Re:Why we must seek a widely-applicable Science of Systems.
by bokoharambe on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @10:46AM
(#40789322)
I feel like the real problem here is the way that research has to be sold in order to get funding (I assume the same was true in the 1960s). There is no inherent harm in trying to find a universalizing science, but market imperatives drive the creation of intellectual hypecycles with the associated booms and busts. That can then discredit entire fields.
Re:Why we must seek a widely-applicable Science of Systems.
by hdarshane on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @09:34AM
(#40788450)
Thank you for your very interesting comment and the reading recommendation.
I agree with your general sentiment that chasing "wide applicability" or trying to force a narrative that xyz theory will explain xyz might be hugely detrimental.
I agree my post and many discussions about complex systems, specifically one in an evangelic-type light might be over-optimistic.
We definitely must approach all work on such a theory with careful attempts not to overhype it. My post was an attempt to lay out some interesting possibilities.
We must remain optimistic anyway but I will be more careful in this regard going forward. Thanks again.
I bring this up because I believe that at the time catastrophe theory was seen as a "widely-applicable science of systems". Or at least some practitioners tried to sell it as such. This point of view eventually soured to the detriment of catastrophe theory, which cleared out. I don't think this was a good thing: catastrophe theory (the study of the singularities of smooth maps and their consequences to dynamical systems) is an interesting topic with many remaining open questions. But it was seen as cringe that people were, e.g., using Whitney's classification of the generic singularities of planar maps to try to say something about predator/prey dynamics or whatever. Any claim about applications of catastrophe theory was infected with this stink, and so people lost interest in it.