When you come on board as an employee, you’re just not in the same situation.
Why is Bob not in the same situation? They both are taking a financial loss in the hopes of having more valuable land to sell. Why shouldn't Bob have the same right to sell his portion of the land that Alice has?
>>Why is Bob not in the same situation?
In this specific circumstance, Bob agreed to an arrangement that contractually doesn't put him in the same situation. Hopefully Bob will learn from this experience and, if possible, negotiate better (or equivalent rights) instead of willingly agreeing to unequal rights.
Pragmatically, unless and until more workers are willing to take the risk to become founders themselves, the balance of power usually is in the founders' and investors' favour (i.e. capital).
They did not do that alone. If they had, there would be no employees to keep secrets from.
should the employees have a legal claim against the money that was taken in the secondary transaction?
It's wrong.
Startup employees, especially early ones, take on most of the risk that founders do. They take pay cuts. They work insane hours. They sacrifice.
And they have the same liquidity needs, too.
It's wrong to make them wait a decade for a fraction of the liquidity that founders got in the Series B.
It's wrong to force them to absorb the risk of the Series B, C, D, E, F, and IPO. All while the founders were set for life years ago.
If founders are going to take money off the table, they should extend the same liquidity offer, pro-rata, to their employees. Period.