Programs speak to filesystems.
1. Some people want file systems to case sensitive. 2. Case sensitive is easier to implement. This is very much not a trivial thing. Case insensitivity only really makes sense for ASCII.
In the camp of wanting case insensitivity:
1. Some people want file systems to be case insensitive.
There is more in favor of case sensitivity.
But no filesystem I am aware of is actually homoglyph insensitive.
Case insensitive filesystems picked one arbitrary form of intuition (and not even the .oat obvious one) in one language (English) and baked that into the OS at a somewhat deep level.
You say "human intuition" - are those using different writing systems nonhuman then?
Now, as you said, UNIX did the choice that's easier for computers. And for computers, case-insensitive filesystems would be worse. There are things that are definitely strange about UNIX filesystems (who doesn't love linefeeds in file names!?), but case-sensitivity is not one of them.
This is just one of many cases, where case-insensitiy would give more trouble than it's worth. And others pointed out similar cases with the Turkish language in this post.