They have driving assist that people still measure in 'number of times I had to grab the wheel'.
Larry/Sergei didn't create the Cybertruck
The kind of founders who knows shipping > waiting-for-perfection?
move fast and break things may be ok for social networks, but never ok for endangering the safety of others
to launch a 6th model of a marque, so well established, theoretically knowing a lot about cars, a model that dies when it gets wet, it's just embarrassing
If Tesla does manag to jump straight from level 3 to level 5, they have a chance to compete, but that seems unlikely. They also might move to level 4 and be able to expand level 4 coverage faster, but that still remains to be seen.
Waymo has years of experience with the other hard part of self driving taxis: actually picking up and dropping off people without a human driver.
Anti-musk partisanship frustrates me, but I suspect it is your fan-boy talking points that drive the downvotes of your comment
Technology progress is non-linear. Yes, Tesla is at L3 and Waymo at L4.
But, you completely missed the point of rate-of-innovation, which was why I made that as first point.
My GOOG holdings are 4x than TSLA. But in terms of who will deliver FSD at better margins, it's hands down TSLA. It's simple Math and Elon's obsession about cutting material costs & process to it's barest minimum. Waymo has no such discipline or culture.
FWIW - You definitely come off as as irrationally in favor of tesla, regardless of reason.
Nobody missed any of your points, they just don't agree with most them or believe the rest follow from your points.
Any driver that makes this kind of move is typically in the top 5%ile of driving skills. Yes, it's an asshole and slightly illegal move, but the level of intelligence that needs to be applied for this move is all you need to know about Tesla's advantages.
I have been extremely critical of Musk's reliance on only cameras, but I'm impressed with the progress they have made because of the new architecture in 12.x series. Considering it'll be trained with 100x more compute, I'm willing to bet that Tesla will overtake Waymo's capabilities.
Yes, it's a speculation and you can disagree, but unless proven you can't tell it's wrong
It was luck that the left lane was moving and that there was space. I don't want to see this kind of move from a driverless car.
A skilled driver always makes the smooth transition into those gaps. I know most HNers are goody-rule-followers and can never appreciate the skill required to make that maneuver consistently. But, this is a clear example of separation of intelligence / skill and I'm happy with the bet that these are signals of intelligence
What you call first-principle-thinkers, the rest of the world calls dicks. Everybody sees that manoeuvre, it doesn't require a genius. Most of the people don't do it because they are afraid of repercussions (if they get caught) or are civilised enough to realise that their time is not more important then the time of others. Yes, that manoeuvre doesn't "save you 5 minutes", it steals 1-2 seconds of everybody else's time.
Just read this https://fooledbyrandomness.com/ConvexityScience.pdf
From fig (1)
Waymo/ HNers : Knowledge Edge
Musk : Convexity Bias
That's why Musk's approach will win. Waymo will no doubt provide a safe, rule-following driving experience, but Tesla will have frontier breakthroughs and provide more human-like, adapting and sufficiently aggressive driving experience
So Tesla will necessarily converge to the performance of your average driver, because that's where the data leads it.
Waymo's is developing a new type of understanding and modelling of the world. It perceives and tracks items above the capability of humans to track and understand. Therefore its limits are outside of the bounds of the most capable human drivers.
Your own argument highlights exactly why Tesla's approach is a dead end (exactly in the same manners that LLMs will lead to the dead internet), while Waymo's approach will likely generate super-intelligence.
Hard disagree.
It's pretty clear the car just didn't understand what the line of cars was doing.
> level of intelligence that needs to be applied for this move
If you were a human making this move, I would judge your intelligence as below average.
Every idiot can drive like an impatient asshole. Choosing not to do is is the true sign of intelligence. The car is literally driving itself at this point. What does getting there three minutes faster so you can doom scroll Instagram from the lobby instead of doing that while your car is driving itself do for you? Are you more important than everyone else and thus deserve not to wait your turn?
If it helps, Waymo's will run red lights, so it's not like Tesla's got a monopoly on being a bad driver.
How is the "rate of innovation" higher but yet they've innovated less and have a less functional product? It's made up metric and was ignored because it adds no value to the conversation unless you have some actual data.
from Fig 1: https://fooledbyrandomness.com/ConvexityScience.pdf
Waymo (and most HNers) : Knowledge Edge
Musk / (Billionaires hated by HNers) : Convexity Bias
Tesla isn't even comparable to Waymo at this point because Tesla has zero level 4 capability. Teslas don't even have the redundant sensors needed for level 4+. All Tesla has is empty promises and an u unclear path for ever getting past level 3.
The cost of delivering Tesla FSD = 1/10 * cost of delivering Waymo FSD"
This seems like one of the key assumptions, but is not proven out at all because Tesla does not even have a level 4 vehicle. So the cost of delivering one comparable to waymo is infinite right now!
Your other key assumption is "Waymo can never get to the scale of Tesla (it can never buy 5 Million FSD cars, while Tesla is delivering them every 2 years)".
Both the assertion in the first part and the second part seem like super-strange assumptions, and not obviously true at all, yet are also critical to your analysis.
Waymo could get to the scale of tesla. It may or may not be too expensive to do. It could in fact, buy 5 million FSD cars. It may or may not be too expensive to do.
"Mathematically, Tesla has an upper hand over Waymo and it'll play out as that."
Or you know, if needed, Waymo could change?
It's funny to watch someone say "this one company will be able to adapt in every possible way to it's advantage, and nobody else can or will"
That almost never happens.
Your retort is then that you are getting downvoted because of anti-musk hate.
Have you considered that maybe you just don't have that good of an argument instead, and that your comment comes off as more of a tesla fanboy (regardless if you are) than a useful contribution?
I could write the literal opposite comment of what you did, in favor of Waymo. That would not be a useful contribution either for the same reasons.
Why not? They only do the integration, and traditional car and electronics manufacturers have solved the scaling problems long ago.
cost of Tesla FSD hardware add-ons : $5,000
Tesla benefits from vertical integration, which is super important in the innovation phase.
I'm still coming to this from an unbiased perspective. Personally, I'd be a lot richer if Waymo wins the FSD race.
The rate of innovation at Tesla > Waymo
The cost of building Tesla FSD = 1/100 * cost of building Waymo FSD
The cost of delivering Tesla FSD = 1/10 * cost of delivering Waymo FSD
Tesla has economies of scale. Waymo has all the details figured out. Waymo can never get to the scale of Tesla (it can never buy 5 Million FSD cars, while Tesla is delivering them every 2 years)
Mathematically, Tesla has an upper hand over Waymo and it'll play out as that.
Larry, Sergei are extremely poor capital allocators. Musk is brilliant (despite him being a narcisstic a*hole).
Larry/Sergei left Waymo at a limbo state because they don't think in terms of economics, just coolness.
Waymo is successful enough to not kill it, but also not a cash-flow positive to scale it up
Edit : Tch, Tch expected HN anti-Musk hate showing up in downvotes.