> To my understanding this is what most transit networks do anyways, to prevent an enterprising user from modifying their balance on the card itself.
On those on which this was attempted that I know of, this synchronization is far from instant. I was wrong in my other comment, in St Petersburg metro it only takes two hours for a dumped and restored card to be blocked, but you can apparently do this indefinitely on buses and trams because they aren't (weren't?) networked: https://web.archive.org/web/20170323213524/https://habrahabr...
Maybe that's not clear: the turnstile needs to connect to a server to check the QR. Need to only have one server, so some turnstiles will be relatively far from it. Latency.
Sure, but is this a serious design pressure? I've been on a lot of EU train and trolley networks that have a POS terminal on the train for direct sales, which are already doing networking both for the card transaction and to issue the ticket.
(Again to be clear: I'm not saying a QR is better. But I don't think connectivity is a unique problem, since systems that use NFC without tying into payment cards are almost certainly using connectivity to make up for the lack of tamper resistance.)
(The optical scanning argument makes sense, however.)