News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by jsprinkles on Friday June 01, 2012 @04:26PM (#4055562)
I wish your comment was the only one, frankly, and we could really use a "you are not a lawyer, stop pretending to be one" guideline.

Edit: I've made a "Ask PG" to ask for just that: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4055661

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by nirvana on Friday June 01, 2012 @04:49PM (#4055685)
The idea that only lawyers can know anything about the law, and therefore nobody else can suggest avenues of investigation is shockingly elitist.

Imagine what HN would be like if only state approved programmers were allowed to have an opinion on technical subjects.

You're being down voted because you are lying about what I said and attacking me for the "crime" of trying to suggest areas of investigation for this guy... who's primary problem is that he has been UNABLE to get a lawyer.

So, yeah, shame on me for trying to help him get a lawyer. I won't sleep tonight.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by nostromo on Friday June 01, 2012 @04:57PM (#4055736)
> The idea that only lawyers can know anything about the law, and therefore nobody else can suggest avenues of investigation is shockingly elitist.

It is elitist and shitty, but also true. It's not because lawyers are smarter than the rest of us. It's because the legal code in the US is ridiculously complicated, vague, and fraught with landmines.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by larrys on Friday June 01, 2012 @05:29PM (#4055901)
"It's because the legal code in the US is ridiculously complicated, vague, and fraught with landmines."

Dealing with these situations does not just involve legal knowledge. It also involves strategy as well as some practical examples of what others have done in the same situation.

Lawyers (with obvious exceptions) tend to be pretty weak on common sense strategies and tend to frame things totally based upon their legal knowledge and training. This can be a trap that prevents them from seeing a very obvious solution to a problem that a non-lawyer can come up with.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by nostromo on Friday June 01, 2012 @05:41PM (#4055976)
Right. One example strategy a lawyer probably wouldn't come up with: shame the company on HN.
Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by larrys on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:26PM (#4056176)
Lawyers being officers of the court have to act in ethical ways. And most importantly they have something to loose which is their law license. That's a powerful motivator to not take any chances.

A layman on the other hand can engage in different types of manipulation that an attorney can't do even if they had the same idea.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by mindcrime on Friday June 01, 2012 @05:47PM (#4056006)
Lawyers (with obvious exceptions) tend to be pretty weak on common sense strategies and tend to frame things totally based upon their legal knowledge and training.

OK, one data point is just an anecdote, but I saw a good example of a lawyer using some basic strategy a while back. I had a legal situation of my own, hired a lawyer and went to court with the lawyer. The situation wasn't settled the first day, so my lawyer looked at the court schedule, figured out that if we asked for a continuance we'd come back to court when a different judge was presiding, who he believed - based on his knowledge of the judge's personal life - would be more favorable to our position.

We came back two weeks later, sat in front of the new judge, and the judge came down pretty clearly on our side, and the situation was resolved amicably. Had we tested our luck with a different judge, things might not have turned out so well (then again, maybe they would). But, anyway, is struck me as a fairly subtle, but effective technique.

That said, I understand that - in general - the courts don't like it when lawyers try to "pick their judge" to YMMV.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by nirvana on Friday June 01, 2012 @05:29PM (#4055903)
You're absolutely correct when it comes to legal advice, as such would need to avoid such land mines.

But that's not the issue here. The issue here is whether one can suggest possible legal avenues of investigation that could be used to get a lawyer interested in the case.

There is zero risk in reading the law and then talking to a lawyer about what you find there.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by cube13 on Friday June 01, 2012 @05:34PM (#4055930)
>But that's not the issue here. The issue here is whether one can suggest possible legal avenues of investigation that could be used to get a lawyer interested in the case.

Here's how you get a lawyer interested in the case:

1. Find the phone number of a lawyer. Contact the EFF, or the local bar association for a lawyer that's listed as knowledgeable with the part of law that you're dealing with(in this case, copyright and trademark law).

2. Call the lawyer, arrange a meeting. Gather up everything they ask for when you call them.

3. Meet with the lawyer. If it doesn't go well, go back to step 1. Repeat until done.

4. There is no step 4.

This should be the only piece of advice in this thread.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by ferringham on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:50PM (#4056262)
oh Mr. Very Important and his "this should be the only piece of advice in this thread."

A few days ago there was this post #1 on YC News about a guys whose kid had this super-rare genetic disorder. Now, what, this guy should only listen to the Doctors and forget about turning on his own brain?

I think that a good lawyer will listen to his Client and appreciate the Client who is interested enough in his case to propose solutions based on this readings/understanding of the Law. Or even discuss the stuff he saw here.

Why on Earth everybody such a pain about legal advise and when it comes to much more important thing in life - health, life threatning disease - nobody's complaining when questions are asked and resolutions proposed.

HN as I understand it is to exchange and share information. Not to censor it. Go to Cuba with your attitude dude. Or just relax.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by jsprinkles on Friday June 01, 2012 @07:04PM (#4056314)
That child's doctors personally examined the child, have expertise to deal with the situation, and are aware of any details which are important. A HN commenter has not personally met either party, in most cases is not a lawyer so he does not have expertise to deal with the situation, and most importantly, are only aware of what one party has told them. There is a significant difference.
Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by detst on Friday June 01, 2012 @10:52PM (#4056835)
You should take a look at an exchange between that guy and a guy with the bio: "Software development, web design ; interested in movies, animation and humor." [1]

Should they both just shut up and let the big boys handle it? Or should he take another person's input and use his head to determine it's value? People are capable of offering valuable input without expertise and full details.

As PG said, "Don't trust stuff you read on forums." He didn't say ignore it. It might even save his son's life. I'm strongly inclined to believe this can work in law as it can work with extremely rare medical conditions.

[1] http://twitter.com/mattmight/status/207529584999153664

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by ColinWright on Friday June 01, 2012 @05:12PM (#4055810)

  > The idea that only lawyers can know anything
  > about the law, and therefore nobody else can
  > suggest avenues of investigation is shockingly
  > elitist.
My personal experience is that disclaimers such as you gave have very little legal standing, and that what you said can be regarded as legal advice, regardless of the "if"s, "but"s, "possibly"s, and "maybe"s that you so carefully sprinkled throughout.

You certainly can share what you know about these things, but advice given to me in the past about similar situations is that by doing so you can be regarded by some as taking some of the responsibility for the advice you think you haven't given.

The law is complicated, and while you may share what you know, doing so can put you personally at serious and considerable risk. Further, it doesn't always make sense to those who have not studied it (and sometimes even to those who have), so while what you have said may seem perfectly sensible, a lawyer may disagreed strongly with several of your suggestions, and following them may put the person you are trying to help in more trouble.

So despite the fact that you are trying to help, and despite the apparent soundness of your advice, you are not a lawyer, and there are very likely to be implications of which you are unaware. I applaud your willingness to take on the personal risk of what you said, but I am concerned that you are not helping, and may be making things worse.

Edited for clarity

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by guelo on Friday June 01, 2012 @05:56PM (#4056052)
> you can be regarded by some as taking some of the responsibility for the advice you think you haven't given

That sounds bogus to me, has anyone heard of any lawsuits of that type? That is, someone who is not a lawyer and is not presenting themselves as a lawyer being sued for giving bad legal advice?

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by jt2190 on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:28PM (#4056193)
If I understand correctly, no client-attorney relationship is established just by sharing your opinion of legal matters with someone.[1]

(edit: The rules are different if you are an attorney.)

(2nd edit: This debate seems to be about whether one can be held legally accountable if someone acts on your naive legal opinions and whether it's a good idea to share your legal opinions when--admit it--you really have no idea what you're talking about.[2] Then again, is it a good idea to follow free legal advice provided by a non-lawyer?)

[1] http://meta.answers.onstartups.com/questions/113/do-i- need-to-add-a-disclaimer-when-i-answer-a-question-on-this-site

[2]http://www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/episode/293/A...

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by ColinWright on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:58PM (#4056289)
So if I understand correctly, according to this, nirvana can offer advice without bothering to add any kinds of disclaimers (although he did), and everyone thinks that's completely fine, and can have no possible repercussions.

On the other hand, jsprinkles and I, when we offer comments about our personal experiences, and pass on to nirvana advice that we received from our actual lawyers, we're somehow in the wrong.

Just wanted to be clear. I will now be much more literal about the advice I got from my lawyers and comment no further on these matters.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by ColinWright on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:09PM (#4056098)

  > Do not meddle in the affairs of dragons,
  > for you are crunchy, and taste good with
  > ketchup.
I am passing on, almost verbatim, the advice I was given most strenuously. Included in that advice was the comment that not everything in legal circles passes the "That sounds right" test.

Certainly in this case, no, I can't quote cases where this has happened. But, you know, like, I'm not a lawyer. There are things that happen in legal circles that I don't know about, but which I have been given legal advice about.

So feel free to ignore it all and take a chance that you're right, and the advice given to me was misplaced. Heaven forbid that you should think I'm advising you.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by jsprinkles on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:14PM (#4056129)
I'll reiterate this for the benefit of context at this very location, but I have personal experience with a very similar scenario that I am not legally permitted to discuss; it was a situation of unsolicited advice resulting in consequences for people. I cannot say who. I think you'll find if it's a common experience, most people are (wisely) not going to discuss it.
Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by chris_wot on Friday June 01, 2012 @09:46PM (#4056674)
As someone else has asked you already, provide an example you were NOT personally involved in.

Also: I doubt that you can talk about the specifics of the case, but there should be nothing stopping you from quoting the court case so we could look it up ourselves.

Incidentally, it appears that are providing us with legal advise here. The legal advise is that we shouldn't provide legal advise.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by rprasad on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:40PM (#4056231)
Disclaimers have legal effect. If you include a disclaimer that you are not providing legal advice, and that your discussion is limited solely to specific issues (and may not include all issues raised by the fact pattern at hand), you will not be liable.

That does not mean you cannot be sued; anyone can be sued. But it does mean that you would win any lawsuit against.

I am a lawyer. (In my particular field, the magical disclaimer is the Circular 230 Notice regarding tax advice.)

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by ColinWright on Friday June 01, 2012 @07:02PM (#4056302)
Given that your advice is at odds with advice I have received in the past, I will now make no further attempts to share my experiences in these matters.

Thank you for being clear and specific.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by rprasad on Friday June 01, 2012 @11:59PM (#4056980)
Your experience is still relevant -- disclaimers don't work in every context. The danger is more relevant for a practitioner than a non-practitioner, since courts will interpret disclaiming language in favor of the "client".

However, based on your comment, it sounds more like you are referring to "hedging language" about the reliability of advice offered rather than an explicit disclaimers that the content is not legal advice.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by mighty_crown on Friday June 01, 2012 @10:13PM (#4056745)
I too am a lawyer and while I agree that disclaimers have legal effect, I disagree that including a disclaimer necessarily relieves one of liability. In my jurisdiction, what is more critical is whether the recipient of the information believes it to be legal advice and whether the giver of information should realize the recipient may so believe.
Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by rprasad on Friday June 01, 2012 @11:47PM (#4056955)
Same in Ohio and Cali; that is why the disclaimer must explicitly state that legal advice is not being provided. The key is that it must be reasonable for the recipient to believe that they are receiving legal advice. If they are explicitly told that they are not receiving legal advice, they cannot reasonably rely on what they are told.
Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by guelo on Friday June 01, 2012 @05:53PM (#4056024)
I agree. I have received plenty of awful advice from lawyers, especially when I only have a couple grand to spare, which this guy might not even want to spend considering it's a hobby. The idea that some cheap inexperienced lawyer is going to give better advice than HN which is full of experienced entrepreneurs with tons of business related legal experience is ridiculous.
Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by ricefield on Friday June 01, 2012 @04:56PM (#4055723)
> Imagine what HN would be like if only state approved programmers were allowed to have an opinion on technical subjects.

Programming and law are two completely different fields, each with its own sets of requirements, regulations, practice, and repercussions. Please don't try to make them out to be the same.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by marshray on Friday June 01, 2012 @08:04PM (#4056465)
It's called an "analogy". He didn't try to make them out to be the same. Personally, I feel it's an apt comparison and one that has occurred to me too many times.

The fact that each field has its "own set of requirements, regulations, practice, and repercussions" is obvious to everyone.

Perhaps a better way to respond to such an analogy is to explain how the similarities and differences make his analogy valid or invalid. That could be interesting and informative.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by malachismith on Friday June 01, 2012 @09:40PM (#4056665)
And it's ridiculously elitist that only brain surgeons get to cut people's brains open. I mean come on! Is this a democracy or not?!?!
Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by detst on Friday June 01, 2012 @08:03PM (#4056462)
Yeah, this is like using Wikipedia as a starting point in researching an unfamiliar topic. It might be poorly written and do more harm than good but likely you'll get enough from it to pursue further.

"Don't trust stuff you read on forums", as PG said; use your head and maybe you'll find something worth pursuing.

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by jsprinkles on Friday June 01, 2012 @04:52PM (#4055701)
> Imagine what HN would be like if only state approved programmers were allowed to have an opinion on technical subjects.

Technical subjects do not carry the risk of legal consequences in the general case, now do they?

Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by guelo on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:25PM (#4056174)
Sure they do, you can make technical decisions that ruin a company and that causes lawsuits (as many business deaths seem to). You can make technical decisions that get you sued for copyright, patent stuff, privacy violations, indecency laws, on and on. We all make legal decisions every day without having to consult a lawyer all the time.
Re:A VC-funded startup called WhosHere is trying to steal my... by jsprinkles on Friday June 01, 2012 @06:57PM (#4056283)
You skipped right over where I said "in the general case," as I am certainly aware that there are exceptions as you are pointing out. Specific legal advice is almost universally dangerous. Specific technical discussion is almost universally not.