News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DHCPv6-PD – First Steps by ninkendo on Thursday June 06, 2024 @07:02AM (#40595975)
How could it not be a compromise?

If I use a global unicast prefix, the IPs I see on my devices are their real honest to goodness routable IP. That is great!

But I can’t use that IP in any configuration because it will change. That’s not so great.

So I have to compromise by not using the routable IP in places where I need to put the address in a config file.

Nobody wants ULA. ULA is a solution for the fact that your prefix will change, which I wish didn’t happen.

You can say it’s unreasonable to expect a stable prefix (and we could argue about that all day) but don’t pretend it wouldn’t be massively beneficial if I could rely on one. It is absolutely a compromise. A necessary one? Yes. A reasonably simple solution to implement? Yes. But it’s still a compromise.

Re:DHCPv6-PD – First Steps by Dylan16807 on Thursday June 06, 2024 @10:16AM (#40597680)
Well as someone else mentioned, do you want your devices to have no address when your internet connection goes down? A global IP is also a compromise unless you have your own ASN.

> don’t pretend it wouldn’t be massively beneficial

It would be barely beneficial to me.

I don't want to memorize my global prefix anyway.