News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by vessenes on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:19PM (#40516518)
I’m mystified as to two things here: first that people feel this is ‘open and shut’ in Ms Johannsen’s favor, and second that this hasn’t been settled economically.

IF: OpenAI had advertised SJ as being a voice, had sold the plus subscription with that voice as a benefit, and had instructed talent scouting and internal editors to ‘copy her’ then this would be open and shut. We know for sure the first part did not happen: if there’s a case then discovery will tell us the second part.

If on the other hand they chose the voice for sky because they liked the actors natural voice, whether or not it was because they were reminded of SJ that is anything but open and shut- in fact it seems very difficult to me; a judge must determine that another actor cannot work at all, even if she makes no attempt to sound alike, sell as SJ, all through a platform that shows undeniable value regardless of voice. Guys, SJ is beautiful and likable. But this is a big ask of a credible federal judge.

As to money, I’m also mystified why they can’t ink a deal like: the largest single film voice acting payment is roughly $15mm. Let’s do a deal where we use your actual voice (which I would say is obviously different than sky) and rev share 50/50 with you on premium purchases, 50mm guaranteed year one.

It seems to me like this would open up the best possible world where people can have gpt4o talk with the voice of whatever actor that’s licensed, and these actors have a new distribution vehicle that’s valuable. Again SJ may not want to license for whatever reason she chooses, but I bet that OpenAI didn’t make a serious rev share offer, and I think they should.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by tsimionescu on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:26PM (#40516607)
For the first part, you're forgetting the "her" tweet, and the attempts of getting SJ to sell them her voice as recently as two days before they launched her sound-alike. And we know they thought it's a soundalike because they immediately changed it once the scandal started.

For the second part, you're assuming that they just didn't offer enough money. It's very likely instead that SJ didn't want to associate her brand with this business.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by michaelbuckbee on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:33PM (#40516693)
To add on to your comment, in the arts and creative space there are substantial levels of opposition to AI as it's perceived as a job killer and maybe at some level perverse or akin to an automated plagiarism system that steals their intellectual property (this is complicated and not my personal take, but I see where they're coming from).

It's quite likely that SJ would suffer from severe reputational damage from being the literal voice of AI.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by vessenes on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @10:05PM (#40519392)
I'm not forgetting "Her", and I think it's in-bounds to say a company is inspired by / referencing a film in PR -- I can list quite a few SV startups that directly tie their DNA to an inspiring book or film, and heretofore that's generally not considered objectionable. (For instance, Paypal / Cryptonomicon).

The sky voice has been part of the app since the launch, it was not newly launched for GPT4o.

You're missing a key step in your logic chain: That they pulled the voice when SJ made a public complaint does not imply that they thought it was a soundalike, or that they documented they were making a soundalike, or that a soundalike is wrong, or that they thought they were doing something wrong when they hired the Sky voice actor. It just means that they pulled the Sky voice on public request from SJ.

That, combined with SJ reports that she turned down a licensing deal, and WaPo reporting that the Sky voice actor sounds like the voice delivered in ChatGPT, are pretty much the only facts we have right now.

As to SJ brand decisions -- maybe. I would bet the offer was low / not discussed, instead of it being substantial. But, that is also speculation.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by ml-anon on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @06:29PM (#40517822)
Why the fuck would one of the most famous people on the planet who is already phenomenally wealthy want to be the voice of a company that has already maligned her for an application that people are already demonstrating the use of to have sexually explicit conversations.

Anyone signing up to your revenue sharing scheme is going to be all over the internet saying the most vile things imaginable.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by mateus1 on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:24PM (#40516583)
It’s not just a matter of the voice being a 1:1 match with Johansenns’s or that it used it as an input to build the model. What is definitive is that Open AI intently based this on the film Her as per docs and tweets && they used her voice similarity after being declined more than once.
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by opello on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:36PM (#40516740)
On the sound alike front it seems like attribution must resolve this since it can't possibly be reasonable to deny access to the marketplace of voice work because someone else that you sound like "got there first"?
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by vessenes on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @10:07PM (#40519411)
Exactly.
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by bobthepanda on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:36PM (#40516736)
commercial benefit for copyright is not limited to literally selling things but also covers ads and publicity.

the legal system may be asked to consider if a press release for a new model counts as advertising, and if implying a connection to Her was a significant part of said advertisement.

the fact that it does not cost money does not make it legal. PETA can't go around running its mouth saying "Beyonce supports PETA and banning pets" when she's said no such thing.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by williamcotton on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:42PM (#40516787)
A voice seems to be covered by trademark as opposed to copyright.

Two people can naturally have a very similar voice and it would be pretty absurd to have someone not allowed to use their own voice.

It isn’t absurd for someone in a specific industry to have their voice protected within that trade.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by bobthepanda on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @06:51PM (#40518027)
Publicity rights are distinct from both copyright and trademark. In California, they basically have the same protections, lifetime + 70 years. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_Celebrities_Rights_...

In 1988, Midler v. Ford Motor Co was decided in favor of Bette Midler after Ford hired an impersonator for their commercials. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Midler_v._Ford_Motor_Co.

Tom Waits won a lawsuit against Frito Lay for a radio commercial where they hired a impersonator. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1990-05-09-me-238-st...

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by vessenes on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @09:54PM (#40519326)
I'm aware of both of those -- this voice actor is not a "Johannsen sound-alike" actor. And she is not reciting lines from "Her". It's a significant difference, and there are real harms to any actor not already 'famous' implied by the sort of ruling people here think is obvious -- it's a big leap to say "The Federal Government will not allow you to work because you sound too much like X and so other person, signed, Judge Alsop."
Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by vessenes on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @09:59PM (#40519354)
I agree; one's voice should be protected, generally.

However, I do not agree that one should be able to stamp out use of any voice one person deems 'too similar' from plying that trade. This would be pretty surprising; it raises numerous questions of fair play, who decides, whether the courts wish to be in the position of making these determinations, and ultimately, I think the balance of equity is against making a broad decision like this, full stop. People have the right to work, and especially have the right to work in a fair environment where they are not unduly taking advantage of other's rights and trademarks.

Marilyn Monroe did not have rights to ban women from blonde curls, or beauty marks, Bettie Page did not have the ability to stop numerous lookalikes from selling pinup photos; this is the same situation.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by vessenes on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @10:14PM (#40519452)
So, to be clear, I think you could launch a company that was like "It's 100% exactly as good as the movie Her. Seen the movie Her? This is like that AI. You can download it here", and not legally owe a penny. The concept of the AI in Her is not something that the makers of the film own, and companies are inspired by creative works of all sorts all the time when they make things. This is considered good in American business law.

Agreed that an endorsement, express or implied, is usually something the endorser has rights over.

So, in this case, from your perspective, you'd need to prove that people understood such an endorsement to have happened, and if you want damages, that it benefitted the company and/or harmed the endorser.

On these terms, the facts we know don't seem terrible for OpenAI - they negotiated in good faith for the endorsement, and when she went public / gave a final 'no' they pulled the voice, which apparently was not created by a copycat voice actor, but instead by another woman that SJ claims sounds identical to her. OpenAI has not summarily fallen over or gone bankrupt, in fact, the app that caused controversy hasn't launched yet.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by bobthepanda on Thursday May 30, 2024 @02:41AM (#40520817)
Personality rights in California also cover the right to persona, as in a specific person acting as a specific character. You can sound like ScarJo to some extent, but ScarJo does own her performance of Her and anything like that. Daniel Craig is allowed to be James Bond, but Daniel Craig is not allowed to pretend to be Sean Connery playing James Bond.

And of course there can be impersonators, but there is a world of difference between hiring an impersonator for the express purpose of impersonating where everyone knows that is the case, vs. hiring an impersonator to imply commercial endorsement from the original person.

A commercial endorsement does not require that it be the sole form of endorsement or that it even be financially positive. Ford was running more than one ad campaign when Bette Midler sued and won, and Frito Lay was in a similar boat with Tom Waits.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by vessenes on Thursday May 30, 2024 @10:02AM (#40523850)
Yes to all this. Where we are at right now is: guy with scottish accent is available in an app and his name is "Clay". Owner of app tweets how Bond was inspiring to him making the app.

If it can be shown in court that Sky is an impersonation and that SJ is ruled to have endorsed whether through tweets from Sam, or the Sky voice, and that she suffered some damage or that OpenAI benefited in some way before taking it down, then I think she would likely win some money in damages. Unless all those are true, it seems tough to get more than she already got -- a quick removal of the voice.

Few people mention the existing Sky voice actor (whose agent has held her name for safety concerns) is harmed here, quite substantially, by the idea that SJ could control her own performance. At any rate, my point at the top of all this is just that this is not 'open and shut' and I'm not even sure OpenAI has been more than 'aggressive' so far in its launch; we might found out they were, but I don't think the facts on the ground show more than that right now.

Re:What Scarlett Johansson vs. OpenAI Could Look Like in Court by bobthepanda on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:19PM (#40528141)
i think people don't mention the existing sky voice actor, because in these kind of cases it is never the actual impersonator getting sued or found liable. in fact, if there were something problematic here, it could be entirely possible that OpenAI kept the voice actress in the dark about the intent of the performance and they would still have a legal problem.