In isolation a sunset is physics, photography is chemistry and AI is math. Without the artist there's no real difference between an AI song and playing /dev/random. Only through human interpretation do astronomy, chemistry and math turn into art.
[1] https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/10.1177/13678779241252664
ie: https://suno.com/song/dfaa6a3c-ce91-4b71-a394-5b9232d00dc7
I can see why legit artists are concerned. (!)
Yeah, I'm starting to get that too already. :(
This argument makes sense to me for e.g. a novel, and is the reason why I wouldn't read an AI-written novel, all else being equal with human-written novels. But much of the music people consume is background music and requires no time investment at all.
For example, I play music while I exercise... give me a playlist that sounds good enough and it's upbeat enough, and it will be fine for the task.
@franze is that something you have control over - is the prompting so detailed / accurate that you can specify that? Or is there some other tool that can adjust an initial revision? Or is it simply a roll of the dice?
With suno there is a lot of difference between the models (v3 vs v3.5) and then it is a lot of sometimes pretty random style prompts and a lot and lots roll of dices.
It can get quite frustrating, i.e.: https://www.instagram.com/p/C7oeyGzt0jd/ its unfinished and I like it a lot - but I never got Suno to recreate this exact style again.
Can see why you like it.
But yeah, Suno managed to do a decent job setting it to a poppy beat that is well-suited to the poem
This one even asks the question, in german: "Is this art or can I throw it away?" (DE: Ist das Kunst oder kann das weg?")
Can AI music trigger real emotions or are they just artificial emotions?
https://www.instagram.com/reel/C79y1Dbst3l/?igsh=bDgzeGMxZTJ...
(And this one I call "If Poe had had a cat." https://www.instagram.com/reel/C79yC-rsywz/?igsh=MThzbDZvamV...
Title by me, everything else Chatgpt, Suno, Midjourney and ChatGPT again.)
So the big question is, can AI generate art? Can AI generate "real" music? Or is all AI music artificial music? Can artificial music create real emotions?
I love this topic. So much possibilities to challenge our understanding / appreciation of art and music.