News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by svara on Sunday July 07, 2024 @09:14AM (#40897446)
If Germany gets this right, then, very little gas. The role of gas peaker plants in a system dominated by PV and wind is as a dispatchable backup for weather patterns in which storage is insufficient. By building out storage, load shifting and long distance transmission, you can squeeze out gas almost completely.

You still need it for those very low probability situations that would be disproportionately expensive to also cover with storage (since storage becomes exponentially more expensive the more you build, since it needs to be used exponentially less).

At some point, it'll hopefully be possible to eliminate carbon emissions from gas plants entirely with CCS or by burning synthetic gas.

Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by zozbot234 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @09:21AM (#40897510)
How can you realistically build out storage when the bulk of current storage is pumped hydro, which can't realistically be scaled up and is not obviously enough for the possibility of lengthy, geographically vast "cold snaps" of renewables-hostile weather. Is this about feasible, proven technology or just sci-fi speculation?
Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by defrost on Sunday July 07, 2024 @09:27AM (#40897557)

    With a turnover of over 15.7 billion euros, and a 46 percent growth increase in comparison to 2022, the energy storage sector’s expansion in Germany continues at a fast pace ...

    The toal capacity of household storage devices now has reached about 6 gigawatts, roughly equal to the capacity of Germany’s pumped hydro storage installations, the association said.
~ https://www.cleanenergywire.org/news/energy-storage-capacity...
Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by svara on Sunday July 07, 2024 @09:33AM (#40897601)
Don't ask me, go do your own research if you really want to learn about this. It's a complex topic.

I agree that nuclear should have it's place in a modern energy grid for the time being, but the skepticism towards renewables from nuclear proponents is also not right. It may have been justified twenty years ago, but the world is different now.

The thing is that there's isn't one answer to how to smooth out renewable production, making it harder to mentally model than a simple "just build nuclear".

I'm going to just give a few ones that you need to take together:

* You don't need pumped hydro. There's a massive yearly 650 TWh of hydro in Europe, which can serve as a "virtual battery" by using it only when other renewable sources are low. The same, to a lesser extent, is true for bio-methane.

* Electricity is just about 10% of primary energy. The other 90% contain many sources of demand that are extremely amenable to load shifting. Cars, heating, to name two massive ones.

* Short term variations in renewable output (i.e, anything shorter than seasonal) can be smoothed by batteries, eventually. Not today, but, like PV, battery cost is on a staggering exponential decline.

* The EU has an integrated grid, nuclear will continue to be used in all European countries at least indirectly through imports.

From a high level economic perspective: The low and declining cost of a kWh PV provides a massive economic incentive to solve this.

Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by adrianN on Sunday July 07, 2024 @10:54AM (#40898129)
You build electrolyzers and batteries?
Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by TheLoafOfBread on Sunday July 07, 2024 @02:15PM (#40899361)
* Pumped storage is hours of electric output

* Battery storage is minutes of electric output

Cold snaps and inversions (clouds are low, no wind, cold) are counted in days to weeks.

Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by derriz on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:29PM (#40899834)
Battery storage systems generally provide 4 hours of full power output per daily cycle not minutes and are specifically designed to exploit the most typical daily demand cycle which has a 4 hour peak.

You're mixing up the use of batteries for grid stabilization with their use for storage.

Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by TheLoafOfBread on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:28PM (#40901011)
Generally more like 20 minutes.
Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by derriz on Sunday July 07, 2024 @08:32PM (#40901641)
That’s not true - the average storage duration for grid batteries used in non-stabalization roles is 4 hours - see https://www.eia.gov/todayinenergy/detail.php?id=51798 and that’s from a few years ago. Since then the xMW, 4xMWh format has become almost universal.
Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by TheLoafOfBread on Monday July 08, 2024 @02:40AM (#40903093)
Yeah with draw of few kW. If you would draw watts, it could last for months!

But it might come as a shock to you, cities are taking in order of MW to GW

Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by derriz on Monday July 08, 2024 @06:36AM (#40904201)
I don't understand your point at all.

A typical grid-storage battery will have enough storage to dispatch power at 100% of its rated capacity for 4 hours.

Of course if you draw out the energy at less than full capacity, it will take longer to fully discharge.

The largest battery currently in the US - Moss Landing - for example is rated 750 MW/3,000 MWh - which means it can sustain 750MW of output for 4 hours and it does this daily.

This is not "20 minutes".

Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by adrianN on Sunday July 07, 2024 @02:33PM (#40899492)
> You build electrolyzers

New solar parks often come with a couple of hours of battery storage. You numbers seem to be out of date.

Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by TheLoafOfBread on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:29PM (#40901024)
No they are not. It is either 30 minutes at MW range or hours at kW range. And countries are taking GW
Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by anovikov on Sunday July 07, 2024 @09:26AM (#40897549)
Just add batteries. It's cheap. Fleet of installed grid batteries will exceed pumped hydro in maybe 2-3 years and will keep expanding at a crazy rate after. Storage is solved.

In general, renewable electricity is solved. Energy transition problems is now about marine and air transport for which no applicable solution exists yet (ammonia is too problematic from too many angles and hydrogen stubbornly refuses to really take off).

Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by energy123 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @11:37PM (#40902416)
> How can you realistically build out storage when the bulk of current storage is pumped hydr

You build batteries like what California is doing.

> possibility of length, geographically vast "cold snaps"

The correlation between renewables drops off literally exponentially as a function of distance, creating a diversification effect that makes this situation sufficiently rare. The bigger the land mass, the better. You also overbuild by a bit to handle droughts, and curtail in normal periods. In the circumstances that it still happens, you use natural gas as a backstop, or you use long-duration clean storage like hydrogen (which remains more hypothetical/expensive currently, but that will change).

Re:Germany set to overhaul subsidy regime for renewable energy by anonym29 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @11:49PM (#40902463)
I'm not making the argument that grid-scale storage is currently feasible, but there are some really interesting developments on sand batteries, CO2 batteries, and plastic batteries, among others. They're at various stages of development and all have unique pros and cons (cost, efficiency, longevity, scalability, etc), but I suspect renewables + storage will eventually prove to be exceedingly cost efficient once we figure out the "right" way to do them.

Hydrocarbons have had centuries of process improvements and optimizations - I think it's only fair to give renewables a chance to catch up, no?