Re:Meta won't train AI on Euro posts after all, as watchdogs...
by stavros on Monday June 17, 2024 @06:57AM
(#40704310)
The conversation went like this: I asked why people are against AI training on their posts, some people said "because of copyright", I pointed out that Meta has a license from them to use the posts for anything, and now your post is "but the government can force them not to". Yes they can, but that wasn't the original question.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Meta won't train AI on Euro posts after all, as watchdogs...
by kolinko on Monday June 17, 2024 @07:23AM
(#40704468)
Meta, nor anyone else doesn’t have a license to do anything they wish according to EU law - we don’t have wildcard copyright assignments - you need to specify the fields in which a person grants the copyright. Exatly for the reason that when a new tech is invented, the original author may decide to not grant the copyright for that field, or grant it to someone else.
That is, each legally binging copyright assignment needs an enumeration of fields, like radio, tv, streaming and so on, and when a new field appears the copyright belongs to the original author by default. And statements like “in all fields current and future” are not legally binding.
There is no such thing as “people signed copyright to Meta so Meta can use it in whatever fashion”.
You can read an exercept of Meta’s ToS here - these ToS do not allow them to train models based on the content people publish. https://www.quora.com/When-I-post-a-photo-on-Facebook-or-Ins...