News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by roenxi on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @11:08PM (#40724367)
If we're aspiring to 1970s standards then sure. Nuclear power isn't about achieving the lofty heights of the 1970s. I'm just going to wave the famous article by Crawford on the economics of nuclear around: https://rootsofprogress.org/devanney-on-the-nuclear-flop [0]

What you can see there is a very impressive learning curve that was well on the way to very cheap electricity. Then it suddenly and sharply inverts in a shape that defies common sense. Then no-one else really builds any.

"Supporting nuclear" isn't supposed to mean splitting the atom at any cost. The point is if we would just stop regulating the industry into oblivion and let costs drop then it'd be a perfectly competitive form of power. We have this lobby that goes in, wrecks the economics of nuclear then uses the wreck they created as justification for why we can't build any more. And in some senses that is fair because if they had the power to destroy past nuclear projects they can do it again. But lets not pretend that these costs are fundamental to nuclear.

Keeping a weather eye on China, if they do their usual trick and start learning how to build nuclear cheaply they could leapfrog everyone else on energy tech in another industry. On the one hand that'd be fantastic to the point where I'd love it. On the other it is so frustrating to be relying on nominal communists to push the state of the art forward on energy technology after listening to my western compatriots whinge about exactly that topic for decades while blocking the obvious solutions. We could have built the future in the west, we never had to have a do-it-in-China policy.

[0] If you read the article, he's paraphrasing some book by someone called Devanney. I'm going to gamble on nobody reading the article so I can get that wrong without being corrected.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by defrost on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:13AM (#40724734)
> Keeping a weather eye on China, if they do their usual trick and start learning how to build nuclear cheaply

Well, that ship has apparently sailed already:

How innovative is China in nuclear power? (1 day ago | 173 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40703088

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:35AM (#40724858)
this is a great find, thank you, but keep in mind that 81% of the prc's new electrical generation capacity last year was wind and solar; 16% was fossil fuels, 2% was hydroelectric, and ½% nuclear. so while they're certainly going to do their best with nuclear, for the foreseeable future they're moving rapidly to solar

https://climateenergyfinance.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/...

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by defrost on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:48AM (#40724938)
How about we keep in mind that they're doing both, in parallel:

    China intends to build 150 new nuclear reactors between 2020 and 2035, with 27 currently under construction and the average construction timeline for each reactor about seven years, far faster than for most other nations.
with a clear stated long term planned intent for a target mix of solar+nuclear.
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:04AM (#40725039)
yes, but the nuclear ingredient continues to be insignificantly tiny. 10 new nuclear reactors per year is maybe 20 gigawatts per year. they installed 216 gigawatts of solar capacity last year, and that's a number that's rapidly increasing. i think the reason they're building nuclear plants is the same reason so many nuclear plants were built during the cold war: to build nuclear weapons
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by defrost on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:14AM (#40725077)
yes but, they're doing both, in parallel.

Currently coal still accounts for nearly 60% of China's electricity. The vast bulk of global solar production comes from China and the bulk of that production of solar panels is being carried by coal power underpinning the required energy demands.

Go on, say solar again.

Act like I have no idea and that saying solar again will change something about the current state of China's energy supply and demand, their plans for the future and my current understanding of those plans.

> i think the reason they're building nuclear plants is the same reason so many nuclear plants were built during the cold war: to build nuclear weapons

There's also having consistent reliable baseload power for 24|7|365 day industry and personal use which they intend to achieve with a lot of solar and somewhat less nuclear.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @02:11AM (#40725341)
solar ;)
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by Herz on Friday June 21, 2024 @07:58PM (#40755057)
Well, 216 GW of solar is in no way comparable to 20GW of nuclear. Capacity factor much higher, much more reliable + no storage needed.

What's more, Chinese nuclear power is sometimes also used to heat homes. https://www.globaltimes.cn/page/202211/1278469.shtml

If you want to make an intellectually honest comparison, this is the reality.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by audunw on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:15PM (#40733397)
This is kind of scary considering Chinas huge variability in quality assurance. I’m sure they can build with great quality most of the time. But it only takes one bad project to set the whole world back another decade or two when it comes to nuclear energy.

Yeah, I know it’s not rational. Doesn’t matter. Humans just are not all that rational. People will shun nuclear no matter how safe you assure them that your reactor is if there’s one big catastrophe somewhere.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by roenxi on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:44AM (#40724913)
Who cares? If solar is cheap people can build solar. That isn't a particularly controversial idea. When coal was cheaper coal plants got built, when gas was cheaper people built gas plants. When solar is cheap we can build solar farms.

The issue is that nuclear has the potential to to shift society's energy costs 2+ orders of magnitude cheaper and we're explicitly retarding its progress by policy. Apparently only because of irrational beliefs.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:03AM (#40725032)
hmm, so, if i get a 360-watt solar module for 30 dollars and set it up someplace with a 30% capacity factor (like in the north of argentina where it's sunny) it will produce an average of 110 watts, which is 950 kilowatt hours per year. if i demand a 10% return on my investment, i'm getting 950 kilowatt hours for 3 dollars, which is 0.3¢ per kilowatt hour

this is already better than wholesale electrical prices, which average about 4¢ per kilowatt hour, but of course that involves all kinds of auxiliary equipment and batteries and whatnot. so let's assume generously that you're saying that nuclear energy has the potential to produce electricity for a wholesale price of 0.004¢ per kilowatt hour, which would be 2 orders of magnitude cheaper

why would you think that it has that potential? you cited crawford and devanney, but they don't say anything that even suggests that they think that. at the extreme they think that you can get those same 360 watts from nuclear power for 360 dollars. what are you basing your estimate on?

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by roenxi on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:14AM (#40725076)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_density#In_nuclear_reac... - the difference in energy density from coal to uranium alone is absurd, let alone if we have some breakthrough that taps in to a more exotic substance. It isn't that much harder to mine these fuels, the only problem is that we haven't really squeezed down the cost of building those honking great plants and focused on making the whole supply chain cheap. We're talking potentials like 6 orders of magnitude improvement over coal (which is currently competitive enough to run an industrial society).

We should be giving the nuclear industry as many opportunities as possible to achieve breakthroughs, not limiting it.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @02:08AM (#40725330)
yes, clearly that is correct when it comes to spacecraft, where what matters is energy density; voyager 1 would not be transmitting to us today if it were powered by kerosene or solar panels.

but, here on earth, operating power plants is generally not an expense in proportion to how much their fuel weighs. only about half of the cost of a coal power plant is the coal; the other half is the plant, with its spinning electromagnets, parsons turbines, deionized supercritical steam circuit, cooling towers, and so on. as long as you're using nuclear power as an alternative way to drive steam through the coal-plant machinery, the best you can do is knock the cost down by a factor of about 2, which is 0.3 orders of magnitude rather than 2+

also, by the way, if you can come up with a heat engine that's cheaper by one or more orders of magnitude, you can compete with photovoltaic power plants using not just nuclear energy but also concentrating solar and geothermal. that would be a huge boon

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by roenxi on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @02:28AM (#40725436)
> but, here on earth...

Well, yeah. If you assume we keep doing everything the same as we do right now, we'll get similar results to what we are getting right now. You've put your finger on the core issue with that paragraph, but I suspect not in the way you intended.

What you're not dealing with is that the likelihood we figure out alternative ways of doing things is extremely high. Or it would be if we didn't have a brain-dead regulatory state in the West that blocks us from doing things differently. We're talking a fuel source where we can fit the energy equivalent of 10 trains of coal into an 2L ice cream container - assuming no improvements from using Uranium. There aren't any laws of physics saying it has to be expensive to turn that into useful energy. We haven't really tested any part of the industrial supply chain to see how low costs can go. And any ideas the academics are having aren't being put in to the practice - or at least they weren't until the best and brightest over in China started getting involved. Hopefully it works out.

Not to mention that, as you point out, nuclear is also a technically superior form of energy in a bunch of specific applications where weight and volume are factors.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:28AM (#40725781)
i agree!
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by loeg on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:15AM (#40725083)
There's a big handwave at "an average of 110 watts." There will be periods where it generates 0. Does that line up with demand? How will you satisfy demand at night? Solving that is the majority of the costs of solar/wind. The cost of the panels is almost insignificant.
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @02:10AM (#40725338)
currently the cost of the panels and balance of plant, not batteries, is the majority of the costs of solar power. the panels have historically been about ⅓ and are edging up past ½ of the total. batteries are not insignificant but also not overwhelming. obviously the amount of battery needed is dependent on demand patterns

see https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40725765 for me trying to quantify this better

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by Retric on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @11:50PM (#40724611)
Just a FYI that article you linked is written by someone that doesn’t actually understand what’s going on they even say: “I‘m a little fuzzy on the economic model, but” And then say things that aren’t true.

The baseline cost of fuel rods alone ends up being ~0.9c/kWh. That already significantly eats into the margins before you consider the ~500 person workforce required to maintain such a complex system 24/7 365. The physical degradation of equipment like pumps, turbines, and lightbulbs costs yet more money. Decommissioning again yet more costs.

People focus on the upfront construction costs because they are extreme, but even if construction costs were the same as a coal power plant nuclear electricity would still be quite expensive. Further, many things like the initial fuel supply get lumped under ‘construction costs’ but are better thought of as something else like operating expenses.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by roenxi on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:04AM (#40724676)
It is an argument based mainly on learning rates. He doesn't need to know any details about the economic model of nuclear; the observations are based on the economic model changing over time.

> The baseline cost of fuel rods alone ends up being ~0.9c/kWh.

I saw a quote from the 4th generation reactor wiki page (it came up while people were talking about China getting started on the build out of next gen of nuclear tech) that mentioned "100–300x energy yield from the same amount of nuclear fuel" as a potential advantage. People will figure out how to make fuel rods cheaper. We haven't really pushed the limits of this stuff.

Besides, even in the current climate 1c/kWh is still a great lower bound to aspire for. Possibly even that would be worth pushing through the political blowback for.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by Retric on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @06:25AM (#40726831)
Gen IV doesn’t mean anything specifically. No individual gen IV designs has every single advantage you see in any of those designs. You need to look at a specific designs in isolation as well as what trade offs are involved in that design.

“100-300x energy yield from the same amount of nuclear fuel”

That’s one of those things that sounds good in isolation, but ends up being more expensive. It’s just like CANDU reactors don’t need enrichment and can operate on natural uranium, but it turns out fuel costs drop by 20% when they started enriching the fuel.

Similarly LWR/HWR could make better use of their fuel if they could operate at higher temperatures, but that causes a world of other problems.

Unfortunately nuclear engineers aren’t dumb, they’re doing things for surprisingly solid reasons even if counter intuitive reasons.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:06AM (#40724690)
i'm not convinced that the fuel is inherently that expensive; plausibly a lot of that cost is unnecessary bureaucracy and antiproliferation costs. i think the killer is your point, 'even if construction costs were the same as a coal power plant'
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by Retric on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @06:18AM (#40726802)
Again when you dig into things some things are inherently extremely expensive like operating a lot of gas diffusion centrifuges.

You could cut fuel use in half if the thermal efficiency of nuclear increased to that of a combined cycle coal power plant. But having two water loops (or a liquid salt then water etc) inherently reduces the temperatures the second loop reaches compared to the primary loop. On top of this you want to stay well away from material limits for safety concerns. Net result the maximum Carnot efficiency is only like 45% and achieved efficiency is significantly lower than that.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @04:11PM (#40731933)
gas diffusion centrifuges are an excellent example; possibly, for example, silex will turn out to be orders of magnitude cheaper. the absolute thermodynamic limit for isotope separation is many orders of magnitude away from what is currently practiced. and of course if you run your reactors on thorium or plutonium you don't need isotope separation

interesting, i hadn't heard of igcc before

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by Retric on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @06:59PM (#40733300)
Yea, I don’t think things are hopeless here. What you mention might drop fuel costs by as much as 0.3c/kWh which would be a major step forward, but nuclear needs several such wins and it needs them quickly.

People aren’t going to ramp up construction until the economics change significantly and then you’re looking 6+ years out before anything comes online. Meanwhile investors are thinking what will renewables look like in 6-60 years from now? which makes such projects hard to justify without massive subsidies or at minimum locked in pricing for decades.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Thursday June 20, 2024 @05:30PM (#40743616)
60 years is way beyond the prediction threshold. in https://dernocua.github.io/notes/backward-exponential.html i calculated that we can produce 16 earth-surfaces of human living space in less than 30 years, using 0.3% of the mass of the moon

60 years ago was 01962, when moore's law hadn't yet been noted, most people were farmers, there was no energy crisis, global warming was a forgotten 19th-century speculation, nuclear energy was hoped to make electricity too cheap to meter, communism was widely believed to be more efficient than capitalism (and produce higher living standards, if you discounted the gulag), mass imprisonment was a defining characteristic of russia rather than the usa, global thermonuclear war was widely considered survivable, overpopulation was driving inevitably toward widespread famine because the green revolution hadn't happened yet, and electric generation capacity in the usa was starting its last pre-energy-crisis doubling

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by Retric on Thursday June 20, 2024 @06:34PM (#40744179)
The world doesn’t actually change that quickly. A great deal of energy infrastructure designed or even built well before 1962 is still in use. The hover dam for example was constructed between 1931 and 1936 for ~800 million in today’s money. It’s paid that off over time, but time horizons get really long. People had been evaluating that site for ~30 years before construction began and the project was authorized all the way back in 1928.

With nuclear you’re essentially betting that the plant will have an operating surplus long enough to both pay down the initial construction costs plus interest and be able to set money aside for decommissioning. If you predict the nuclear plant will be shut down 30 years after construction finishes that’s a deal killer. Further while people talk about construction timelines but projects start well before construction begins because you need to convince someone to pay for it. So you’re essentially looking out 40 years before the possibility of profit exists.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Thursday June 20, 2024 @07:35PM (#40744659)
the vast majority of energy infrastructure in china was built in the last 20 years. actually that was true in the usa in 01962 and 01972 as well. the world is changing much faster now than it was in 01936, when all we had to deal with was the rise of fascism, the end of the millennia-long gold standard, history's deepest recession, communist revolutions around the world, radical overhaul of the economic system in the united states, and the rapid adoption of automobiles and electricity. you probably think i'm being sarcastic but i'm not
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by Retric on Thursday June 20, 2024 @09:21PM (#40745244)
> the world is changing much faster now than it was in 01936

Hardly.

In most ways things were advancing much more quickly in 1936. Look at say medicine, cars, aircraft, physics, nuclear power, even computers and communication systems, and if anything things are currently slower right now than back then. In 1905 the fastest aircraft did 30 MPH and had troubles traveling 30 miles in bad weather, by 1965 we could fly ~1,000x as fast and that’s ignoring interplanetary probes etc. 1935 sat in the middle of that transition but fly somewhere today and there’s good odds you’ll be in a 30+ year old airplane with some new paint an arguably upgraded interior.

Walk into a Walmart today and ~99% of the stuff sold had direct equivalents 10 years ago. Most of it is minor improvements on stuff available 50 years ago. That really wasn’t the case in 1935.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Friday June 21, 2024 @12:20AM (#40746106)
it is true that if transportation speed is your metric, things are advancing much more slowly; even considering 01876 to 01936 physical movement sped up enormously, and it was widely felt that speed was the defining feature of the age. and progress in aviation, as in many other fields, basically stopped 50 years ago

but i'd say that the differences in computers and nuclear power up to 01936 were all zero since neither of them existed. and i'm not sure you're right about physics and medicine either

unfortunately i can't walk into a walmart (they pulled out of my country, which is in an economic crisis worse than any it's seen since, coincidentally for this discussion, the great depression) but i have two rebuttals here:

1. walmart sells starlink, alexa (echo), airpods, impossible burgers, apple carplay, cheap solar panels, and ring cameras, none of which existed ten years ago, and i think doesn't sell divx anymore. they sold cassette tapes in 02014 and don't anymore. they decided the live lobster tanks were inhumane and took those out too. a lot of locations also stopped selling cigarettes. and they no longer sell fish. or ar-15 and similar rifles. also 02014 was the last year you could buy polaroid film anywhere (though maybe not in walmart)

also, there are lots of products which were hobbyist or luxury niches 10 years ago and are now on sale at walmart. 3-d printers and google chromecast come to mind. oled tvs might be another example. you could argue that ring cameras are really just a webcam, but webcams you bought ten years ago weren't remotely controlled by a surveillance company

2. if you walked into a woolworths in 01936, 99% of the stuff sold there had direct equivalents in 01926. i don't have a woolworths catalog from 01936; the closest thing to hand is https://archive.org/details/1937-sears-christmas-wishbook-ca.... selecting 5 random pages (12, 44, 52, 83, 101, all counted from the beginning of the pdf) and 3 random items from each page we get:

- a 13½-inch doll with jointed arms

- the 17-inch version of the doll

- a 13-inch doll with closing eyes and rayon socks that says 'momma'

- a 10¾-inch-wide chalkboard with interchangeable educational chart cards with a whiteboard side for erasable crayons

- 10 coloring-book-like picture cards that come with a glue stick and colored sand to color them with

- 12 picture cards that come with six colors of sand instead of three

- a radio-controlled model train controlled by voice recognition (though i suspect the radio part may have been just as fake as the voice recognition part, because it says 'transformer included' but doesn't say it requires batteries, and also because it would have required several vacuum tubes to actually use radio control, and it cost less than the vacuum tubes)

- another 'remote-controlled' model train which is fairly clear that there's no radio

- a wind-up train

- a wooden men's suitcase covered in top-grain cowhide leather with a tray inside for toiletries such as a toothbrush and a mirror

- a similar suitcase for women

- another men's suitcase with split cowhide leather on a metal frame

- a 1-pound bag of extra fancy fresh mixed nuts (walnuts, pecans, brazil nuts, almonds, and filberts)

- a 1-pound bag of filberts

- a 5-pound bag of brazil nuts

this obviously isn't enough to conclude that 99% of the stuff in the catalog had direct equivalents in 01927, but i think literally every item in this list (generated by python's systemrandom object) did, which i think justifies the claim that probably at least 94% of it did. even electric model trains date from 1897, and hornby was selling toy versions from 01925

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by Retric on Friday June 21, 2024 @09:07AM (#40749225)
> differences in computers and nuclear power up to 01936 were all zero since neither of them existed.

Computers existed in 1936, they were mostly analog but still surprisingly capable. Unlike today where we’ve basically standardized on only using transistors things where rapidly evolving in serval directions at the same time including the use of vacuum tubes and electromechanical relays etc. Look at the evolution of say 3D graphics card pipelines and sure things are getting faster but we’re well past the peak period of innovation when dramatically different architectures where showing up regularly rather than just more processing power.

Nuclear power isn’t limited to electricity, we used to do things like paint watch dials with phosphors that lit up at night. Radioactive quackery had largely died down by 1936, but that in itself was a significant change as was the understanding of worker safety issues.

> starlink, alexa (echo), airpods, impossible burgers, apple carplay, cheap solar panels, and ring cameras, none of which existed ten years ago

Alexa was released in 2014, and it’s arguable how distinct it is from Siri (2011) etc. You’re basically defining new in terms of brands on that list.

Satellite internet, bluetooth earpiece, vegan burgers, cheap solar panels, internet security cameras were all available 10 years ago. Solar panels have gotten cheaper per watt, but in 2014 you could get a 10kW system for ~30k vs 26k today. Adjusting for inflation it’s a bigger price drop but breakeven times aren’t that different.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @11:41PM (#40724553)
it would be a perfectly competitive form of power by 01970s standards, but naval nuclear reactors, chinese nuclear reactors, and russian nuclear reactors are not regulated into oblivion and have not had their economics wrecked by lobbying. nevertheless, they remain more expensive and less economical than even fossil-fuel plants in both warships and china. conceivably capitalism could solve that problem (us defense contractors and chinese power plant builders are pretty tightly state-linked rather than free-market actors) but we don't have strong reasons for believing so

crawford here talks optimistically about building nuclear plants for 250¢ per (nameplate) watt. europe and india are already building solar farms for 60¢ per (peak, nameplate) watt, a cost that is dropping dramatically year by year. he does plot some plants being built that cheaply in the 01960s in the us, in inflation-adjusted 02010 dollars, but for some reason he doesn't comment on that, and he doesn't find anyone able to do anything like that in recent years; the 'building cheaply' he cites in south korea and india is 190¢–250¢ per watt. this suggests that perhaps either the inflation adjustment or the original cost figures are incorrect

solar does of course have a lower capacity factor than nuclear, but there are numerous countries where it's 30% or better, so 60¢ per peak watt is still less than 200¢ per long-term average watt. also 60¢ today is 41¢ in the 02010 dollars crawford is using: https://data.bls.gov/cgi-bin/cpicalc.pl?cost1=60&year1=20240...

i sympathize with crawford's leanings but even the most generous reading of his claims doesn't support the contention that nuclear can be built cheaply enough to compete with solar

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by XorNot on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @12:43AM (#40724908)
None of those watts are dispatchable though. A solar plant can't look ahead a month and bid a block of kWh on any given day with any confidence.

Solar and Wind in "price per watt" are meaningless when storage is not accounted for. In fact a huge chunk of their actual cost of power has to be buying contracts for the backup plants to provide the kWh they want to promise but may not be able to deliver (hence the true cost of a kWh from a solar plant is basically whatever it would cost a gas plant to produce it).

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by roenxi on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:51AM (#40725242)
The quality isn't the same, but price is its own reward. We'll learn how to shift a lot of industrial production around if the price goes low enough.

Watt-for-watt dispatchable is superior, but for half price there are probably a lot of uses that will turn out to be quite flexible. The energy markets don't appear to have quite gotten to the point where they handle that flexibility (prices keep dipping negative, which is unfortunate if you understand what that implies), but it is reasonable to expect that it is coming.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @02:13AM (#40725351)
yeah, negative lmps with solar is 100% perverse bureaucratic incentives. solar panels aren't like coal plants (or conventional nuclear) where they overheat if you stop drawing power from them, and take hours to heat back up if you ramp down their burn rate; they're perfectly happy to be left in the sun either open-circuited or (more safely) short-circuited, and can return to supplying grid power in literally nanoseconds
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by dev_tty01 on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @10:22AM (#40728597)
>We'll learn how to shift a lot of industrial production around if the price goes low enough.

Are you going to send everyone home on overcast days? What if production needs to run 24/7? Solar is a whole solution if and only if storage is solved on a massive scale. Even with adequate storage, it still isn't going to work in some parts of the world or during certain seasons.

In the end, I think we need a mix of energy sources and working to make nuclear cost effective is part of a practical low carbon energy future. I just don't understand the confrontational nature of the solar vs. nuclear argument. Solar is absolutely going to be a huge part of our energy future. Supplementation by cost-effective nuclear would be a great complement to solar. Nuclear costs might not ever get low enough, but we'll never know if we don't put serious effort behind the goal.

Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @05:50PM (#40732774)
yes, i completely agree; i'm skeptical that nuclear will make it in the next decades, but certainly it's worth continued research
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by kragen on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:07AM (#40725048)
you'd think it would turn out to be a huge chunk, but it turns out to be relatively marginal. also power producers bid on day-ahead markets generally, not month-ahead markets
Re:U.S. Senate passes bill to support advanced nuclear energ... by Krasnol on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @01:06AM (#40725043)
> Supporting nuclear" isn't supposed to mean splitting the atom at any cost. The point is if we would just stop regulating the industry into oblivion

Sounds to me like just that.

If deregulation is the only way you could make nuclear work in the 21st century, then it rightfully is on the way out.

> Keeping a weather eye on China, if they do their usual trick and start learning how to build nuclear cheaply they could leapfrog everyone else on energy tech in another industry.

Oh, China learned to do all kinds of things cheaply. They are famous for their tofu dreg and the catastrophes connected with this meme, which is a result of regulative negligence and corruption. I would question the theory that this model should become an example for the rest of the world and especially in technologies which are as dangerous as nuclear power generation.

But there are actually fantastic news coming from there with much lower risks where we could learn from:

https://cleantechnica.com/2023/02/06/renewables-in-china-tre...