It's kind of like saying: "Lawyers? I've dealt with them twice -- and let me tell you, they're all a bunch of lying scumbags who ..."
But interesting data points, nonetheless.
If you deal with two lawyers and on both occasions they lie to you that is a perfectly rational and defensible position to take.
Kinda like being bitten by the same breed of dog twice or opening two bottles of beer from the same brewer on two different occasions and finding them both to be filled with water.
The thing about default positions is that they only represent a beginning.
I am a human.
I am also not an at-bat in a game of baseball. Two strikes and you're out.
Especially, that probably your two strikes rule can be applied such way to groups of people that everybody would be “out”. For example if they are white, then all white is out, and also everybody in the whole new world, and the north hemisphere, and everybody who lives on continents, etc. But I’m quite sure that it would be possible to form such groups from which you would be the only who is not out.
You can think like that, I don’t care, sometimes I do too, but it still doesn’t make it rational.
That is ironically, in itself, a gross distortion of what I'm saying here.
Whether this is a useful way of looking at the world or not is up to you.
But in any case: no, they're definitely and obviously not the same.
Just because someone's view of a particular situation isn't exactly as diabolically dark and sinister as yours -- doesn't mean they see it as all rainbows and unicorns, either.
It's a bit more like saying: "Lawyers? Both I've dealt with were lying scumbags so I'm distrustful of lawyers in general."
Not that it's especially more rational but it at least allows for trusting particular journalists.
Can you present some sample data from which to draw something ? /s
>Every journalist who is not too stupid or full of himself to notice what is going on knows that what he does is morally indefensible. He is a kind of confidence man, preying on people's vanity, ignorance, or loneliness, gaining their trust and betraying them without remorse.
From her book The Journalist and The Murderer
In the early 90s I was interviewed for a newspaper for winning a writing contest and an exact and precise 0.0% of the quotes attributed to me were spoken by me.
Later I was in the Army and I was interviewed by a major national news network while preparing to deploy overseas.
The 7 seconds of me talking, extracted from the five or so minutes of interview, that made it to air was so chopped up and out of order in relation to the questions being asked that it formed an actual, intentional, lie on the part of the person who created the video.
If "intrepid" reporters are willing to lie in a four-paragraph story in the middle of the Metro section of a newspaper, what are they doing for the big stories?
There is a multi-billion-dollar industry that has been specifically created to train you on how to communicate with journalists, to make it harder for them to lie on your behalf.
As far as I can tell, the journalist combines the morals of hollywood producers, the ethics of used car salesmen, and the smug self-righteousness of mid-century urban planners into one profession.