News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by suzzer99 on Saturday June 08, 2024 @02:48AM (#40615771)
Here's something I've wondered. If the universe is made up of 85% dark matter, does that mean we can assume black holes are also made up of the same ratio of dark matter to regular matter (or at least when it went into the black hole)?
Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by PartiallyTyped on Saturday June 08, 2024 @05:32AM (#40616398)
IANAP (physicist)

The only the matter portion of the universe is 85% dark matter (26.8% of mass-energy content of the universe).

As for the question; I don't think it's right to assume that dark matter really is exotic matter. It's just a set of observations. It's something that behaves like matter (with respect to density scaling) but only seems to interact gravitationally.

Some theories posit that it's some unknown particles, others that they are primordial black holes, and some that gravity just behaves differently (MOND).

I really enjoyed Dr Angela's videos on Dark Matter [1,2]

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qS34oV-jv_A [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PbmJkMhmrVI

Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by andrewflnr on Saturday June 08, 2024 @09:42AM (#40617498)
> It's just a set of observations.

I've never heard anyone but Collier put forward this perspective on "dark matter", and I can't recall any other physicist using the term in a way consistent with that perspective. Frankly I think she was off base. Her videos are fun but her takes on terminology are often pretty bad.

Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by PartiallyTyped on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:24AM (#40617739)
Could you elaborate?

It’s a set of observations about “something” that behaves like matter[1], and interacts only gravitationally. There are many theories proposed but none has any real answers or solutions. The following is taken from Cern[2]:

> Many theories say the dark matter particles would be light enough to be produced at the LHC. If they were created at the LHC, they would escape through the detectors unnoticed. However, they would carry away energy and momentum, so physicists could infer their existence from the amount of energy and momentum “missing” after a collision. Dark matter candidates arise frequently in theories that suggest physics beyond the Standard Model, such as supersymmetry and extra dimensions. One theory suggests the existence of a “Hidden Valley”, a parallel world made of dark matter having very little in common with matter we know. If one of these theories proved to be true, it could help scientists gain a better understanding of the composition of our universe and, in particular, how galaxies hold together.

And thus at least whoever wrote this and the people who approved that publication agree with the notion that it is observations for which no concrete theory exists that explains them.

[1] i used “behaves like matter” in the sense that follows this definition:

> In standard cosmological calculations, "matter" means any constituent of the universe whose energy density scales with the inverse cube of the scale factor, i.e., ρ ∝ a−3 . This is in contrast to "radiation", which scales as the inverse fourth power of the scale factor ρ ∝ a−4 , and a cosmological constant, which does not change with respect to a (ρ ∝ a0). The different scaling factors for matter and radiation are a consequence of radiation redshift: For example, after gradually doubling the diameter of the observable Universe via cosmic expansion of General Relativity, the scale, a, has doubled. The energy of the cosmic microwave background radiation has been halved (because the wavelength of each photon has doubled);[51] the energy of ultra-relativistic particles, such as early-era standard-model neutrinos, is similarly halved.[d] The cosmological constant, as an intrinsic property of space, has a constant energy density regardless of the volume under consideration.[52][e] In principle, "dark matter" means all components of the universe which are not visible but still obey ρ ∝ a−3 . In practice, the term "dark matter" is often used to mean only the non-baryonic component of dark matter, i.e., excluding "missing baryons". Context will usually indicate which meaning is intended.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dark_matter

[2] https://home.cern/science/physics/dark-matter

Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by andrewflnr on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:38AM (#40617808)
The way she wants to use "dark matter", MOND is a dark matter theory (explains (some of) the same observations), and no one else uses it that way. "Dark matter" always means some kind of matter, whatever the specifics. Think of it as a family of theories if that helps.
Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by PartiallyTyped on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:49AM (#40617891)
I don’t see where we (or she for that matter —hah!) disagree.

She agrees that Dark Matter is observations or a problem for something that seems to be matter from our definitions of matter and its interactions.

She didn’t claim that MOND is the only theory or answer — in fact she made a video about this exactly, that she believes she failed to adequately argue that DM is what we are discussing because people put too much emphasis on MOND or thought of it as “the only solution to the DM problem”.

Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by andrewflnr on Saturday June 08, 2024 @12:01PM (#40618418)
Are you actually reading what I'm saying? Can you tell the difference between a claim about whether a theory is true and how it is best categorized?
Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by PartiallyNerdy on Saturday June 08, 2024 @12:22PM (#40618608)
I claimed dark matter is something we observed and dark matter “theories” are proposed but yet to be proven theories that describe it.

She did that too.

She didn’t claim Mond is true, neither did I, and as far as I can understand you, neither did you.

If you assume me or her did that, then you’ve grossly misunderstood mine or her remarks.

Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by andrewflnr on Saturday June 08, 2024 @06:42PM (#40620686)
> She didn’t claim Mond is true, neither did I, and as far as I can understand you, neither did you.

Well I'm glad we're clear on that. But then why did you feel the need to say

> She didn’t claim that MOND is the only theory or answer

As if that was a question anyone was asking?

Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by PartiallyTyped on Saturday June 08, 2024 @02:28PM (#40619384)
Please tell me what I said that’s wrong instead of outright downvoting.
Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by T-A on Saturday June 08, 2024 @06:35AM (#40616647)
Assuming that the no-hair theorem

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/No-hair_theorem

applies, once the black hole is formed, you can't tell which kind of matter was involved in its creation.

Re:Gravity Without Mass: UAH Study Proposes Alternative to D... by magicalhippo on Saturday June 08, 2024 @07:22AM (#40616852)
The thing about dark matter is that it seems to be highly non-interactive.

If it could interact it would be able to shed its momentum through collisions like normal matter, and thus fall towards the center of the galaxy and clump like normal matter.

Instead the gravitational evidence, like galaxy rotation curves, indicates that the dark matter is spread out in a huge diffuse halo around the galaxies, several times the radius of the visible galaxy.

Thus in the same way, dark matter would be unable to form a "dark accretion disk" around a black hole, where it could shed it's momentum in order to lose enough orbital velocity to fall into the black hole.

Thus the only dark matter that would enter would be that captured during formation and that which hits it directly like a meteor, so the ratio would be significantly lower.

This of course assumes dark matter is a particle (or several), which is the current leading hypothesis but it's by no means settled yet.

At least that's my understanding.