News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Stop asking “But how will they make money?” by wpietri on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @02:45PM (#4044194)
Oh god.

I just mentored at a startup event this weekend. Half the teams had no idea how they were going to make money. None. They were building products, not businesses. Many of them were subconsciously hoping that the VC fairies would visit them, and then 18 months later somebody would buy them. "Instragram!", they cried. And then I cried.

Facebook is the worst possible business to use as an example here. They are an outlier, a once-a-decade company. Building an actual ad-supported business these days requires you get massive amounts of traffic quickly, and that means that a very large percentage of your brainpower will be devoted to user acquisition, ad network optimization, and trying to decide how you feel about auto-play video ads and popunders. That is, you will always be thinking but how will we make money?

It also kills me that when talking about ways one makes money he mentions Stripe, Boku, and Kickstarter in the same breath with ad networks. Those are not business models. They are just ways that money travels. It's like saying one's business model is accepting checks.

His post, if it's relevant to anybody, is only relevant to a very small number of businesses that will take $10m-100m in venture funding and are doing something so trivial that nobody is willing to pay money for it. It's ridiculous.

Re:Stop asking “But how will they make money?” by cube13 on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @03:32PM (#4044429)
>It also kills me that when talking about ways one makes money he mentions Stripe, Boku, and Kickstarter in the same breath with ad networks. Those are not business models. They are just ways that money travels. It's like saying one's business model is accepting checks.

I came here to post this. Kickstarter's intent is to assist with bootstrapping a product. It's not monetization. It's a way to get the capital to produce something. They answer the question "It's going to cost $100,000 to make a batch of our widgets/books/etc. Is there enough of a market to actually sell that number?"

Stripe, Amazon Payments, Google Checkout, etc. are payment processors. Again, they're not monetization. They're there to get money from customers hands into your hands. They're the answer to "We want to sell this, how can we get our customer's money?"

But even if you're using those methods to provide answers to those questions, the fundamental question still remains: "What are you selling, and how do you sell it?"

THAT is where the business model comes in. If you cannot answer that question, I seriously question your entire startup.

Re:Stop asking “But how will they make money?” by wpietri on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @06:24PM (#4045215)
Agreed 100%.

The thing that really kills me about this: cluelessness about one's business model can be an adaptive trait in a bubble. When the situation is crazy, sanity is not a virtue.

A post like this makes a good Exhibit A in a case that we're in Bubble 2.0.

Re:Stop asking “But how will they make money?” by joelrunyon on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @03:16PM (#4044343)
>It also kills me that when talking about ways one makes money he mentions Stripe, Boku, and Kickstarter in the same breath with ad networks. Those are not business models. They are just ways that money travels. It's like saying one's business model is accepting checks.

This. I'm really having a hard time seeing how these are relevant at all. They're ways to accept/raise money - not generate it.

Re:Stop asking “But how will they make money?” by 127001brewer on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @03:30PM (#4044412)
Great comment: ...are doing something so trivial that nobody is willing to pay money for it.

I have had many conversations with inspiring entrepreneurs that thought building a relatively simple product/service "supported" by advertising would instantly generate millions (or "gazillions").

I'm curious, though, what is your company's business model? Is it an ad-supported business?

Re:Stop asking “But how will they make money?” by wpietri on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @06:20PM (#4045203)
Good question.

I can't talk about my current company's business model, although anybody looking at it would say that ads are certainly one plausible candidate. For what it's worth, the last company I helped start is ad supported, as is one I worked on in the 1995-2000 timeframe. Before that, I consulted a lot for publishers. (The old kind, whose business plans started with: first we slice the trees real thin.)

I say that to demonstrate that I'm not entirely knocking ad-supported businesses. They can be a great way to pay for something that is otherwise hard to monetize. But I also know how hard they are to get to scale, and I know there's a difference between them and businesses that fill a need strong enough that people are willing to open their wallets.

So in sum, I'm ok with ad revenue as a business model. But I hate, hate, hate people using it as a fairy tale so that people can pretend they don't need to think about their business model.

Re:Stop asking “But how will they make money?” by wpietri on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @06:42PM (#4045273)
And thinking further, "something so trivial" sounds too harsh. I don't mean it that way; I consume plenty of unpaid media that I like. I even like Facebook, and use it daily.

But I think the fact that ad-supported businesses need millions of users says something: the value delivered to each user is pretty small.