Peak usage times are obviously what matters for congestion
> I would argue it is a net congestion creator rather than congestion reducer
I think buses even outside of peak hours are usually net congestion removers... but if you want them to be congestion removers during peak times, you also need to offer service during other times.
Even triple the space usage, is leas than what you claim to observe. What is your methodology for determining this?
When you get a chance, follow behind one during a non-congestion period and count the cars that pass you in the other lane (meaning, your lane is slower) and estimate how many additional cars it would take to have the same speed of traffic (how many cars would need to be in your lane, instead of 1 bus, for the lane to be as slow?).
Imo everyone driving unpredictably to "get ahead" and save (literally, do the math) 1 minute on a 30 minute commute is what causes a lot of congestion.
Imo even if a bus took up 10 car spaces, the more predicable driving and slower accel/decel might still be a net positive for traffic flow.
Also, do you care about the state of traffic at off-peak hours? who cares if buses don't run at peak capacity when there's no traffic?
But like I said, triple the “physical space” the bus actually takes up and that is still less than their claimed “space consumption” of a bus.
And Waymos would need to also stop to pick people up as well…
Buses on regular roads create a "shadow" that affects other vehicles behind it and reduces 2 lanes in one direction to an efficiency of much less than 2 lanes, due to stops and starts. And except for peak usage times outside of a few major US cities, I would argue it is a net congestion creator rather than congestion reducer. A bus has the same effect as 10 or 15 cars, from my observation; so if there are less than 15 people on a bus, it's worse.
Part of the reason that buses have wraps or tinted windows is so you can't see how few people are riding on it.
At least the Waymo is not moving and not on the road when not in use.