News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by 29athrowaway on Saturday June 01, 2024 @02:24PM (#40547946)
The idea was to make Boeing compete with SpaceX.

SpaceX has already sent multiple crews to the ISS. Boeing is delayed and overbudget. Boeign has had a long series of problems including setting the system clock wrong.

Clearly SpaceX already won, NASA should just pull the plug on Boeing.

Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by Tuna-Fish on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:02PM (#40548248)
> Clearly SpaceX already won, NASA should just pull the plug on Boeing.

That would cost NASA a lot more money than continuing.

The contract is task order based. Boeing (and SpaceX) get paid for reaching some milestones, but mostly for launching the actual operational missions, of which Boeing is currently contracted for 6. Boeing had to front the development money for the system, and then gets paid back when they actually fly. This is in contrast with the traditional cost+ contracting, where Boeing just tallies costs and gets paid that plus a fixed profit margin.

At this point, Boeing has reached all the milestones and gotten paid for them, but hasn't flown any of the operational missions, and has spent billions more than they've been paid to develop the system. If NASA cancels now without a clear reason listed in the contract, Boeing has a clean case for contract violation against them, and can sue for the spent development money. Delays are not an appropriate reason, so long as Boeing isn't unduly endangering the crew they can just keep trying. But they are not getting paid any money from NASA for any of this, every day that the program continues but they are not launching the actual paid 6 missions, they are just wasting their own money.

Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by mjevans on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:20PM (#40548358)
It's sort of like a game of chicken in that respect...

I guess Boeing would have to do the math and figure out that paying SpaceX for 6 ISS missions is a cheaper way of fulfilling the contract?

Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by Tuna-Fish on Saturday June 01, 2024 @04:18PM (#40548769)
They don't even have to do that. As I understand it, they freely have the option to keep the money paid for them so far and just inform NASA that they are not flying the 6 operational missions, and shut it down.

The reason not to do that is that as stated above, most of the money in the contract is in those operational missions. Even if the contract will lose them money in total, if they think it will cost less to complete starting from right now than what those 6 pay out, it will make economical sense to keep trying.

Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by 29athrowaway on Saturday June 01, 2024 @05:29PM (#40549228)
Thanks for the clarification here. Now it makes more sense.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by PopePompus on Saturday June 01, 2024 @07:54PM (#40550159)
Why aren't delays an appropriate reason? Is that explicitly in the contracts?
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by sandis on Saturday June 01, 2024 @02:31PM (#40548007)
The idea wasn't to have them compete. The idea is to have "dissimilar redundancy", so that the US still would have a human-rated launch system with the ability to go to the ISS in case one of them gets grounded for whatever reason.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by kjkjadksj on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:02PM (#40548244)
While that seems prudent, at the same time for how many years have we been beholden to russian launches because we didn’t have an american system at all after the shuttle? Seems like the sky didn’t fall during that time despite only one launch system we had to go to Kazakhstan to borrow. Kind of hard to justify the cost to the tax payer when the benefit they get is effectively zero since no new capabilities are present really: we could launch people to iss before and we can do that now too.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by dralley on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:37PM (#40548468)
The cost, politically and otherwise of relying on the Russians now is much higher than it was 15 years ago.

And in any case Russia's entire space program is at risk of going under given the budget issues they're going to be dealing with.

Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by kube-system on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:12PM (#40548301)
Given today's political climate, that seems extremely risky, especially since Russia has already officially announced the intent to discontinue cooperating with the ISS program

And besides, the purpose of aerospace spending on human spaceflight isn't just for the purpose of human spaceflight, but also for related capabilities.

Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by kjkjadksj on Saturday June 01, 2024 @04:31PM (#40548843)
Right, I forget we still burn billions on that nuclear arsenal capable of glassing the planet in a half hour should some 75 year olds in dc decide that is prudent.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by kube-system on Saturday June 01, 2024 @06:04PM (#40549442)
Yes but before you get too snarky, we also do other things like provide free navigation services and weather forecasts.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by geertj on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:02PM (#40548247)
Yes, also referred to as “Assured Access.”
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by ericcumbee on Saturday June 01, 2024 @04:02PM (#40548641)
Boeing was supposed to be the safe pick and spaceX the risky one that might not pan out.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by ethagknight on Saturday June 01, 2024 @02:30PM (#40547997)
Competition is good, unfortunate that NASA picked a know abuser of govt contracting for the competitor.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by dylan604 on Saturday June 01, 2024 @02:43PM (#40548074)
It takes more than one to compete though. Right now, we have one and only one that actually works, and then some people floundering around taking government funding to do nothing really to justify anything.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by delfinom on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:20PM (#40548352)
NASA has no choice. Boeing is a political requirement.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by bryanlarsen on Saturday June 01, 2024 @04:34PM (#40548867)
Northrup would also have been a politically feasible choice.
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by readams on Saturday June 01, 2024 @02:30PM (#40548001)
53 people across 13 launches for SpaceX
Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by robomartin on Saturday June 01, 2024 @03:53PM (#40548575)
> The idea was to make Boeing compete with SpaceX.

Not quite. Results aside, the idea is that the government wants multiple sources for access to orbit. This isn't so much about competition but rather about having options. I have no idea if there are other political elements to this at all.

And so, ULA gets funding because they represent that other potential option. They can be as inefficient and slow as they want because, in a sense, their metric is to exist as backup. And, for backup to exist, you have to fund it not just to have things designed and built. You have to use these things despite cost and performance issues for readiness considerations.

Conceptually, it makes sense. The execution, in my opinion, is seriously lacking in many ways.

Re:Boeing and NASA call off Starliner crew launch minutes be... by TMWNN on Saturday June 01, 2024 @02:37PM (#40548030)
By contrast, Marcus Wandt of Sweden:

* Nov 2022 - Chosen as reserve ESA astronaut

* Jun 2023 - Chosen for Ax-3 mission using SpaceX Crew Dragon

* Jan 2024 - Flies to ISS