Re:Discussions: Flat or Threaded? (2006)
by dvh on Sunday June 09, 2024 @09:30AM
(#40624314)
Phpbb is almost unreadable for me. What he's missing is persistently collapsible comments.
Say for example in this discussion someone mentioned internationalization which I don't care about with 50 replies. I collapse this comment and it's 50 children and this discussion is for me still very readable. It must be persistent because if I return in 30 minutes I don't want to collapse same posts over and over. I also collapse posts that I have read and I'm not interested in replies. This effectively makes me a moderator.
Subreddits protects website from off-topic posts. Nested collapsible comments protects posts from off-topic comments and tangents.
Re:Discussions: Flat or Threaded? (2006)
by plingbang on Monday June 10, 2024 @09:26AM
(#40633431)
And what makes it worse in phpBB and other forum engines is the waste of vertical space. 4 messages on your screen seems to be the maximum despite using smaller fonts than web average nowadays.
Say for example in this discussion someone mentioned internationalization which I don't care about with 50 replies. I collapse this comment and it's 50 children and this discussion is for me still very readable. It must be persistent because if I return in 30 minutes I don't want to collapse same posts over and over. I also collapse posts that I have read and I'm not interested in replies. This effectively makes me a moderator.
Subreddits protects website from off-topic posts. Nested collapsible comments protects posts from off-topic comments and tangents.