News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:James Joyce Was a Complicated Man by Loughla on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:43PM (#40833782)
All joking aside, there is a lot of literature that really needs to be spoken to be grasped.

I learned this in college taking a middle English literature course. The Canterbury tales really need to be read out loud. They have a cadence that needs to be spoken.

I would actually argue that Joyce is in the same category. His work isn't meant to be internal. It's storytelling in a group and meant to be spoken. It helps understand the DENSE writing.

Re:James Joyce Was a Complicated Man by dataphyte on Saturday June 29, 2024 @06:57PM (#40833860)
So many (snooty) people treat audiobooks like a cheap substitute for reading, when in reality, reading is the cheap substitute for oral storytelling. Sure, you've got Infinite Jest where page structure and end notes are part of the aesthetic design, but I think more people would consume more literature if audiobooks were more normalized.
Re:James Joyce Was a Complicated Man by complaintdept on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:34PM (#40834060)
Problem being that most literature we have today was written with a reader in mind, not a listener.

I don't even think audiobooks are necessarily bad, it's people consuming them like a hamburger while they multitask so they aren't even really engaging with the text. Let alone not really having the ability to stop, think and relisten very easily. With a text you do it basically automatically if necessary, with an audiobook you've got to fumble around for your device and hope you get back to the right spot and not break your train of thought in the process.

Re:James Joyce Was a Complicated Man by sourcepluck on Sunday June 30, 2024 @05:39PM (#40840592)
Audiobooks are a cheap excuse for oral storytelling. People listen to audiobooks as they sculpt their muscles in the gym, as they walk to the shop to get groceries averting the eyes of all strangers who pass by, as they fold laundry, alone.

Oral storytelling used to happen in small intimate groups around fires with a couple of lamps lit, total silence, wind howling, drinks and sometimes other delights, with no conceivable distractions. Even saying "no distractions" isn't accurate, as it was moreso the case that they'd a completely different conception of time. The stories would be told live by another human, with their voice and body and eyes looking at you.

Reading is different than oral storytelling - it doesn't pretend to be the same thing, at least not anymore. Creating a hierarchy between the three is, I find, a bit odd, in general.

Re:James Joyce Was a Complicated Man by suzzer99 on Saturday June 29, 2024 @07:26PM (#40834011)
A lot of literature and pretty much all poetry imo.
Re:James Joyce Was a Complicated Man by atombender on Sunday June 30, 2024 @09:55AM (#40837176)
This is also true of Homer, whose stories were meant to be shouted out to a large crowd.

A much later and much more obscure American writer, R. A. Lafferty, was deeply influenced by ancient Greek poetry and philosophy, and his prose is better understood if you think of it as being read loud to a large crowd.

Re:James Joyce Was a Complicated Man by sourcepluck on Sunday June 30, 2024 @05:25PM (#40840528)
I wasn't joking at all (but if I had been I'd nonetheless be very tempted now to refuse to put it aside).