News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI and Scarlett Johansson's Voice by theultdev on Thursday May 23, 2024 @09:31AM (#40454483)
Ford hired impersonators, she's not an impersonator, that's her real voice.

She's allowed to be a voice actor using her real voice.

Your can point to the "Her" tweet, but it's a pretty flimsy argument.

Re:OpenAI and Scarlett Johansson's Voice by Matticus_Rex on Thursday May 23, 2024 @09:51AM (#40454720)
This is correct, and is very different from both the Midler and Waits cases. The courts are never going to tell a voice actor she can't use her real voice because she sounds too much like a famous person.

And besides, it sounds more like Rashida Jones anyway. It's clearly not an impersonation.

Re:OpenAI and Scarlett Johansson's Voice by BeefWellington on Thursday May 23, 2024 @08:52PM (#40461735)
They are unlikely to tell the voice actor anything, since OpenAI is the problematic party here.
Re:OpenAI and Scarlett Johansson's Voice by senorrib on Thursday May 23, 2024 @09:49AM (#40454694)
Whether the actor was an impersonator or not is still up to debate. I can see an argument being made when you consider the entire context.
Re:OpenAI and Scarlett Johansson's Voice by theultdev on Thursday May 23, 2024 @10:32AM (#40455220)
I don't see any argument considering the entire context, care to explain?
Re:OpenAI and Scarlett Johansson's Voice by krisoft on Thursday May 23, 2024 @01:47PM (#40457712)
> Your can point to the "Her" tweet, but it's a pretty flimsy argument.

I'm not making arguments which are not already explicitly written in my post.

My argument is simple: jorvi commented that you can hire "a real-life voice actress" to "try to imitate Scarlett Johansson’s voice as best as she could", and that is not illegal.

I said that the legality of that is more complicated. What jorvi describes might or might not be illegal based on various factors. And I pointed them towards the two references to support my argument.

I explicitly didn't say in that comment anything about the OpenAI/ScarJo case. You are reacting as if you think that I have some opinion about it. You are wrong, and it would be better if you would not try to guess my state of mind. If I have some opinion about something you will know because I will explicitly state it.