I sent a Section 220 demand letter to the founders of this company to get transparency on the money that was taken during the secondary stock sale and they're currently fighting me on it because I wasn't a shareholder at the time the secondary sale took place, I only held options in the company at the time.
This anecdote is illustrating a real world situation in which it is being used as a way for founders to try to screw their employees, not because their hands are tied by some arcane tax law.
you aren't actually vesting stock month to month you are vesting your stock options. when you "exercise" your stock options you pay the company the strike price * number of options you want to exercise in order to purchase the actual stock in the company.
If the company has grown in value since you joined then you would have a taxable event upon exercising your stock options because you are buying the stock at the strike price, but the fair market value of the stock is significantly higher, so that is a taxable capital gain that you have to deal with.
Any sane company will give you a 10-year exercise window after leaving the company to actually pull the trigger and "exercise" your stock options so that you don't incur a tax liability but some companies only give you three months. Which means not only do you have to front the cash to "exercise" the options, but you also have to pay the tax liability on the capital gain of stock for that year.
If you're asking how you can possibly be expected to pay the tax on a million dollar+ capital gain, without ever even having access to cash or a guarantee you even will have access to cash in the future, then welcome to the scam that is being an employee at a Silicon Valley startup and the fucked up logic of the US tax code.
As the company with equity, any calls you’re selling are guaranteed covered, which hedges against downside loss of having given away equity and it exploding in value. Calls also theoretically align incentives better than equity because it gets the staff member personally interested in seeing the stock rise, rather than just selling immediately to take profit if they’re short your company’s future outlook.
Lots of other nice properties - If you sell the option, either discounted or at some full price, you make a money premium, which helps runway. If the stock falls, you make money from having chosen options and basically don’t have to give the employees anything. If the stock rises, you’re probably making great sums from your (much larger) equity share, and your losses versus just giving them equity are essentially capped at the difference between the current price and strike price, instead of theoretically unlimited cost. This is easily quantified with some multiplication when issuing the options, meaning in a growing company, you have knowably limited exposure, and essentially are just giving them the equity you would’ve given them anyways.
First of all, we're talking about pre-IPO startups, so you can't just sell the stock.
Second, talking about "company loses money because it gave equity to employees" is as non-sensical as saying "company loses money because it gave equity to investors".
You're not giving away equity, you're exchanging equity (at present value) for cash (from investors) or labour (from employees). They're both investors (investing either their money, or their time/skills), and by investing, they're taking ownership of any potential future gains or losses (and by letting them invest, the company is giving up that potential).
This is often but not universally true - about 40% of companies allow you to do so, and about 40% of those that allow you to do so allow those sales on secondary markets [1]
>company loses money because it gave equity to employees is nonsensical
You lose money in the sense that the gains beyond the strike price which you would have realized had you not sold the call option are your losses: you could’ve not sold the option and profited on that rise instead. You have lost the difference in the profit between these two investment plans.
> You're not giving away equity
I was responding to someone asking “why don’t they just give the equity instead as compensation?”, as opposed to writing call options against it - assuming that as a company you want to incentivize workers to work by setting aside some fraction of your equity which they may receive, these are the reasons a company might prefer to “give” employees that equity with options, instead of discounted equity or stock grants
[1] See page 8 footer of https://www.gsb.stanford.edu/sites/default/files/publication...
Someone is going to point out that giving actual shares is a taxable event. And that is sometimes the rational for options. But there are work arounds: you can put shares in a 401k for example. 401ks were originally created to be employee incentives, but morphed into being used for retirement, but you can still do it either way.
There is one exception: if you are high enough in the company that you actually know the non-public information as it happens (not either because you need to know or months later in the all-employee meeting). Then the shareholders demand you hold a lot of value in the company so that if you do something bad for the company it hurts. Most of us will never be that high.
However, employees often have virtually no net worth (why else are they worried about paying taxes on share, except they can't take the risk of loss? I can say from experience that when I worked for a startup but had previous personal financial success I just absorbed the tax bill for exercising options knowing that the shares I paid taxes on could ultimately be worthless.).
So if all their net worth is in a company its not ideal but it is a risk you can take when you are young. I see the argument of avoiding taxes and not taking ownership until the shares are liquid-- good arguments, it is true-- as being used as ways to justify giving employees shares or options that are likely to be less valuable then the ones held by founders and investors.
That same company eventually raised a sizeable equity round and then began issuing options for new employees. If they were to continue issuing equity grants, the cost to purchase the grant would be much more than $200 (likely tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars). Alternatively, if the company were to give employees equity grants directly instead of having to buy them then that would count as income and the employees would owe taxes on the equity gained. The tax bill could also easily be tens or hundreds of thousands of dollars.
Options avoid all of that and defer the upfront costs that come with an equity grant.
Imo, the real problem is that options can be clawed back once you no longer work for the company.
They can get options, they can get equity, they can get nothing (beyond salary).
Options are common probably because it gives (the company) more or easier control over what happens when.
they get options, not equity
personally, I never understood why they don't get actualy equity (in particular, given that the options are "fairly priced" i.e. the call price is the latest equity round price, making them worth literally $0!)
and that equity should have the same terms as investors get (no "liquidation preference" lol) because - guess what - you're literally exchanging your labour (== money) for them!