News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by mmastrac on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:38PM (#40458222)
The whole drama was pretty silly, and the fact that everyone got upset that a feature that is inactive by default, consumes no processing power, memory or anything else and bullied the author of the open-source program should make everyone unhappy.

This is why open-source maintainers burn out and we can't have nice things. Honestly, people, please consider the human on the other side of the toxic discourse.

Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by boringg on Thursday May 23, 2024 @03:04PM (#40458592)
Agree - it really speaks to the issues around AI and how wrought that conversation has become. To your point that it is turned of by default - you have to opt in if you want it.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by rsynnott on Friday May 24, 2024 @08:08AM (#40465327)
It's mere possible presence would probably be enough to get iTerm banned from more security-conscious companies, tho.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by WhereIsTheTruth on Thursday May 23, 2024 @03:16PM (#40458767)
Nobody likes when a company (commercial-proprietary) sneaks in your tools, either directly or indirectly

Who knows if there was a deal made under the hood

Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by ThrowawayTestr on Thursday May 23, 2024 @06:09PM (#40460472)
What deal? You can literally just read the source code if you don't trust the developer.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by atkailash on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:40PM (#40458258)
Exactly. You have to provide it your own API key. If you don’t want it, don’t put it in and bam, no problem
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by mhurron on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:57PM (#40458487)
Except that it can be. As was pointed out in the original issue to remove it, the feature is not disabled, it is unconfigured. Put anything in the box for the OpenAI key, valid or not, and the functionality to send data to OpenAI is active. Accidentally put a [space] in that box and it looks like there is nothing there, but it's doing things you didn't expect.

That was the wrong way to do it. The feature should have been disabled with an actual, clear toggle that shows that it is. This blew up in the developers face for a good reason.

Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by stnmtn on Thursday May 23, 2024 @03:32PM (#40458913)
You still have to take the action to enable the AI features even if you just have a " " character in that field, no? It doesn't send anything to openAI until you open the prompt for it to do so.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by mhurron on Thursday May 23, 2024 @04:17PM (#40459398)
At the moment it appears that way, but that is still the wrong action. An unconfigured field is not a disabled function and there is no way in iTerm to disable the functionality. Also, the 'prompt to use OpenAI' is not OpenAI specific, it is a new button in a previous function that you could use in earlier versions for completely non-openai purposes. There isn't a OpenAI specific prompt area.

If you leave the field empty (open to accident) and you don't press this button in this function that you may use for other things (open to accident) it doesn't send data where you didn't expect it to. This is functionally equivalent to you can accidentally send data you didn't mean to. This is simply prevented with a real toggle to disable the function.

I don't know about you, but I have clicked on things I didn't mean to because I lost where the mouse is, or because I'm giving a window focus again, it is not an accident that doesn't happen.

Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by stnmtn on Friday May 24, 2024 @11:08AM (#40466995)
You can accidentally click on this checkbox you're talking about, then accidentally click on the UI element that opens up the AI prompting mechanism, then accidentally type something in and send it as well. I don't understand this
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by soraminazuki on Thursday May 23, 2024 @07:15PM (#40461038)
> the feature is not disabled, it is unconfigured

It doesn't do anything at all unless you actively engage with it. This is sophistry at its finest.

> Put anything in the box for the OpenAI key, valid or not, and the functionality to send data to OpenAI is active.

No it isn't. Nothing happens until you bring up the Codecierge toolbox and type in a question.

Also, from your later comment:

> 'prompt to use OpenAI' is not OpenAI specific, it is a new button in a previous function that you could use in earlier versions

You just made that one up, the Codecierge UI is entirely new.

Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by vasachi on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:46PM (#40458344)
Say they introduce a bug, that will try to call that API even when there is no key.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by moloch on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:47PM (#40458361)
Say they introduce a bug, that deletes every file on your machine.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by shawnz on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:55PM (#40458457)
Not even that unlikely, for example consider the well known `rm -rf $STEAMROOT/*` bug in Steam some years ago
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by adrianN on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:48PM (#40458369)
If you're afraid that programs on your computer leak your data, run them in a sandbox with limited permissions.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by Suzuran on Thursday May 23, 2024 @03:00PM (#40458530)
This is what was claimed was happening. I received multiple warnings that iTerm2 was sending "all terminal interactions" to OpenAI's servers regardless of the absence of an API key. Packet captures showing "exfiltrated" data were represented as proof when those were created with an invalid API key, not a blank API key.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by jedberg on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:48PM (#40458379)
It's still an opt-in feature. The bug would have to be so bad that it calls that API even with the feature off.
Re:iTerm2 removes AI feature from core, creates separate plugin by brysonreece on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:48PM (#40458366)
And? Say your bank introduces a bug that siphons all your money; that’s the risk of operating in a digital age.