You say this like it's easy, but it's actually very hard for most white-collar jobs.
Is that guy who's closing lots of tickets just picking the easy ones - or fobbing off customers with unhelpful responses?
Is that guy who took two weeks to make a two-line change incredibly unproductive? Or did they explore hundreds of avenues to finally stamp out a bug that had stumped dozens of other engineers for months?
Is that guy who's overseeing an external project and hasn't raised any issues a veteran with the foresight and initiative to solve problems early, and the expertise not to need hand-holding? Or are they simply not looking for issues?
Is that guy reviewing grant proposals taking the time to carefully read through every last one and fully comprehend all the technical details? Or are they skimming a few then funding the famous researchers at the well known universities, same as last year?
For a great many jobs, the main form of monitoring is how productive the worker's line manager feels they are. An extremely flawed measure.
Between talking to your reports, auditing some small portion of their work, and reviewing historical data, you'd be able to answer all of your hypothetical situations with fairly high confidence. Certainly higher than just vibe-based feelings or how many keys were pressed per minute.
If the managers don't have super busy schedules, leaving them little time for "auditing work" and "reviewing historical data"
If the managers aren't managing workers who know much more than them, meaning they're poorly equipped to understand how hard a given task is.
If the managers have perfect vision into untracked work like prioritising tickets, helping people in other teams, interviewing, coaching new starters, performing code review, working on cross-team standardisation efforts and so on.
If the managers don't feel looking over people's shoulders or demanding webcams be turned on in meetings would seem distrustful and intrusive.
If the managers have time to keep track of everyone's health, wellbeing and equipment so when a spot check finds periods of low productivity it can't be explained away by a broken keyboard or wifi problems or having the flu that week.
If the managers think firing one person is guaranteed to let them hire someone better, with no hiring delays or freezes.
If the managers don't feel they're buddies with the people on their team, who they eat lunch with every day, and they have far greater affection for the corporation they work for.
And if the managers don't benefit from having a larger empire, incentivising them to respond schedule slips by hiring more people
Then yes, the manager could indeed address many of these scenarios.
Ha! That's a funny joke you hid in the middle of your comment.
What would be a justifiable (won't get me in jail) firing in your mind?
At least in the companies I worked with, KPIs are manager/lead level items and it is divided into tasks that is handed out to individual team member.
I admire the folks who have such quality KPIs.
And, yes, I’ve been forced to deal with others’ decisions to let folks go as well (primarily missing growth targets), but very rarely.
History is full of outrageous "agreements" by the powerful applied to the powerless, so there have to be labor laws that set an even playing field. Distributed work across legal jurisdictions is an opportunity to push those labor agreements and avoid consequences. On the other hand, there have always been cheaters among workers and that wont go away, either.
Modern technology has opened a pandora's box of constant surveillance that was not practical or even possible previously. There have to be new agreements on labor practices. It is a political problem. Compounding the urgency of this situation in an advanced economy is the looming implementation of AI to replace workers, and to enable a few workers to do the work of many, many more of the past. This time around, middle-managers are included in those that are replaceable, or perhaps even mid-level leadership i.e. "your boss is an AI"
Visit /r/overemployed on Reddit and you’ll find a large community of people teaching each other to do stuff like this so they can collect 2-3 full-time salaries.
a) the employees met all required KPIs and delivered well and were just meeting some dumb policy while actually being totally fine, and therefore shouldn't have been fired; or
b) the company has literally no way to tell if someone is actually useful and many of the people not using such devices could easily be far worse performaers.
In either case, firing someone based on this sort of monitoring or information should be illegal.