News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by otabdeveloper4 on Friday June 07, 2024 @04:42PM (#40612755)
Maybe humans didn't originate in Africa. There are many arguments for and against.

But this is an ideological and political issue, not a scientific question. So case closed, the Consensus Is Settled.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by AlbertCory on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:06PM (#40612988)
I have not seen the arguments against. What are they?
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by adolph on Friday June 07, 2024 @05:30PM (#40613185)
My impression is that relatively recent genetic findings open "recent out-of-Africa" to conjectures of "its complicated mostly-out-of-Africa"

https://www.edge.org/conversation/christopher_stringer-rethi...

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by AlbertCory on Friday June 07, 2024 @09:23PM (#40614556)
I found this kinda hard to follow, but it doesn't seem UFO-level crazy, anyway.

I'm sure this is ignorant, but: if two individuals can interbreed and produce fertile offscreen, then aren't they, by definition, the same species?

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by thaumasiotes on Saturday June 08, 2024 @01:50AM (#40615565)
> if two individuals can interbreed and produce fertile off[spring], then aren't they, by definition, the same species?

No. For example, that would make it impossible to determine the species of fossils.

For another example, wolves are considered a different species from dogs, and coyotes are considered separate from each.

For a third example, bacteria don't interbreed at all, but we don't consider each of them to be their own species.

The definition you allude to is technically known as the "biological species concept", which should be a hint that it's not viewed as definitive.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by AlbertCory on Saturday June 08, 2024 @10:51AM (#40617910)
OK, thanks. What makes a wolf a different species than dog, and what species are the offspring of a dog-wolf mating considered?
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by thaumasiotes on Saturday June 08, 2024 @03:36PM (#40619742)
Fundamentally what makes a wolf a different species than "dog" is that people don't consider them to be the same.

But there are several good reasons; their behavior, life strategy, and often size and appearance are all radically different. The best match here is probably the "ecological species concept": (1) https://www.blackwellpublishing.com/ridley/a-z/Ecological_sp... ; (2) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecotype

> and what species are the offspring of a dog-wolf mating considered?

I am not personally aware of standard terminology, but I might say "half wolf" or "wolf hybrid". The wikipedia page is titled "wolfdog". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolfdog

There is standard terminology for the offspring of a wolf and a coyote; those are called "red wolves". Wikipedia suggests that they have a taxonomic species name canis rufus, but this is controversial (since they're hybrids).

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by AlbertCory on Saturday June 08, 2024 @08:36PM (#40621101)
I do appreciate this and I hope you don't perceive it as "arguing." My biological education is a little sketchy.

Turning it around a little: if some members of a mainland species move to an island and eventually become incapable of interbreeding with the original species, then it is always a new species. True or false?

So "no-interbreeding" is sufficient but not necessary?

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 09, 2024 @02:57PM (#40626638)
> Turning it around a little: if some members of a mainland species move to an island and eventually become incapable of interbreeding with the original species, then it is always a new species. True or false?

I think people would basically agree with this; true enough.

> So "no-interbreeding" is sufficient but not necessary?

Not quite; the example of bacteria, above, disproves the sufficiency of "no-interbreeding".

(Bacteria do mix their genetic material, but they directly exchange it with each other, and then their children are clones of themselves. Imagine if, whenever you had sex, your partner took on some of your traits, and you took on some of theirs. This would obviate the need for your children to draw their traits from more than one parent, and that's how bacteria work.)

There are asexual higher organisms, like some lizards, and they follow the taxonomic example of bacteria in that when two of them are genetically similar enough, we call them the same species despite the fact that - since they can't breed at all - they cannot interbreed.

The fossil example is also incompatible with "no-interbreeding" being a sufficient criterion, though this is a bit less clear than the bacteria example; we can't determine whether two fossils were or weren't able to interbreed. We can be nearly certain that there is some pair of structurally similar-looking fossils out there that we have labeled as belonging to a single species, despite the fact that the individual organisms wouldn't have been able to breed with each other. You could make the argument that this is simply a mistake on our part, and that would have a lot of validity, but even viewed that way it's a mistake that cannot even theoretically be corrected, which causes some conceptual difficulties.

The reason there are so many species concept is that species are just a reflection of the idea that two organisms are "the same". What it means to be "the same" varies in different contexts, according to, without claiming to be exhaustive, (1) what you care about; (2) what is possible in the space you're discussing [pigs can't do the direct genetic exchange that bacteria can]; and (3) what it's possible for you to know.

> I do appreciate this and I hope you don't perceive it as "arguing."

Don't worry about offending me; you seem to be in perfectly good faith so far.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by AlbertCory on Sunday June 09, 2024 @09:25PM (#40629193)
ok. If we know that a species (1) is sexual, and (2) cannot interbreed with an individual of a superficially similar species, then it IS sufficient to say we have two species there. I think I have all the qualifiers :)

Incidentally, today on Facebook someone made the risible claim that since our DNA is 98% the same as a chimp, WE are "98% the same as a chimp."

I pointed out that by that standard, we're also 60% the same as a banana.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by thaumasiotes on Sunday June 09, 2024 @10:52PM (#40629673)
You might be interested in the concept of "ring species", which doesn't contradict the principle you just stated, but does conflict with the biological species concept. A ring species is a continuum of interbreeding populations such that the ends of the continuum are not interfertile.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ring_species

This parallels the phenomenon you see in languages where, for example, any two adjacent villages across a considerable distance will be able to speak to each other, even though villages at opposite ends of the continuum cannot do so.

(The "ring" part of the term refers to the two ends of the interfertility continuum being located in the same geographic area, which is a red herring.)

As the wikipedia page notes, the problem that this concept exposes is that interfertility is not a transitive relation, and therefore can't be an equivalence relation.

> today on Facebook someone made the risible claim that since our DNA is 98% the same as a chimp, WE are "98% the same as a chimp."

> I pointed out that by that standard, we're also 60% the same as a banana.

The major problem here is that "to what degree is a person 'the same' as a chimp?" is not a well-defined question. Again, you would need to define what it means to be the same, and it will vary with what you care about.

There are important ways in which we are the same as a banana; most obviously, you can eat a banana and expect to be nourished. This is not a given for an alien organism, even one that appears to be largely chemically identical to a banana. Whether the similarities reach 60% depends on how you convert them to numbers. We can note that the concept of 'species' assures us that any two humans are 100% "the same", as compared to a banana, whereas if you research relatedness the convention is that two brothers are 50% "the same" and two strangers are 0% "the same" (and bananas, not being human, don't exist), and if you're doing theology the convention is generally that even identical twins are 0% "the same".

Summing that up, if you're told that two things are the same, the response is "the same how?" The reason the Facebook argument is stupid is that total shared DNA count isn't a useful thing to measure for most purposes. The salience of a difference in phenotype isn't closely related to the amount of DNA that changed to enable it.

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by AlbertCory on Monday June 10, 2024 @12:44AM (#40630246)
and with that....... thank you, sir.
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by otabdeveloper4 on Sunday June 09, 2024 @08:21AM (#40623951)
> I have not seen the arguments against.

How could you have seen any if the entire topic itself is a political hot potato and verboten to even discuss?

Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by AlexeyBelov on Monday June 10, 2024 @03:05AM (#40630987)
It's not, you can discuss it. Why don't you say anything of substance?
Re:Clues to disappearance of North America's large mammals 5... by thaumasiotes on Friday June 07, 2024 @04:55PM (#40612871)
> Maybe humans didn't originate in Africa. There are many arguments for and against.

Sure, but the arguments against are in the same vein as the argument that, if I draw a circle, it's not a real circle, because I don't have the level of fine control over my hand that would be necessary to produce one of those, and the tip of my pen is too wide.

True, but not really relevant to anything, and in particular unlikely to convince anyone that it's a mistake to call what I drew "a circle".