News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by sholladay on Sunday June 09, 2024 @12:02AM (#40621938)
So far, I have made use of my car insurance policy two times. Each time I regretted it. First was for a rodent that somehow got into the space between the roof and the headliner, then died and made a mess. The second was for hitting a pothole at highway speed, which damaged a wheel and its control arm.

In both cases, the insurance company paid the minimum they had to. For the rodent, sure they paid for the ceiling to be disassembled, fixed up, and reassembled. But did they pay for the interior detail that was necessary because of the rodent guts that had dripped from the ceiling? No, of course not.

For the pothole, they paid for the wheel and control arm replacement and even one new tire. But did they help me pay for a tire on the other side so the wear could be reasonably symmetrical? No, of course not. How about the alignment I obviously got, which isn’t strictly necessary but really should be done after such an incident and installing a new drive wheel? No, of course not.

Oh and they categorically consider hitting a pothole to be the driver’s fault, no matter the circumstances, so they raised the insurance premium on me. They made all of their money back within 18 months and now I’m still paying the higher rate.

Insurance is such a scam. The company makes a profit despite their team of employees because they always price the premium above your level of risk. If the math made any sense for the customer, the company would break even or go bankrupt.

I wouldn’t have insurance but it’s required in my state.

The one good thing I can say about it is it helps ensure victims of car accidents get their medical bills paid for regardless of the financial status of the driver.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by majormajor on Sunday June 09, 2024 @12:25AM (#40622037)
> I wouldn’t have insurance but it’s required in my state.

Does your state require comprehensive/collision insurance? I've only lived places where you would be permitted to get liability-only insurance which would specifically not cover either of the situations you think you got screwed on.

(Neither of which is why most people get insurance anyway. You get car-insurance beyond the legal minimum because while you will likely pay more in the long run, you won't have to deal with a surprise tens-of-thousands replacement bill out of nowhere if you accidentally total your car. Or because you have a loan and your lender doesn't trust you to go without it - of course, if you truly don't need insurance for something, you likely don't need a loan for it either. This is generally non-controversial and the "obviously it's a bad deal because the insurance company exists and pays salaries" hot take is... duh? well known? not an insight?)

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by tjohns on Sunday June 09, 2024 @12:43AM (#40622100)
Insurance is primarily for major events. The things at the extreme upper end of the bell curve.

For example, you've hit another car (possibly an expensive one) and caused tens of thousands of dollars in damage. Or you've inured a passenger and caused hundreds of thousands of dollars of hospital bills.

The kinds of events that would financially ruin you, or at least seriously set you back on your life goals. Or, in the case of state-mandated insurance, where there's a high likelihood you wouldn't be able to make the other party whole.

You can use it on smaller things if you insist (and your rates will go up), but that's not really what it's for.

Personally, both the events you described fall under my definition of one-off maintenance ("things that are an unpredictable yet unavoidable cost of owning a vehicle") and that I'd expect to pay for out of pocket.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by efitz on Sunday June 09, 2024 @03:44AM (#40622718)
And that is one of the reasons why medical insurance is so crazy in the United States nowadays - it’s no longer used to hedge catastrophic unpredictable events (which used to be called “major medical”), but instead is used to pay for normal, minor consumption or for chronic conditions.

In other words it’s no longer like a bet, it’s like a discount plan. But the problem is that the complexity of introducing a third party payer who doesn’t want to pay, and a consumer who has no incentive to self regulate consumption, means that the costs spiral up and up.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:01AM (#40623007)
> But the problem is that the complexity of introducing a third party payer who doesn’t want to pay, and a consumer who has no incentive to self regulate consumption, means that the costs spiral up and up.

The first part is correct but a consumer that “doesn't self regulate consumption” is not a thing in medicine. People don’t take drugs for fun. People don’t injure themselves more in public healthcare systems. In fact, a huge problem in medicine is getting men to go to the doctor before issues become critical (and more expensive).

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @09:49AM (#40624415)
People eating more than they should, getting diabetes, and then consuming more medical services is a form of poor regulation of consumption.

The overapplication of OxyContin is another form of unregulated consumption.

Now we have the semaglutides and will see the same effect.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @11:29AM (#40625097)
The USA has a 38% obesity rate vs the UK at 29% (for men). Given both exist quite far apart on the public/private healthcare debate, I don’t see how this supports your argument at all.

Source: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7670332/

I’m not going to debate the others because I don’t know much about them and, since your argument fell apart at light prodding, I don’t think you do, either.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @11:41AM (#40625182)
I was not making an argument about the public/private healthcare debate. I am objecting to the assertions 'a consumer that “doesn't self regulate consumption” is not a thing in medicine' and 'People don’t take drugs for fun.'

I was similarly convinced that moral hazard in healthcare was not a problem because consumers don't get more healthcare than they need. I know now that this is not the case.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @12:09PM (#40625405)
I’m not making a public/private argument either. The full sentence was:

> But the problem is that the complexity of introducing a third party payer who doesn’t want to pay, and a consumer who has no incentive to self regulate consumption, means that the costs spiral up and up.

Obviously, people do eat to excess, engage in activities that have risk (and die as a result).

Whether you pay or someone else pays does not factor in these decisions, which is why I pointed to obesity rates in UK/USA to demonstrate this. If such moral hazard existed, you’d see lower obesity in the USA than in the UK. You don’t, ergo, it mustn’t.

EDIT: By “take drugs for fun” I’m specifically referring to medical drugs in my original message so removed it from this one (where I conflated with recreational drugs).

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @12:49PM (#40625720)
OxyContin is a medical drug. I have unfortunately had to assist my mother with visits to the "pain clinic" and seen firsthand many patients with a problem with self regulation of consumption.

Maybe I am interpreting your assertions too literally.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @01:09PM (#40625884)
Ok but I’m guessing you’re in the USA where you’d have to pay significant sums for that in some form, as long as you can convince a doctor to sign off.

I’m not aware of a similar problem in England, where prescriptions are currently £9.90 per prescription.

This is my point: the financial cost, as with obesity, is not regulating the behaviour.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @01:17PM (#40625939)
Ah, now I understand why you are confused. No, most people with health problems in the U.S. are paying, at most, only a copay for a visit. They are getting medical treatment at no cost to them directly. It is paid for by an insurer or the state or Federal government.

This moral hazard is fundamental to our problem and why many have problems regulating their consumption.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @01:30PM (#40626027)
Except this simply DOESN’T HAPPEN in the most famous free healthcare system on Earth, so clearly it can’t be a moral hazard. I also know for a fact these people aren’t getting this for “free.” I just checked and copay is subject to the deductible. Also, I seriously doubt insurance companies aren’t ramping up premiums on these people once they get a chance.

Are these people seriously going “well it’s only $26 a pop so I may as well.” Do you think the (apparently) low price is what’s causing this?

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @01:54PM (#40626191)
I believe that you have strong opinions of the system with which I have too much experience.

Many of these people are, in the case of pain clinics, getting their pills paid for by workers’ compensation carriers.

That the UK has avoided some moral hazards does mean that they cannot exist elsewhere. Maybe the UK doesn’t incentivize doctors to hand out more pills.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @03:41PM (#40626964)
No, I have a strong opinion that the moral hazard of affordable healthcare doesn’t exist based on the lack of evidence. Americans (and the hard right of British politics) are the only group that even consider such an argument.

If there were a moral hazard to affordable healthcare, I posit that you’d see lots of it in a system where healthcare is mostly free at the point of use (prescriptions aside). The fact that obesity and opioid addiction happen in the USA at far higher rates than in the UK points to a strong indicator that this moral hazard simply does not exist. The fact is that the only examples you can give point to issues unrelated to “moral hazard.”

You have failed to point to a systemic pattern of risk-taking behaviour that is higher in a system with socialised healthcare than in privatised systems to convince me otherwise. You cannot because it doesn’t happen. Human beings, on the whole, do not engage in obviously dangerous behaviour more if it’s free to get treatment because we’re simply not that stupid.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @03:47PM (#40627010)
I would very much like to move to live amongst the people that are simply not that stupid.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:05PM (#40627154)
Now I don’t know if you’re just deliberately misreading my comments. At no point do I say “people don’t engage in dangerous behaviour,” I merely point out such behaviour is UNRELATED to the cost of healthcare. You’ve yet to show me any data that shows a link between affordable healthcare and moral hazard.

On the contrary, your only examples come from within a system famed for being the opposite.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:09PM (#40627190)
I never claimed that there is a link between affordable healthcare and moral hazard. I argued only with two of your assertions which I have found to be unfortunately untrue, in my experience with the U.S. healthcare industry.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:13PM (#40627224)
> I was similarly convinced that moral hazard in healthcare was not a problem because consumers don't get more healthcare than they need. I know now that this is not the case.

Except for… you know, right here.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:21PM (#40627292)
I did not claim that the moral hazard problem is linked to affordability. You seem to want to argue with things I have not said.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:26PM (#40627320)
That’s the “moral hazard” in healthcare that’s used against affordable healthcare. It’s the only context it’s used in.

Obesity and opioid addiction aren’t “moral hazards” in healthcare, they’re literally things healthcare and society need to deal with. We’re far off the topic of insurance and I don’t even understand what you took issue with apart from nitpicking a sentence at this point.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:33PM (#40627366)
Your assumption about context is not relevant to my argument.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scott_w on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:48PM (#40627499)
You’re right, it was my mistake for assuming words mean what they’re commonly used to refer to /s
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mcculley on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:55PM (#40627547)
Moral hazard has a well understood meaning outside of affordability. I would very much like to see the system in the U.S. make more sense. Any time spent in an emergency room or waiting room in the U.S. makes the moral hazard obvious.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by abenga on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:39AM (#40623166)
And that is why the insurance model should not be used for healthcare. For example, why should an insurance company charge you anything less than the cost of treating a chronic illness after diagnosis? Why should the minimum price of giving birth not be the exact premium you pay? None of those are surprises (after the initial diagnosis or conception, of course, and it can obviously be argued that birthing complications can be insured against too), so there is no reason to use probabilistic models to pay for them.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by bruce343434 on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:31AM (#40623443)
The problem is price fixing deals between hospitals and insurers, where the insurer pays only a tiny fraction of the retail price. It's not economically viable for consumers to not have the "discount plan" as you aptly put it. That benefits the insurance company so they like it like that.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by mpreda on Sunday June 09, 2024 @01:46AM (#40622319)
> Insurance is primarily for major events. The things at the extreme upper end of the bell curve

That's how it should be, but isn't because all insurance contracts cap the maximum insured amount. So that's absolutely NOT the "extreme upper end of the bell", not at all.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by Mathnerd314 on Sunday June 09, 2024 @02:19AM (#40622425)
There are unlimited umbrella policies, but practically past 1 million or <net worth> it is probably cheaper to declare bankruptcy than pay the additional premiums.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by e_y_ on Sunday June 09, 2024 @03:17AM (#40622628)
Wouldn't you rather not lose $1+ million? It costs something like $400/year per $1M coverage which is hardly breaking the bank.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by Mathnerd314 on Sunday June 09, 2024 @11:28AM (#40625092)
$400/year is a new laptop or something, if you spend the money then the creditors can't take it.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by bigthymer on Sunday June 09, 2024 @12:50AM (#40622127)
One way to solve this problem is to be part of mutual insurance instead of a private company. Not sure if that is an available option for you.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by zeroonetwothree on Sunday June 09, 2024 @01:13AM (#40622205)
You can get a liability only policy.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by pkulak on Sunday June 09, 2024 @01:44AM (#40622314)
> I wouldn’t have insurance but it’s required in my state.

As long as you have a few million set aside in case you cause one of the 45,000 deaths, or even more injuries, that happen on US roads every year, I agree with you.

But then you say exactly my point in your last paragraph… you’re all over the place here.

Insurance isn’t about pot hole damage. If you use it all the time, it’s a membership fee, not insurance.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by dazc on Sunday June 09, 2024 @03:38AM (#40622697)
In the UK we have multiple insurers competing fiercely on price, to the point where many lose money year on year. People still say it's a scam though because their experience when making a claim doesn't play out like they expected.

I think part of the problem is the unseen costs of long-term hire cars, injury compensation and outright fraud that has become an everyday expense that someone has to pick up the tab for?

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by michaelt on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:15AM (#40622822)
> People still say it's a scam though because their experience when making a claim doesn't play out like they expected.

A friend of mine had her insured bicycle stolen.

It was locked up with an extremely heavy chain and lock, which were rated 'gold' by insurance companies for locking up motorbikes. Her insurance denied the claim, because the chain wasn't gold rated for locking up bicycles.

By all means get insurance - but when their marketing talks about being on your side, you gotta realise that weaselling out of paying claims is a big part of their business model.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by infecto on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:02AM (#40623009)
Weasel? How do you expect it to work? There is a contract and the company is going to follow it.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by scns on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:41AM (#40623176)
They have lawyers preventing customers getting paid. One of those couldn't take it any longer and switched sides.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by infecto on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:46AM (#40623199)
Perhaps in your narrative. I don’t believe that to be true for the vast majority of property claims.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by globular-toast on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:21AM (#40623388)
Bicycle insurance is mostly useless unfortunately. We really need to do something about it if bicycles are going to be practical for more people. Cars get probably 100x the Police resource dedicated to them compared to bikes.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by bruce343434 on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:36AM (#40623480)
Bikes were not meant to be $1000+. Get a cheap one and set aside a monthly amount for replacing it. Don't get insurance on it. Get into an accident? You should already have health insurance to cover it.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by globular-toast on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:18AM (#40623931)
They definitely don't need to be that expensive, but anything less than 500 credits isn't going to be very nice to ride. The sweet spot is something like 600-700 which is non-negligible.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by graemep on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:18AM (#40623372)
I think one of the problems in the UK is too much of the competition is just on price. People buy what is cheapest on a price comparison site. They do not consider reputation for trying not to pay, or customer service very much (because there are either no metrics or unclear ones).

The same applies to things like internet connectivity. People look only at price and download speed.

I also think it is not worth claiming for minor things and you keep your no claims bonus - therefore you might as well get a policy with a higher excess.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by pipes on Sunday June 09, 2024 @03:54AM (#40622741)
In the UK damage caused by potholes can be claimed back from the local council. It's a pain in the ass but worth pursuing. I'm surprised the USA doesn't have the same. (Assuming you are in the USA!)
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by infecto on Sunday June 09, 2024 @05:02AM (#40623014)
I believe most states have some ability to do what you describe. It’s a PITA too though.
Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by infecto on Sunday June 09, 2024 @04:57AM (#40622989)
Of course insurance companies need to make a profit. That does not mean they are scams. Hitting a pothole will almost always be either your fault or the local governments fault. Insurance companies are incentivized to make competitive quotes when possible.

Your thought of not having insurance demonstrates you are not thinking about this the right way at all. Your state requires liability which will pay out claims against yourself.

Re:What makes gambling wrong but insurance right? (2017) by globular-toast on Sunday June 09, 2024 @06:18AM (#40623371)
> Oh and they categorically consider hitting a pothole to be the driver’s fault, no matter the circumstances

Because it is your fault. How can someone force you to drive into a pothole at speed? Smooth roads build complacency, but you need to be on the lookout at all times. Most drivers are disastrously bad when it comes to understanding speed. Modern cars encourage awful habits.