So yes, agreed, his connecting of dots come across poorly but it didn't stop him from gathering 38k views.
From what I've seen, articles on forbes.com are mostly low-quality - often blogspam or tabloid-style journalism. They seem to have a good reputation in society which isn't represented by their articles.
I would be a happier living in a filter bubble with "forbes.com" removed from my life.
http://jimromenesko.com/2012/02/21/nyt-reporter-defends-forb...
In general (though, agreed, ~off-topic here), more can be done w/r/t quality assurance of a distributed content network. Something like "report blogspam" is highly subjective and rife with abuse potential. Slashdot's moderation / meta moderation, in combination with straight up and down votes by the wider community, can be effective. Relying on a "central editorial functions" to handle it all is inefficient and doesn't scale well.
This - reputation, rewards, quality (of writers, content, community) - has been an area of interest for me for years. I'm actively working on same currently. I'll put an Ask HN together and see if it gets any traction.
(Disclaimer: I work at Forbes and speak here only for myself)
There's another similar kind of misunderstanding whenever Apple releases the "money they have paid to developers". First they forget that Apple only ever mentions the total amount they have paid since the App Store was created in 2008.
They also forget that again, Apple had a huge headstart in both number of apps and in number of units in the market until late 2010 or so, and that only more recently they've had about the same amount of apps and number of units in the market as Apple.
So when you compare the "total amount" Apple has paid to devs to Google's "total amount" that they paid to devs, obviously Apple will come out on top because of their huge headstart in the first 2-3 years. But if you compare the last quarter or last year for both, which is a lot more relevant for devs, because they'd want to know how much they can make right now, Apple might still come out on top, but the difference should be a lot smaller, and definitely not something like $3 billion vs $100 million.
Hopefully the "Apple media" will remember this before they start slamming Google when Apple will release their new numbers, without really understanding the context of those numbers.
http://articles.latimes.com/2010/may/12/business/la-fi-googl...
In the US, Google accounted for 28% of smartphones versus Apple's 21%.
Apple opened its App Store in July 10, 2008. Google opened up its Android Market in 22 October 2008.
If you follow Apple's conference calls, you'd realize that Apple gives frequent updates of the amount being paid out to developers. In the last quarter, Apple paid developers approx. $500 million. So far as I can see, Google doesn't release figures for what they pay Android developers in either app or ad revenues.
If Google was to be more transparent with their revenues and how much Android developers receive, then there could be a genuine accounting for how each platform is doing, but ironically in these instances Apple is far more open than Google.
You could say that Apple makes infinity times more money from their app store if you were just talking about sales of apps.
but the quote he uses (his own) to support this actually combines search and maps with no indication of the proportion of revenue between the two products: "The figures also suggest that Apple devices such as the iPhone, which use products such as its Maps as well as Google Search in its Safari browser, generated more than four times as much revenue for Google as its own handsets in the same period." [ http://www.forbes.com/sites/timworstall/2012/06/09/apple-is-... ]
Also - This calculation was debunked shortly after it was published: http://marketingland.com/no-google-doesnt-make-four-times-mo...