Yet it doesn't stop scammer at all.
I don't want that when I sell random stuff out of my house. I want to meet a random dude at a gas station, exchange cash, and never know anything about each other again.
France must be one of the last countries to still use cheques and they are often refused, but at least there is a reasonable threat for the account owners whose cheque would not clear.
This is what makes cashier's checks fairly scam-free if you know that.
(Also remember, this is about cashier's checks, not ordinary personal checks.)
Of course this does require that you make your buyer wait while you phone the bank (and possibly do this during bank business hours), get put on hold, etc. And deal with the social discomfort of so obviously not trusting them. And then the risk of what might happen afterwards once you discover they are trying to scam you -- do they just go away or do they get violent or something?
But if you tell them upfront that you'll be calling to verify the check when you meet, it's much more comfortable. Especially because if they're trying to pull the scam, they'll just give up and not meet in the first place.
(Oh, and obviously never accept extra payment and then separately refund a difference. That's scam avoidance 101. If they even suggest that, stop talking to them.)
If you're selling, you should always specify cash-only. Period, no exceptions. You can meet at a bank if you're nervous about having cash.
Some transactions are prohibited by cash (notably when you buy a house, but that would not be through a classified ad :))
They do warn you about scammers, and my feeling is that if they tried to filter out the vermin who say "my agent will arrive with a cashier's check to pick it up" the scammers would just find some way around it, and people would get a false sense of security to boot. Whack-a-mole games, in other words.
A site for discussion would be Discogs, where I've had almost nothing but great experiences: all nice, honest people. Maybe the fix for Craigslist would be to split into verticals, where a community could develop, something that's absent now.
What I don’t like is the emotional energy it takes to filter them out.
Feels like the time is ripe for something like that, too. I think you're right, that would really up Craigslist's game.
A coworker's son participated in a high school archery team as a sophomore, then lost interest. My coworker listed the equipment on Marketplace, but after a day his listing was flagged for selling weapons.
He requested an appeal: the school has a zero tolerance policy for 'weapons' but allows students to carry their archery gear. By this reasoning, the listing should be fine, but Facebook's reviewer disagreed and banned him from marketplace for life.
Craigslist on the other hand has generally been alright, although it is better to be a buyer than a seller. Most of the time I've had someone flake or ghost me they were a buyer.
The only way to use Facebook Marketplace to buy things is to purchase locally. Anything else is sheer insanity.
"In person, cash transactions ONLY, no shipping or trades. Scammers will be ignored. Prices are firm, please don't respond if you don't understand what that means - I monitor markets daily on (CL, eBay, Reverb, XYZ music sites), here are links to recent similar condition gear sold for $xxx more. Respond with a phone # and 2-3 times this week that work for you to talk or meet."
At my work some of our best employees (including myself!) were found through Craigslist. And as a hiring manager, CL ofter brings me better applicants than Zip Recruiter, Indeed, Idealist and other "mass application spam cannons" HR inexplicably favors that have made being a hiring manager a real PITA in the last 5 years.
I had a co-worker in the pas who met his wife on Craigslist.
Most people assume this happened via the personals/missed connection sections but apparently it was b/c he saw a comment of hers on the forum section, messaged her to say he thought it was funny and the rest is history.
I stopped selling on Craiglist b/c EVERY SINGLE TIME I posted something I immediately started getting the "hi! I'm moving so I'm going to send the movers with a check that includes their pay and the balance to pick up your item" scam.
At least on Facebook Marketplace, I can see who the person is, do they have a rating, do they know anyone I know etc etc.
As a side note:
For the Twitter folks, I've written a bunch of funny threads about selling things on FB and Craigslist that you can find here: https://twitter.com/alexpotato/status/1305311410579214336