv...
by root_axis on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @12:23AM
(#40912517)
Yes, I was referring to the OP's quote about armed men enforcing the law, not copyright.
Re:Z-Library Admins "Escape House Arrest" After Judge Approv...
by lmm on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @12:46AM
(#40912607)
Armed men have never enforced that everyone gets what they deserve. Not even close. They enforce those laws that we have decided they should. It's a huge leap from saying that someone deserves something to saying that society's armed men should take that something from other people and give it to them.
Yes, that's how property rights - and in fact all rights afforded through civilized society - are enforced. If you have a problem with that take it up with literally the entirety of recorded human history.