News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by darby_nine on Friday June 28, 2024 @06:05PM (#40825780)
Genetics are a poor proxy for ethnicity. There are many who would even refer to the use of blood quantum (e.g. 23-and-me) to determine ethnicity as a form of race (pseudo)science.
Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by runarberg on Friday June 28, 2024 @08:06PM (#40826714)
I’m curious how they assign percentage to geographic location. For me it fails the sniff tests. Like how far back do you pick your line of ancestry (which has migrated all over the world) when you say stop and determine, this is the place 20% of my bloodline is from?

I imagine they do some sort of cluster analysis to find correlation along with self-identification. If so, then this is undeniably junk science based on junk-in junk-out statistical models (which is often the case with cluster-analysis).

I’m simply curious here, cluster analysis is the only method I can think of (other than guessing/categorizing arbitrarily).

Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by thrownv7032g on Friday June 28, 2024 @09:59PM (#40827319)
I'd think bones from a couple hundred or thousand or ten-thousand years ago would provide a okay trail.
Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by runarberg on Friday June 28, 2024 @10:48PM (#40827526)
I don’t think the ancestry tests compare the DNA with archeological finds. If they did I wouldn’t trust it given the relatively small sample size of archeological finds with intact DNA.
Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by setopt on Saturday June 29, 2024 @05:47AM (#40829025)
The usual tests certainly don’t. But some scientific studies do: https://www.nature.com/articles/ncomms15694
Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by runarberg on Saturday June 29, 2024 @11:38AM (#40831324)
I thought those were done to investigate migratory patterns, movements, and inter-connectivity of historic populations, not to establish ancestral lineage of living population, and certainly not to assign a geographical region to existing ethnic groups.
Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by klipt on Friday June 28, 2024 @10:20PM (#40827426)
Yeah I think it's clustering and dimensionality reduction. E.g. if French people form a rough cluster in DNA space and Japanese people form another cluster, someone with a French mom and Japanese dad would show up as a data point roughly halfway between those two clusters.
Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by runarberg on Friday June 28, 2024 @10:44PM (#40827512)
I went on a little Wikipedia expedition hoping to find the methodology (and failed), but I did find an interesting (though not surprising) quote from one scientist (Adam Rutherford): “[These tests] don’t necessarily show your geographical origins in the past. They show with whom you have common ancestry today.”

So when our thread’s ancestor (pun unfortunate) says “45% Levantine” they mean they 45% of people alive today that are from that region (which includes many European immigrants). I bet this gets very messy given immigration patterns. Like which immigrants count as ancestry sample, and which don’t? For this problem I would personally use cluster analyses, however I would probably simply give up, knowing that cluster analysis would give me junk (and ultimately arbitrary) results with such noisy (and potentially skewed) data.

Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by Gormo on Saturday June 29, 2024 @04:43PM (#40833233)
> I imagine they do some sort of cluster analysis to find correlation along with self-identification.

I don't think it's "some" -- I think that's 100% of it.

Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by Amezarak on Friday June 28, 2024 @06:19PM (#40825907)
My understanding of ethnicity on a genetic level is basically that it's the degree of relatedness above "clan", e.g., you have something of a hierarchy from: individual > family > clan > ethnicity. What's the issue with declaring some sufficiently high degree of relatedness ethnicity? Or is relatedness that diffuse not measurable?
Re:The Origins of Yiddish (2014) by gizmo686 on Friday June 28, 2024 @06:25PM (#40825961)
It is not that genetic simmilarity is inherently meaninglessness. Just that it is not a good proxy for the social concepts people are generally using it to talk about.