News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:NLRB judge declares non-compete clause is an unfair labor... by Xylakant on Sunday June 16, 2024 @10:21AM (#40697283)
In Germany, there are certain kinds of questions that are not permissible on an employment questionnaire, for example asking whether a candidate is pregnant or plans on having children, union affiliation, etc. However, these questions are often included in the questionnaire and not answering them would provide sufficient signal to the employer and the only remedy would be to sue the employer. So it's explictly permitted to lie in the answer, rendering the questions useless.

I expect a similar line of reasoning applying to this case: The question is about a protected, legal activity which is nonetheless undesirable for certain employers. Asking the question and requiring a truthful answer would undermine the protected, legal activity. Hence an effective remedy is explicitly allowing to lie in the response.

Re:NLRB judge declares non-compete clause is an unfair labor... by thegrim33 on Sunday June 16, 2024 @11:05AM (#40697606)
> "there are certain kinds of questions that are not permissible on an employment questionnaire" .. "these questions are often included in the questionnaire".

I don't follow. It's not permissible but these companies just blatantly ignore the law and ask it anyways? Or it is permissible?

Re:NLRB judge declares non-compete clause is an unfair labor... by Xylakant on Sunday June 16, 2024 @11:25AM (#40697741)
Those companies ignore the law - knowing that a candidate could sue, but then they would remove the canditate from the pool for any unrelated reason. A union could sue on behalf of a candidate, but until the case is resolved, the questionnaire still stands. Allowing candidates to just fill in the expected answer, truthful or not, is an effective remedy - it renders the question useless as a signal for the employer.
Re:NLRB judge declares non-compete clause is an unfair labor... by AdrianB1 on Sunday June 16, 2024 @12:19PM (#40698148)
In most of Europe there is no notion of punitive damages in a law suit. That means if you sue that company they will fix the questionnaire with no other consequences. 3 months later they can put it back, also without consequences. Suing them can be costly, so most people will not bother. There is zero reward for doing it, as a candidate you waste time and money with no net return. All negatives and no positives.

So with very little risk, they do it.

Re:NLRB judge declares non-compete clause is an unfair labor... by abhorrence on Sunday June 16, 2024 @11:14AM (#40697673)
Presumably they ignore the law.
Re:NLRB judge declares non-compete clause is an unfair labor... by louiskottmann on Sunday June 16, 2024 @12:41PM (#40698350)
It's not allowed, but you'd have to sue if you uncover one such questionnaire, which is a hassle.

So instead, lying on your answer is not sue-able. Which makes including such questions ineffective.

Re:NLRB judge declares non-compete clause is an unfair labor... by lazide on Sunday June 16, 2024 @03:06PM (#40699287)
It renders the questions useless against experienced candidates, but not against naive or ignorant ones. So it still has value to employers.

The best remedy to stop such things is a statutory ‘bounty’ for such activity - like the $2500 penalty for California employers for attempting to scare employees with unenforceable non-competes.