News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple is About to Reduce Google's Revenues by jyap on Sunday June 10, 2012 @05:55AM (#4090659)
To be fair, this is just some random writer at Forbes who doesn't really know what he's talking about to write a totally informed 'article' and is basing his 'article' on some quotes he found and his view of joining the dots. The dots being pretty obvious as least to the Hacker News crowd.

So yes, agreed, his connecting of dots come across poorly but it didn't stop him from gathering 38k views.

Re:Apple is About to Reduce Google's Revenues by clinth on Sunday June 10, 2012 @08:40AM (#4090886)
Agreed. And splitting hairs here, but he's a Forbes contributor, not a writer there. Forbes is using its magazine's name to make its federated/outsourced blog system sound more credible. forbes.com has a lot of blogspam.
Re:Apple is About to Reduce Google's Revenues by smcnally on Sunday June 10, 2012 @09:35AM (#4090997)
What are examples of what you consider blogspam on forbes.com?
Re:Apple is About to Reduce Google's Revenues by someperson on Sunday June 10, 2012 @09:47AM (#4091023)
Here's one (but by no means the only) example: http://nickoneill.com/how-fortune-stole-a-new-york-times-art...

From what I've seen, articles on forbes.com are mostly low-quality - often blogspam or tabloid-style journalism. They seem to have a good reputation in society which isn't represented by their articles.

I would be a happier living in a filter bubble with "forbes.com" removed from my life.

Re:Apple is About to Reduce Google's Revenues by smcnally on Sunday June 10, 2012 @04:03PM (#4092029)
I'm not saying there are no examples. In the one you bring up, though, I recall the piece and ensuing hullaballoo: The original NYT author, Charles Duhigg, basically admired and defended the Forbes writer's job (re taking the story in a different direction; providing more exposure to an audience outside his own; providing a prominent book plug), and then O'Neill backed off his own "link-baity" headline.

http://jimromenesko.com/2012/02/21/nyt-reporter-defends-forb...

In general (though, agreed, ~off-topic here), more can be done w/r/t quality assurance of a distributed content network. Something like "report blogspam" is highly subjective and rife with abuse potential. Slashdot's moderation / meta moderation, in combination with straight up and down votes by the wider community, can be effective. Relying on a "central editorial functions" to handle it all is inefficient and doesn't scale well.

This - reputation, rewards, quality (of writers, content, community) - has been an area of interest for me for years. I'm actively working on same currently. I'll put an Ask HN together and see if it gets any traction.

(Disclaimer: I work at Forbes and speak here only for myself)

Re:Apple is About to Reduce Google's Revenues by TrevorJ on Sunday June 10, 2012 @10:55AM (#4091194)
I noticed that the other day, with the submission comparing Facebook to Enron. I was suprised how poorly thought out the article was, coming from a name like Forbes.