News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by eatonphil on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:06AM (#40716297)
David Frum being a writer for a US magazine, it seems perhaps worth taking his snickering with a grain of salt.
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by addicted on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:20AM (#40716409)
Is there anything incorrect in what he’s said though?

It’s a few hundred character Tweet that has been reproduced fully. You don’t even need to know the author to assess the contents of the tweet.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by eatonphil on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:25AM (#40716462)
He took a pretty uncharitable view. Maybe BRICS is doomed of course. And I'm not particularly hopeful. But I'd rather hear perspectives either from both sides or from folks who I can trust as more independent.
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by addicted on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:45AM (#40716623)
Whether it’s uncharitable or not it makes specific claims that can be assessed by anyone with the slightest bit of knowledge about these countries.

Again, which claim is incorrect?

> Brazil's history of monetary stability

Does Brazil have a history of monetary stability?

> Russia's respect for property rights

Does Russia have respect for property rights?

> India's domestic tranquility

Is India’s domestic affairs tranquil?

> China's financial transparency

Are Chinese finances transparent?

> South Africa's investment opportunities

Does South Africa have great investment opportunities?

One could argue much of this really matters when it comes to economic growth for individual countries. But all these properties certainly matter when it comes to forming an economic alliance across nations.

Which is why BRICS has been almost completely worthless and to the extent these countries have had any effect together it’s through bilateral agreements.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by JumpCrisscross on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:00AM (#40716755)
Hell is where the chefs are British, the mechanics French, the lover's Swiss, the police German and it's all organised by the Italians.

We can do it for America, too: a union with Mississippi’s economy, California’s taxes, Alabama’s services and Kansas’s natural beauty.

This form is good for jokes but bad for analysis. BRICS could have worked if its members agreed on anything. They don’t, and there are better multilateral forums that don’t rely on the West that could be constructed in its place. (Starting with continental organisation.)

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by aamoyg on Thursday June 20, 2024 @09:17AM (#40738448)
Living here in Kansas, we have a lot of natural beauty as a plains state. It's not all flat either. We have badlands, Zion-like rocks, hills to hike on, and minimal intrusion to nature.

When it snows, all you see is a sea of snow everywhere, and in the spring it's a sea of prairie grass in the rural areas.

The cities are like Chicago and San Francisco had a baby in terms of the architecture and layout.

Our taxes are also higher than California if you are going by percentage (for property taxes and sales taxes, but not income taxes, except for food). California is "okay" I guess. They could do some tax reform, but it's a large state with some large programs and initiatives, so considering that, it's not bad. Additionally, Alabama has less than stellar in person services, but great online services. Mississippi is often troped as having not the greatest economy, but their economy is based on oil, and chemical processing, and fishing. They are also located in a hurricane zone. That means that they get hit hard all the time, and have to keep rebuilding infrastructure. That's not easy. They also get hit economically every time there is a chemical spill or an oil spill, cause the plant will shut down, and they cannot fish there either. We should probably open datacenters there.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by meiraleal on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:14AM (#40716874)
> Does Brazil have a history of monetary stability?

30 years and counting.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by boffinAudio on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:57AM (#40716725)
>Does Brazil have a history of monetary stability?

It does, now that its in BRICS.

>Does Russia have respect for property rights?

It does, now that its in BRICS. (ahem sanctions are a crime against humanity, yo.)

>Are India’s domestic affairs tranquil?

They certainly will get better, now that they're in BRICS and their people stand to gain a lot from the economic growth that involves, outside of the Western control that has put India in the position its in, in the first place.

>Are Chinese finances transparent?

Well, ask the other BRICS members: they are the ones who can say, definitely, yes. To Americans? No, of course not.

>Does South Africa have great investment opportunities?

They certainly do, now that they're in BRICS.

>Which is why BRICS has been almost completely worthless ..

.. to the Western Empire.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by soco on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:11AM (#40716863)
I can't even tell whether this comment is sarcasm or not. I mean, a rosy argument based on future guessing, wishful thinking and ignorance of the past (past of the BRICS, that is) must be sarcasm, right? I mean, yes it could end up all of that, like it could become just anything else on the 0-100 probability range. As long there's zero reason to claim such certainty today, I call b$ on it.
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by boffinAudio on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @03:19AM (#40725718)
Why do you think BRICS is happening in the first place? To address the 'problems' listed.

BRICS is a solution, not a problem. Its a solution to the 'situations' listed, but its also a solution to the fact that the USA has weaponized the petrodollar while committing heinous atrocities across the landscape.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by betaby on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:32AM (#40717059)
> Does Russia have respect for property rights?

Yes. I would say better enforced/respected than in Southern Europe (Italy, Spain, Greece) or Balkans.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by throw0101a on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:47AM (#40717194)
> Yes. I would say better enforced/respected than in Southern Europe (Italy, Spain, Greece) or Balkans.

I guess one simply needs to live on the ground floor or not have any windows in their high-rise apartment:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Suspicious_deaths_of_notable_R...

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by betaby on Thursday June 20, 2024 @03:33PM (#40742400)
I guess one simply should not work for Boeing while we are at it.
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by vidarh on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:33AM (#40717063)
Your list of questions is meaningless, because that is not what is worth taking issue with. What is worth taking issue with is the snide assumption that BRICS means the combination of those traits instead e.g. the best traits of each of those countries, or just the average traits of those countries.

That doesn't mean BRICS has achieved lots. It does mean that his snide comment has no merit with respect to saying anything about BRICS whatsoever.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by throw0101a on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:31AM (#40716489)
> He took a pretty uncharitable view.

Frum took an accurate view IMHO.

Unless you think that property rights (and window incidents) in Russia are not a problem, or that China already has good transparency in their economy… Do you think those things?

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by eatonphil on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:35AM (#40716533)
No I agree, it's just the attitude that seems concerning. Like it encourages not taking these countries seriously, and not looking hard enough at ourselves to see how we can do better too.
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by addicted on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:48AM (#40716653)
It encourages not taking BRICS seriously. Which is absolutely correct. BRICS as an organization is a joke.

The individual countries should be taken seriously. Which western countries finally have started doing over the last couple of years. The watershed moment was Russia’s attack on Ukraine. It finally dispensed with the neocon idea that they could spread free market democracies in Russia and China by simply trading with them.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by throw0101a on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:51AM (#40716670)
> Like it encourages not taking these countries seriously, and not looking hard enough at ourselves to see how we can do better too.

One can also take the countries seriously but the 'BRICS project' not-seriously.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by keybored on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:07AM (#40716308)
Or just taking it with a grain of salt since it’s David Frum. :)
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by skhunted on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:14AM (#40716358)
I’ve found the opposite to be true of him. Can you point to things he’s said that make you take him with a grain of salt?
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by eatonphil on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:18AM (#40716392)
Personally my gripe is not so much with Frum as with The Atlantic overall which has been consistently fear mongering.

There is certainly a lot of bad in the world but The Atlantic stance seems over the top.

The Conversation and Rest of World are two much more even magazines in my opinion.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by skhunted on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:40AM (#40716573)
I’ve never heard of The Conversation before. Just looked at an article. Here’s a snippet from the article

There’s both bad news and good news about climate change in the future.

The bad news is that as long as we keep burning carbon, it will continue to get hotter and hotter.

The good news is that we can substitute clean energy, like solar and wind power, instead of burning carbon, to power the products and services of modern life.

This is something I’d expect to see written in a 6th grade textbook trying to get past Texas’ textbook adoption committee. They pretend to give a nod to the climate change deniers by writing, “there’s good news and bad news..” with the good news being a non sequitor. One can use clean energy and strive for that regardless of whether or not climate change is real.

The website did seem much less alarmist than Fox News, CNN, etc.

Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by eatonphil on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:44AM (#40716610)
I'm not sure there is a staff. Post authors are academic researchers and PhD students around the world. I don't mean to say every article is good. I've just been impressed by what I've read so far.
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by skhunted on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @10:03AM (#40718011)
Yeah looking at one article is not a basis for a valid judgment. I did get the impression that it really is “left leaning” in a way to appeal to conservatives by coming across as non partisan. I’m a pseudo socialist so being left leaning is not an issue for me.
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by eatonphil on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:10AM (#40716331)
I was resisting criticism of him and The Atlantic this one time. :)
Re:Malaysia to Join BRICS by defrost on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:22AM (#40716426)
He's the Joe Rogan of Canadian born NeoCon's, former hype man and color commentator for both The Manhattan Institute for Policy Research and the Bush Jr. administration, ... put your hands together for David Frum!!