News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by zogrodea on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:06AM (#40896418)
This is very fair, to respect someone's wishes with regards to how their image is used. I'm sad to see this comment (at the time of posting) be downvoted.

It doesn't imply guilt on the author of this interesting article or others who used this image without knowing her wishes or anything. I don't understand the response.

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by xyst on Sunday July 07, 2024 @12:02PM (#40898518)
It’s probably downvoted because it doesn’t add anything to the debugging story.

At some point, I’ll probably watch the “Losing Lena” documentary. But I wasted a few minutes to determine the comment was not related to the story

[dead]
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by bowsamic on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:49AM (#40896609)
Yeah that's kind of their thing, right? The brand of the SerenityOS community is a safe haven for developers who don't want to worry about ethical or code of conduct issues. And for the most part it seems to work okay. It's like the stupid line about "keep politics out of x" which is of course impossible, but in the case of SerenityOS it kind of works for them.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:59AM (#40896661)
Well the issue is that they seemingly want to be a safe haven for moderate bigots and regressive types as long as they're polite about it, exactly in line with the "keep politics out of x" thing. Their definition of something "political" and deserving of scorn seems to include something as minor as using gender-neutral pronouns in documentation, while assuming that the reader is male is "apolitical" because that's how things used to be.

It seems to be a space designed to avoid anything which the typical 90s white male geek type wouldn't perceive as political. Which in itself is a highly political goal.

"Using Lenna is on-brand for SerenityOS" is not meant as a compliment.

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by bowsamic on Sunday July 07, 2024 @07:03AM (#40896680)
Well honestly I can't really bring myself to care about it. After all, it's not like we're going into the SerenityOS Discord and seeing Nazis. It's a very slight rebellion, and seems to serve well to defuse tension and actually create a space with less hate than a lot of the spaces which do enforce more modern ethical views.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @07:06AM (#40896699)
I just find it sad, more than anything. SerenityOS and Ladybird are interesting projects which I wish I could respect. But instead they seem insistent on regressing back to a dark age in tech where casual sexism was (even more?) commonplace. I can't respect that.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by account42 on Monday July 08, 2024 @08:15AM (#40904701)
Sounds like a problem with your close mindedness rather than with the project. Also, you loss and not the project's.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by tredre3 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @11:08AM (#40898204)
> safe haven for moderate bigots and regressive types

That's an interesting interpretation. Considering that the project has several trans developers and even a handful of (biological) women I'm going to suggest another interpretation: They're not trying to be a safe haven for bigots, they just don't want the endless CoC/pronouns bikeshedding that plagues too many projects these days.

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by ashleyn on Sunday July 07, 2024 @01:09PM (#40898893)
When it comes to inclusion, I look at where the rubber actually meets the road.

If a project welcomes diverse contributors and doesn't foster an environment that alienates them (which, in part, you can evidence by their continued presence and contributions), that seems way more worth its weight than academic quibbles about the language used in documentation.

Are cis and trans women contributors speaking up about any problems? If not, then is the issue really important? I'd rather see a project not actively alienate cis and trans women developers - a higher bar to actively meet than you'd think - than to be religiously attentive to "microaggressions" and the like while doing very little to actually accommodate them as contributors.

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by gremlions on Monday July 08, 2024 @05:07PM (#40909715)
Referring to women as "cis women" as if we are somehow a subset of our own sex class is also alienating and unwelcoming. It's awfully disrespectful and reveals a fundamentally misogynistic view of women.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by bowsamic on Tuesday July 09, 2024 @04:07PM (#40920524)
> as if we are somehow a subset of our own sex class is also alienating and unwelcoming

You are though, that's just the truth.

> It's awfully disrespectful and reveals a fundamentally misogynistic view of women.

Sometimes the truth hurts. I'm glad we could teach you it

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by gremlions on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @10:07AM (#40927053)
You are of course free to believe whatever sexist gibberish you like. Doesn't make it true.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by account42 on Monday July 08, 2024 @08:17AM (#40904723)
> bigots and regressive types

This by the way is exactly why I approve of any policies that keep people like you out of projects. If you can't learn to get along with people with different beliefs then don't expect them to welcome you.

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by oooiu on Sunday July 07, 2024 @07:37AM (#40896872)
Exactly, it keeps the timewasters out.

Far too many projects get tangled up in this nonsense and it just becomes a headache for maintainers.

It's a great heuristic. As soon as someone starts whining about codes of conduct or pronouns or words like 'blacklist' or whatever just shut them down immediately. And kick them out if they persist. Saves a lot of pointless drama.

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @07:54AM (#40896958)
What you're calling "nonsense" is being baseline decent human beings. That's not a headache, but if it was one, it'd be one that's worth the cost.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by oooiu on Sunday July 07, 2024 @08:01AM (#40896998)
Not really, you've just taken your subjective beliefs about how people should behave and decided to call it baseline human decency.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @08:20AM (#40897095)
All ethics is subjective (or at best intersubjective), you're not pointing out anything new or interesting there. Considering the concept of non-male users to be "too controversial" to accept does not meet my threshold for "basic human decency".
[dead]
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @08:30AM (#40897156)
I say "female" when I mean female and "non-male" when I mean non-male. In this instance I mean non-male. Please spare me the fake outrage over precise terminology.
[dead]
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @08:40AM (#40897223)
I don't understand what you're trying to do. Anyone who could possibly be genuinely convinced by a sexism accusation already knows about the existence of intersex people and non-binary people, so they already know that the term "non-male" refers to a different group of people than "women" (regardless of whether we're talking sex or gender).

This conversation is boring, you're not getting anything out of it, and I'm not getting anything out of it. How about we leave it here?

[dead]
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @08:51AM (#40897290)
Cool beans.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by bowsamic on Sunday July 07, 2024 @07:49AM (#40896938)
It works for them but I don't think it's appropriate everywhere, and there is a cost, if not immediately certainly in the future
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by sph on Sunday July 07, 2024 @11:34AM (#40898359)
Are you guys still going on about that because they don't want to create a political space in their open-source project?

Stop putting politics in everything you touch. Once upon a time, before being an activist poseur was in vogue, open source was all about code, not idiotic posturing for terminally online people.

Oh, the beautiful, inclusive movement of brigading and "with us or against us" black-and-white thinking. Very tolerant indeed.

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by kmeisthax on Sunday July 07, 2024 @12:29PM (#40898658)
RMS has been an "activist poseur" since the very beginning - i.e. before "open source" was even a thing. Do people just never read stallman.org?
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by c-hendricks on Sunday July 07, 2024 @01:30PM (#40899057)
Am I wrong, or is "stop putting politics in _____" just people saying "I will politicize _____"?
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by panzi on Sunday July 07, 2024 @03:49PM (#40899971)
You are not wrong.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @07:23PM (#40901310)
Apparently acknowledging the existence of computer users who aren't male is political now
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by sph on Wednesday July 10, 2024 @01:20AM (#40923933)
Do female users really need "acknowledging"?

Is the lack of acknowledging a barrier?

Are they all waiting for "activists" like you to open the door and be welcomed at using, e.g. SerenityOS?

Do you believe female users feel left behind because there is no official line that says "hi, female users. I acknowledge and salute you. You are welcome here."?

Why do you believe people different than you need your white gloves treatment?

Get off your high horse. It is political posturing at best, at worst it's just getting annoyed at nothing and feeling righteous about it.

All these idiotic inclusive movements all that create is ghettoisation and making everything about gender and race, when the stated goal is to remove the gender and race barrier. In the wise words of Morgan Freeman, "if you want to get rid of racism, stop talking about it".

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by worewood on Sunday July 07, 2024 @09:38PM (#40901955)
Yeah, like that time when somebody just wanted to fix a gramatical error ("he" was being used incorrectly) and the maintainers rejected it on political grounds, bringing politics into something that had nothing to do with politics?

So much for a project that claims to be apolitical

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by userbinator on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:36AM (#40896548)
In 2021, she didn't.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:40AM (#40896569)
I don't understand people who enter comment sections just to confidently state something so easily disproven? Losing Lena came out in 2019.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by userbinator on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:52AM (#40896620)
I don't understand people who enter comment sections just to virtue-signal their manufactured outrage.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by mort96 on Sunday July 07, 2024 @07:08AM (#40896720)
That's a funny way to write, "Oh thanks for pointing that out! I should've double-checked my facts before stating them so confidently."

Regardless, I forgive you.

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by timeon on Sunday July 07, 2024 @07:21AM (#40896794)
Do you often talk with just buzz words?
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by bowsamic on Sunday July 07, 2024 @06:56AM (#40896646)
How exactly did you decide that the concern was insincere?
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by asveikau on Sunday July 07, 2024 @10:22AM (#40897943)
Seems like you may be virtue signaling in the other direction?

I hate that term "virtue signaling". I most often see it when people simply don't understand the opinions of the other person. "It's impossible that you disagree with me, so I will accuse you of holding inauthentic positions".

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by rodgerd on Monday July 08, 2024 @12:51AM (#40902697)
Quack quack quack.

Perfect duckspeak.

Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by cedws on Sunday July 07, 2024 @07:11AM (#40896740)
She was paid for it.
Re:Malloc broke Serenity's JPGLoader, or: how to win the lot... by qingcharles on Monday July 08, 2024 @12:04AM (#40902521)
Did she? I know she stopped going to tech conferences, but I never saw anything about her saying she wanted use of the image to end?