News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Portugal brings back tax breaks for foreigners in bid to ... by ithkuil on Sunday July 07, 2024 @10:45AM (#40898067)
I feel you may be swinging the pendulum too far in dismissing the second order effects of money being spent.

Do the landowners and restaurant owners not pay taxes in Portugal? Do they spend all they new income abroad?

Re:Portugal brings back tax breaks for foreigners in bid to ... by ryandrake on Sunday July 07, 2024 @11:26AM (#40898315)
It's somewhere in the middle, probably. People talk about wealthy foreigners, tourists and so on "bringing money to an area" as if that money is being uniformly dumped from a helicopter onto everyone. That's never what happens. It goes into the pockets of a relatively small handful of people/businesses, those people will spend a fraction of it, and downstream people will spend another fraction, and so on. It trickles a little, but the entire community is not benefiting uniformly.
Re:Portugal brings back tax breaks for foreigners in bid to ... by EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK on Sunday July 14, 2024 @02:43PM (#40962545)
That's what I suggested in my heavily downvoted comment - "Maybe the tax should be imposed on the landlords' windfall profits instead?"
Re:Portugal brings back tax breaks for foreigners in bid to ... by EasyMark on Sunday July 07, 2024 @12:37PM (#40898691)
There is rarely one solution or “cause” when considering something as complicated as the economy. It’s really easy for politicians to play on the fears of the masses. There seems to be a solid 20-40% of ANY country that is willing to place all blame on “the other” rather than realize it’s a complex situation. So foreigners are an easy thing to pin all issues on for a politician to gain power, and it takes a complete failure of their flawed theory to convince the population that “hmmm maybe there isn’t an easy fix” by blaming foreigners. I see this nonsense all the time in Texas.
Re:Portugal brings back tax breaks for foreigners in bid to ... by kranke155 on Monday July 08, 2024 @01:05PM (#40907156)
The biggest second order effect is Portuguese people can't afford to live in major cities anymore.

Taking that into consideration the remainder is a bit academic.

Re:Portugal brings back tax breaks for foreigners in bid to ... by ithkuil on Monday July 15, 2024 @02:54AM (#40965783)
gentrification is a problem. But it's hard to truly understand a problem if all sides try to make it extreme.

What does "Portuguese people can't afford to live in major cities anymore." actually mean? Does it mean that major Portuguese cities are no longer inhabited by a majority of Portuguese citizens? Or does it mean that there are some Portuguese people who no longer cannot afford to live there and that the blame for that is the few foreigners who contributed to raising prices in such a way that the those portugues who were already poor now crossed the line and couldn't affort to live in major cities, and joined the other portuguese who already couldn't afford to live there because of other causes of wealth inequality?

EDIT: It's not just mere nitpicking; I really think actual magnitudes are important in in discussions around these topics but the public debates I see often present the problem in very broad strokes and thus inevitably end up in shouting contests by people who have very strong opinions and the rest of us just looks the other way no longer believing what is being said. I know for a fact that that gentrification is destroying europeans city centres. It's very hard to afford to live in other places like Florence, Italy too. But is it really so clear cut that it's because of tax cuts for expats? Or it's just a result of a bimodal distribution of wealth including native wealth?