News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Barcelona will eliminate tourist apartments by dang on Friday June 21, 2024 @05:27PM (#40754012)
Please make your substantive points without swipes (like "that's unintelligible" and "people like you").

This is in the site guidelines: https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html.

Edit: yikes, you've unfortunately been breaking the site guidelines repeatedly and badly—examples:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40743149

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40743095

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40743048

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40675193

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40673804

We have to ban accounts that keep doing this, so please stop doing this, and please make sure you're not using HN primarily for political or ideological battle.

(I suppose I should add the standard disclaimer that no, we don't care about your views. We care about your following the rules and using the site as intended, same as with any other user.)

Re:Barcelona will eliminate tourist apartments by zrn900 on Saturday June 22, 2024 @08:08AM (#40758474)
Under this post and in every single post you referenced, people are taking the largest swipes at entire countries, even peoples/races without any repercussions.

> please make sure you're not using HN primarily for political or ideological battle

All the threads you referenced are filled with people using the site in a political and ideological manner. There are people who are literally doing propaganda against entire countries and people.

> no, we don't care about your views

If you don't care about the views of the users, don't care about them in an egalitarian way. So far the rules seem to be getting applied selectively.

> We have to ban accounts that keep doing this

Feel free to do so. I'll get me coat myself. No need to contribute to a platform that not only does not care about its users' views but also applies its rules selectively and in an exceptionalist manner.

Re:Barcelona will eliminate tourist apartments by dang on Saturday June 22, 2024 @03:05PM (#40761301)
I'd need links to specific posts to say anything about them, but you're right that other people also break the rules. That doesn't make it ok for you to break the rules! It's not ok for either you or them to break the rules.

> the rules seem to be getting applied selectively

Every commenter with strong passions feels this way, that the mods apply the rules selectively and must therefore be on the other side. The people you disagree with are just as sure that we're secretly on your side. I say that with confidence even though I don't remember anything about your views at this moment, nor which side any of you are on.

The reason is sample bias. Everyone notices other people breaking the rules—we just notice different cases. What we notice is governed by what we dislike [1]. We assign the most meaning to the cases that feel most unfair or offensive to us. Since everyone selects these based on their own feelings, opposite feelings lead to different samples and opposite conclusions.

When you see a post that ought to have been moderated but hasn't been, by far the likeliest explanation is that we just didn't see it. We don't come close to seeing everything that gets posted. Also, I'm the only moderator who responds publicly and I can only write so much, not just because I have other responsibilities to worry about, but also because if I make even a slight mistake, it can (and often has) made a situation worse. It's a little bit like writing software in, I don't know, Agda as opposed to JS or something. You can't do it as fast or as much.

Which posts I respond to vs. not is determined by two factors: (a) what has been brought to my attention by others; and (b) randomness. If you or anyone sees a post that ought to be moderated, you can bring it to our/my attention by either flagging it (see https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html#cflag for how), or in egregious cases, by emailing [email protected].

Moderation can't be consistent in any way that would require reviewing all posts, but it can be relatively [2] consistent as long as we work with random-enough samples and handle them in a principled-enough way. That's what we aspire to. We're not perfect at it, but we do have years of practice.

This works well enough to signal to most of the community that (a) HN is moderated in the first place, and (b) that it's moderated reasonably fairly [3]. But it leaves many cases that don't get moderated all, and this means there are plenty of data points which people can select to draw whatever conclusions they want to about HN moderation—and believe me, they do!

We've all had this experience in other contexts. Take cops and speeding tickets. There's always a "why me?" reaction when you get pulled over. Plenty of other cars were speeding faster! The cops must have ulterior motives for picking on me [4]. Even if my brain knows about random samples, the feelings still work this way. Another example is sports and referees. The passionate fans are the quickest to feel that the refs are making calls unfairly, and it always feels like the calls are unfair against your team.

One last point, in the unlikely event that you read this far... when I said "we don't care about your views" I did not mean to belittle them or to imply that they're about something unimportant. On the contrary, the divisive topics are extremely important—far more important than most things that appear on HN. I just meant that we don't (or at least try our best not to) consider your views when making moderation calls. And of course by "you" I don't just mean you personally, I mean everybody.

---

[1] https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

[2] I say 'relatively' because this is a complex problem with lots of failure modes, but they don't change the important point above.

[3] Wait, didn't I just contradict myself, after talking about all the users who feel we're unfair? No, because those feelings are driven by the passions of the perceiver. The more passionately someone feels about a topic, the more that dynamic kicks in. Since most of the community doesn't have strong passions a given topic, the same moderation approach works to reassure the majority while at the same time convincing the passionate partisans of all opinions that the system is specifically biased against them.

[4] And maybe they do? This argument doesn't prove there's no bias; it simply shows that even the most unbiased system would produce strong feelings of bias no matter what you do.