I'm not sure I'd trust random wikipedia page to be up to date on this, but it's good evidence at least that there isn't a EU-wide prohibition on taking pictures of people (without publishing them) without consent. Also that there are some EU countries where it is likely illegal.
> Wikipedia has a table that claims your friend is wrong
"Consent required for action related to a picture of a person in a public place"
a restaurant is not a public space.
In this case, the person is outside and not on the property; if the restaurant wishes to be private they can take measures (curtains or blinds) but they’ve chosen not to.
This is where jurisdictions differ and is not cut-and-dry.
This implies restaurants. Another paper by the EU commssion regarding terrorist soft targets describes crowded spaces as public spaces as well.
Given all this, I assumed that some countries in the EU share this definition, and some don't. Because in the end it's up for each country to decide, and it's always a mess like that.
[1] https://allaboutberlin.com/guides/photography-laws-germany
Its actually silly how many people (in Europe at least) think they can forbid you from recording them “because copyright”.
You are being a dick by taking my picture without permission. That's what it boils down to.
If you walk up to a random European on the street and start taking photos of specifically them, they’ll get agitated real quick.
From the lawsuit: "Ein gezieltes Fotografieren von fremden Personen ist auch dann unzulässig, wenn die Verwendung ausschließlich privaten Zwecken dienen soll."
Translation via DeepL: "Targeted photography of other people is not permitted even if the use is exclusively for private purposes."
[1] https://www.landesrecht-hamburg.de/bsha/document/NJRE0014656...
It's not like Hamburg residents have the freedom to opt out of surveillance cameras. Even Street View is back.
I would hope that such cases would use rules around harassment instead of privacy laws for people in public spaces.
Fast forward to the age of the smart phone. The expansion happened so fast, for so many.. and with the marketing commercials and endless hype on using the phone to take "fun vacation photos" or whatever, and the explosion of Facebook uploads with "friends at a party" .. that social contract changed rapidly. New adoptors are often under 25 years old, and may not have heard of this formal signed consent form.
Now, mass facial recognition at public events is "no big thing" ? Everyone has heard in California from someone that "privacy is dead - get over it" ? Then, covid-19 and masks. Now lots of people wear masks on the street or on public transport, with questionable effectiveness over disease prevention, but is that the only reason? Young thugs dudes certainly wear masks with hoodies every day here..
This situation is not settled and still evolving.
EDIT: Changed my comment because I decided I’m probably out of touch and I thought the tone of what originally wrote came across a touch more aggressive than I intended.
Before covid, there was the stereotype of criminals wearing ski masks. It would make sense if you were doing a serious crime and expected to be caught on camera. It did require you to commit to looking like a criminal. Now, you can just wear a medical mask, walk down the street, you can’t be identified, you aren’t blatantly criminal-looking, but you can opportunistically do a smash and grab or whatever without worrying about your face being seen.
https://giphy.com/gifs/justin-g-grr-fists-grrr-l0NwOkgTYRi30...
Yeah, no. Amazon wouldn't drop your package in a public area. That only happens in North America and very weird.
Europe is not an entity. Every country has a different legislation and it's complicated. Some countries allow dashcams some don't because the lack of consent. Germany is one of the countries doesn't allow this, do police would ask you to turn it off if they see one.
What's infuriating is North Americans talking about "what's happening in Europe". It's equivalent to thinking abortion is banned and heavily persecuted in whole North America. Is what's happening North America really true?
>Yeah, no. Amazon wouldn't drop your package in a public area. That only happens in North America
In London, Amazon drivers will happily dump your parcels on your door step on full view of the road. Some slightly more considerate drivers will attempt to hide them behind a bin or flower pot. Some will put them in the garbage bin, sometimes on collection day.
European (Polish) here.
Saying that all of Europe is privacy conscious is like saying that the entire US is extremely republican and never gets below 40 degrees Fahrenheit; there are a few states that fit this definition, but that's not the entire country.
You have countries like Germany on one hand, where taking photos in public places is heavily restricted, you can get a ticket if the police find a dash cam in your car, quite a few organizations are passionate about avoiding Microsoft and hosting their own solutions, and a significant percentage of the population has Signal installed on their devices. On the other, you have countries like Poland, where everybody uses Facebook Messenger, nobody uses Signal, door and dash cams are perfectly legal, privacy isn't really that much of a concern, and photo laws are quite a bit less restrictive.
We're both in the EU, we're neighbors actually, we both have to follow the GDPR, but the mentality and approach is very different.
Over here, GDPR is mostly seen as "another stupid law that Brussels came up with and that makes things more difficult than they ought to be", not so much in Germany.
A completely separate concern, unrelated to privacy, is how photo copyright is handled. In the US and some European countries (like Poland), taking photos of public buildings is legal, and you generally own the rights to those photos. In other countries, the owner / architect of a building, who owns the copyright on the design of that building, may disallow taking pictures of that design.
In some places, the restrictions on photos stem from that different stance on copyright, not from any privacy concerns.
Your friend was not quite right, but in general it's very poor form to photograph strangers in Germany, when it's not simply illegal. People will walk up to you and scold you.
If you host an event, you usually ask for permission before sharing pictures. At the very least, if someone asks you not to share pictures with them in it, you're expected to oblige them.
A while ago I needed a picture of a Späti to explain what they are to my readers. The owner walked out and asked me what I was doing. I didn't need his permission, but it was a surprisingly tense encounter until I explained my motives, showed how the picture would be used, and how he was not in it.
I wholeheartedly support this culture of privacy.
Then we had a fascinating discussion about how photos without consent are outlawed. And, how video cameras are outlawed in public places. You cannot put up a camera outside your house to watch for Amazon packages.
I was really struck by the "news" I get about Europe. I hear incessant discussions about GDPR, which is a very abstract thing about collecting data. I'm for it, I think, but it is abstract. If I ever heard a reporter saying "You know, in Europe they are having a very different conversation about people taking pictures of your kids without your consent" well, damn, I would be very excited and interested in that article.
The fact that I don't read those articles makes me think my "news" is very controlled by social media companies, or should I say, anyone who has business in making sure data collection is unimpeded, which means Google, Facebook, probably Amazon.
Is my friend wrong? Is this more complicated? Or am I right that the discussion of what happens in Europe is framed in a way that keeps me uninformed about what is really possible?