News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

A comment on The Reign of Alexander III of Macedon, the Great?. Parent comment

Re:The Reign of Alexander III of Macedon, the Great? by worldvoyageur on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @08:43AM (#40427694)
> I suppose my question is: How do you know this? Alexander was surrounded by hand-picked men his father had groomed for decades in some cases. Offering council on every part of war fighting, from tactics to strategy to logistics. Isn't it entirely possible Alexander simply went with the flow of wiser, more experienced men telling him what to do?

Alexander did inherit a superb army. However, while he was present the army enjoyed spectacular operational and battlefield success. Once Alexander was gone, the successes also stopped.

[ Parent | on HN ]
Re:The Reign of Alexander III of Macedon, the Great? by lolinder on Tuesday May 21, 2024 @10:45AM (#40429166)
> Once Alexander was gone, the successes also stopped.

While true, this doesn't necessarily preclude the hypothesis that Alexander's generals were the real power behind the throne. The successes stopped around the time that the Macedonian armies started fighting each other and trying to actually rule the areas that they conquered. This could easily be explained by the generals being all roughly equally competent at commanding soldiers and also simultaneously being distracted by affairs of state and so drawn away from expansion into non-Macedonian territory.

[ Parent | on HN ]