News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by amalag on Sunday June 03, 2012 @07:02AM (#4060507)
So this will increase the slaughter and inhumane treatment towards other sentient creatures. Put another blind eye to slaughterhouses. Better people should get graphic reminders of where their meat comes from than put another layer on the plastic packaging through using a machine.

Losing empathy towards living creatures means reducing empathy for humans as well. A controversial statement, but i am sure one can search that out within themselves.

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by rdl on Sunday June 03, 2012 @07:20AM (#4060528)
I really don't think having some poor people working in slaughterhouses, treated slightly better than the animals they butcher (but only slightly) really improves anyone's sense of empathy for animals (or humans). That ship sailed a long time ago, around when we got factory farming or really once any family didn't contain at least one farmer (1800s?)
Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by gurkendoktor on Sunday June 03, 2012 @07:37AM (#4060551)
To anecdotally confirm what you said: There was a "scandal" in Germany last year where a school slaughtered and barbecued a hare. (Students were around 10/11 years old) Parents were outraged, basically arguing 'it should be everyone's choice to either know or ignore where meat comes from'.
Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by tomp on Sunday June 03, 2012 @07:47AM (#4060560)
Did you read the article? The robot just separates the meat from the bone of chicken that are already dead. Robots won't increase the number of kills - consumer demand will.

Interestingly, robots might even reduce the inhumane treatment towards these animals, which is, if I understand correctly, most often the result of cost-saving.

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by corin_ on Sunday June 03, 2012 @10:32AM (#4060799)
More meat from each chicken could lead to less chickens killed, on the other hand cheaper production could lead to cheaper prices which could lead to a rise in demand...

But as a non-vegetarian I'm pretty indifferent to which animals we eat more of.

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by icebraining on Sunday June 03, 2012 @10:33AM (#4060801)
My grandmother, who raises chicken, likes them as much as most people I know like their dogs, and yet she has no problem killing and eating them.

Your view of reduced empathy is simplistic and wrong.

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by amalag on Monday June 04, 2012 @11:22AM (#4064365)
So you are saying your grandmother is very compassionate?
Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by nitrogen on Sunday June 03, 2012 @09:53AM (#4060731)
So this will increase the slaughter and inhumane treatment towards other sentient creatures.

When did chickens become sentient?

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by justsee on Sunday June 03, 2012 @10:12AM (#4060751)
Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by jlgreco on Sunday June 03, 2012 @11:10AM (#4060901)
Sure, we know what it means. Does any of that apply to chickens? Chickens are stupid, really stupid.
Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by justsee on Sunday June 03, 2012 @11:25AM (#4060961)
Well yes, that's why I just posted the link to the article which explains why they are sentient.

A more interesting, thoughtful piece on this is http://www.gourmet.com/magazine/2000s/2004/08/consider_the_l...

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by jlgreco on Sunday June 03, 2012 @05:37PM (#4061825)
You are going to have to help me out and at least try to make an argument instead of linking to others. That wikipedia page doesn't suggest anything in your supporting as far as I can tell besides 'when talking about animal rights, the ability to feel pain is a sufficient argument' and backs that statement up with 'higher functioning is not required because no matter how crippled, humans are still sentient'. This is an emotional argument and I am forced to say that ratiponallly no, humans that are sufficiently disabled are not sentient.

The lobster article just starts with the premise that they are sentient, dismisses the complete absence of brain structures that, if we lacked, we would likely be considered braindead, and say 'but they don't like being boiled!' Terribly unconvincing.

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by justsee on Sunday June 03, 2012 @10:31PM (#4062410)
The first sentence of that Wikipedia page clarifies that animals are sentient? "Sentience is the ability to feel, perceive or be conscious, or to have subjective experiences."

The 'Consider the Lobster' article simply investigates the philosophical idea that the ability to suffer is the test for sentience and applies it to lobsters, noting how furiously they attempt to escape pain.

Sentience does not imply that living creatures must have the same biological structures to 'feel, perceive, or be conscious' so your point that they are absent brain structures we have seems irrelevant when considering the definition of the word.

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by jlgreco on Sunday June 03, 2012 @10:34PM (#4062421)
Could my roomba be said to have sentience if programmed to respond to undesirable stimuli in a sufficiently 'furious' manner?
Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by justsee on Monday June 04, 2012 @04:15AM (#4063104)
No, because as an inanimate object it has no capacity for suffering or self-awareness.
Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by nitrogen on Monday June 04, 2012 @10:39AM (#4064174)
How do you know it's an inanimate object, if it behaves indistinguishably from a boiling lobster?
Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by justsee on Monday June 04, 2012 @07:42PM (#4066587)
Well the simplest answer: because a roomba is not a living thing.

Regardless of how sophisticated Roomba Mk #9999 is in aping the behaviour of living things, it itself is not living and so is not sentient: "Sentience is the ability to feel, perceive or be conscious, or to have subjective experiences."

I'm partial to Roger Penrose' position on AI, and his interpretation of Gödel's incompleteness theorem and its implications for Strong AI.

It is impossible, and therefore futile, to create consciousness through construction of algorithms, no matter how complex, as the mind is non-algorithmic.

I know there was recent HN exasperation on the apparent 'misapplication' of Gödel's theorem to the mind / matter problem, but I"d dispute the implication that it is misapplied through ignorance. It is simply educated disagreement between two opposing philosophical positions.

Many of the issues around materialism / physicalism / computationalism and the mind / matter problem are covered here http://rational-buddhism.blogspot.com. Yes, it's from a Buddhist perspective, but you'll quickly find a lot of articles seem to cover the issues from a computer science perspective.

If the start of that link requires too much setup for your liking, I'd recommend having a look at http://rational-buddhism.blogspot.com/2012/02/church-turing-... first.

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by jlgreco on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @02:54AM (#4067669)
Penrose's position boils down to him being uncomfortable with the idea that Gödel's theorems might apply to himself. His books have received criticism from the majority of the academic community and his suggestion for where the non-algorithmic nature of the mind may come from has not seen empirical confirmation. Simply put, it is just wishful thinking.

Regardless, Penrose himself dismisses the role of any supernatural factors; this leaves us open to the possibility that a non-algorithic but nevertheless synthetic intelligence could be created (and in theory wedged into my roomba). Orch-OR does not require 'meat'.

Re:Can robots debone a chicken? by jlgreco on Tuesday June 05, 2012 @02:42AM (#4067643)
This strikes me as an emotional distinction then, not a rational one. You'll have to excuse me if I don't give it much attention.