Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by swombat on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @07:45AM
(#4042356)
Even though this is hardly HN material, there's some kind of hackerish mindset about reacting to accusations by doing an in-depth "pot, kettle, black" report about the accuser, so I upvoted this.
For those of us who keep track of US news, it's pretty obvious that the human rights situation there is "variable", to say the least. You rarely hear about people being wrongly killed by the police in Europe, whereas in the US it appears to be relatively frequent. As for freedom... let's not go there. The easily manipulated US government is probably the single most important political force for evil in the fight to protect our rights online.
Anyway, so, totally off-topic, but a smart approach from China...
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by jonnathanson on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:06AM
(#4042406)
With all due respect, this is a tall order of false equivalence. The US's track record on human rights, income inequality, etc., is far from spotless. It's borderline infuriating at times. But even to place it in the same ballpark as the PRC's is silly.
Consider that, in the US, people were able to protest and stop SOPA and PIPA from coming to pass. In China, the government controls the entire internet. It's actually debatable that we could be having a similar conversation about the government, on a site like this one, were we in China right now. The U.S. detains certain people without warrant or trial in its misguided "war on terror." But the PRC can detain any of its citizens, at any time, for any reason, and often does.
It's interesting to consider the hypocrisies and inconsistencies of our own government and society. I'm all for it. But we shouldn't lose sight of reality.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by Morg on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:18AM
(#4042430)
With all due respect, you are blinded by the kool aid my dear.
In the US the government controls the entire internet, as well as every information every company holds, including facebook, twitter, google and apple - as well as Intel and Microsoft.
The PRC and the US both have "legitimate" ways to detain any citizen or non-citizen at any time, for any reason, and often do.
I would like to insist that there is NO difference on that specific point since the patriot act.
SOPA and PIPA aren't govt related, they're big content's attempt at having it's own control channel over the internet.
By the way, you forget the positive aspects of China, like those emphasized in the article: In a communist country, there's real security.
My grandparents were in USSR in the 70's, and many like them said they had absolutely NO FEAR AT ALL letting their kids play outside.
That's right dream on. You'll never get that in the US, unless you have your own security.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by adventureful on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:43AM
(#4042511)
I grew up in an area in Maryland with nearly zero crime (and it was a modestly poor area). I went to one of the best public schools in Maryland, and again, it was in what is considered poor Appalachia. So I'm not sure what you're talking about. The only crime where I live now, is driving under the influence. There's 1 murder per year per 100,000 people in the entire county.
You obviously have extremely little first hand experience with America. Look up the crime stats for Boise, Idaho some time on city data. America is an extraordinarily diverse nation, the most diverse nation in world history to be exact, and it has every sort of living style and environment you could want to choose from.
Don't like the crime in Chicago, move to a safer city at your leisure. Seattle is beautiful, and so is Austin TX. Don't like Florida? Move to Virginia. Don't like Vermont, move to NYCity. Don't like NYC? Move to San Francisco. Don't like urban, America is massive and extremely low population density, so move rural. And on and on.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by adventureful on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @09:01AM
(#4042571)
Drucken & Morg:
You'll note that in no way have I said China doesn't have exactly the same, safe rural areas, or even safe urban areas.
What I said is: America does have those things. My response was to point out that the notion of America being nothing but a giant crime wave or an extraordinarily dangerous place is pure myth. The reality is: America has just about everything, pick what kind of life you want accordingly, and pursue it.
And Morg: the points about Europe would be interesting, except most of Europe allows exceptionally little immigration. So how can outsiders even consider benefiting even if it were the safest place on earth crime wise?
Look up the immigration rates for: Denmark, Finland, Sweden, Germany, Switzerland, Belgium, Norway, etc. I'm sure you already know this however. Then look up America's extreme immigration over the past 100 years. How do you think 20% of our population got to be hispanic? We have a long history of allowing a relatively high amount of immigration (particularly compared to the rest of the world). It's how we become the world's melting pot.
It's not easy to get into America, but it's radically easier than becoming a citizen of most European nations just based on the extremely limited numbers they allow in.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by Morg on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @09:43AM
(#4042757)
That would be because we don't just allow them in> when they get in they get social protection, not just the right to pay taxes.
Racism imho is one of the minor issues though, I'm far more concerned by the police state aspects of the US than the cultural details (such as everyone is fat woohooo).
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by adventureful on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @09:59AM
(#4042828)
That's a snarky comment, but you're dodging: what I'm talking about is legal immigration. America has a much higher rate of legal immigration than pretty much all of Europe. Canada is one of the few first world nations with a higher immigration rate. When you legally immigrate to America, you're treated as a citizen. We've had a lot of illegal immigration over the last 20 years as well, but the odds strongly favor that those illegal immigrants will be naturalized into citizenship over time, it's very likely the Democrats will achieve that outcome.
And if you want to talk about shadow immigration, or people that fall through the cracks, Europe has plenty of that. You must know that. Take a look at the African immigration in France and Spain over the last 20 years, and then look at how many are under the radar. Europe also gets a massive amount of abuse from immigrants that leech off the social systems and never work and contribute properly, which is helping to make the looming EU bankruptcy even worse, which is amping up the rapidly rising xenophobia currently going on Europe, such that the Nazi Party is rising in Greece, and the extreme right is gaining in many nations.
The whoohoo on your fat comment certainly betrays to the flippant nature of it. 26% to 27% of people in the UK are obese, in America it's about 33%. Australia and New Zealand is around 24% to 25%. Chile is 25%. Ireland is 23% to 24%. Canada is 25% obese as well. Mexico is about the same as America on obesity. Clearly the problem is greatest in America, but it's hardly alone in the obesity problem.
If you've ever read the book, The China Study, you obviously understand why these countries have such obesity and higher cancer rates that, for example, China has traditionally avoided. However, now China is gradually switching to a killer western diet, particularly among the affluent, and they're seeing skyrocketing obesity and heart disease rates.
You're concerned about the police state aspects of America? So am I, I live here, and it's very disturbing. China is a police state almost by definition, but that doesn't seem to concern you at all. And the police state is rising all over the place, take a look at some of the police state actions and laws being passed in Britain where you practically can't step out your front door without showing up on a cctv.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by phreeza on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @07:47AM
(#4042362)
Thats why I posted it. I was a bit surprised seeing it made the front page, but I thought it was interesting to see this in basically the same language usually used to describe China.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by metatronscube on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:09AM
(#4042409)
What do you mean? In terms of population? Europe is around 700 million and the US is what 400 million at the most and China is even larger.
So given the population trails behind China and Europe, human rights in the US don't look that rosy (neither does the UK for that matter). I mean the US has for some time had the largest prison population on the planet. I'm just putting that out there as well, and try to understand what you are getting at?
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by Morg on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:10AM
(#4042411)
China is incredibly larger for same culture/language population numbers, yet it doesn't have half the issues.
While this is all propaganda and the article clearly avoids some details, the truth is the situation is really bad and Chinese people have no reason to look up to the US, as much as US people have no reason to look down on China.
Right now, as an European, I'd rather live in China than in the US.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by adventureful on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:22AM
(#4042444)
China doesn't have half the issues? That a lie, and then some.
There's a very good reason Chen Guangcheng desperately wanted to escape China.
China has every bit the racism and nationalism problems that America has. Ask China what they think of the Japanese some time.
China is surely very willing to leave the peaceful, successful nation of Taiwan alone, right? It's not like they have any intention of brutally, viciously conquering the island when it's convenient, invading and murdering its people all in the name of reclaiming land that acted as a safe haven for Chinese fleeing from the genocide of Mao (Mao having killed tens of millions of his own people).
China is massively belligerent and violent. Should we free Tibet? Oh right, Tibet doesn't really exist any more because they gradually cleansed the entire country of its people and culture.
China has radically worse inequality, 3/4 of a billion people living on $1 to $2 dollars per day, half a billion people without proper access to sanitary drinking water or indoor plumbing. China still has half of the poorest 10% of people on the entire planet, meanwhile they're printing billionaires along the eastern coast.
China has no systems comparable to medicare, medicaid, or social security. As faulty as they may be in the US, China doesn't even have a real social safety net at all.
Chinese workers have absolutely zero rights, and there are no rights to unionize.
China has almost zero property rights at all.
There is no right to democratic representation in China.
There is zero freedom of speech in China.
China is even more violent, with mass executions in large stadiums just to clear out crime numbers, regardless of whether those executed are in fact the guilty. 5,000 people were slaughtered execution style in 2009 alone, roughly 50,000 people per decade are killed in execution fashion by the Chinese Government. Texas by comparison executes about 25 people per year, and that gets endless press.
China routinely locks down entire villages. Over 200 riots were reported last year alone. They shut off all access to the external world, and proceed to haul off the trouble makers to gulag camps for political prisoners.
The propaganda that China doesn't have half the problems of the US is complete bunk.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by metatronscube on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @10:05AM
(#4042855)
Half of your points here are completely crap, and the other half are just outdated or inaccurate. I think you need to take the blinders off your eyes are wake up. Its a fact that China has lifted about 400 million of its own people out of poverty (a fact that even the EU says is probably one of the most remarkable things of the last 30 years)
The life expectancy of the average Chinese citizen has increased by about 3 years since 1990 to 71.4 which is 5 years (or there about)above the world average and 6-7years above the average level in developing countries. The US health care system is a joke in many other countries so you cant say that it comes anywhere as close.
I can say that having friends/family that have lived/worked Europe/UK, China and the US and I would say that the US is probably the very worst place out of the lot when it comes to basic freedoms. When I think of propaganda, no one does it better than the good old US of A.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by adventureful on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @10:39AM
(#4042994)
Oh yes, obviously I'm 100% wrong, that's real likely (50% crap and 50% outdated or inaccurate). How convenient that I'm 100% wrong. You're being disingenuous to say the least, and it paints your statements in an extraordinarily bad light.
China having lifted 400 million of its people out of poverty is based on a $1 per day rate of poverty. And it says nothing to the fact that they still have 3/4 of a billion people living on $1 to $2 per day, which is what I said and it is accurate. Would you like me to provide you with the most recent WHO and UN numbers? Are you not aware of what they actually are?
My information is not bunk or out of date. Here, a story about China raising the rural poverty rate from $0.55 / day or less to $1 per day or less. Sure sounds like they have no extreme poverty problems eh:
You say the US health care system is a joke? China doesn't even have a real healthcare system for the bottom billion of its people, and it doesn't have a social safety net at all.
America's life expectancy is nearly 10% higher than China's, despite our obesity and heart disease problems.
Your ad hominen attack on America's basic freedoms is baseless. China is literally a police state, by definition their basic rights are violated 24/7, as they have no freedom of assembly, no freedom of the press, no freedom of speech, no freedom to unionize, no freedom to protest, no freedom to vote democratically, no freedom of religion. So you're inherently and obviously wrong.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by Morg on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:40AM
(#4042503)
Taiwan and Hong Kong and Tibet have been claimed by China years ago, get over it.
Not like Western countries didn't invade Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya to put governments that favor them instead.
The japanese and the chinese is an entirely different story that would take books to cover, it isn't quite relevant as I don't remember the mexicans brutally invading the US of A.
Furthermore medicare and that kind of crap is rapidly becoming better than what's available for free in the US, do remember China comes from much lower and will most likely improve a lot still, while the US is clearly in decline.
So as much as you're correct in pointing out that China has its own issues, they're not the same issues, and some people will rightfully choose China over the USA.
As a modestly rich European, I think my family would be much safer in China than in the US, and overall the Europe is still much better than both.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by adventureful on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:52AM
(#4042542)
I'm not the one claiming the west doesn't have its guilty points. I completely agree with your point about Iraq. You on the other hand say: just get over it, about China's violent aggressions. You ignore and excuse what China does, but not what America does.
Saying those countries have been claimed by China is outrageous to put it lightly, and then saying to get over it is even more obscene. Tell the Iraqis to just "get over" the last ten years, see how that goes.
You're only safer in China if you never say anything.
And that's not even true anyway, because America is so diverse there are countless areas to live, of all variations, that are completely safe. The problem is, you're ignorant of America.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by smoyer on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @09:40AM
(#4042743)
I suspect we can generate pros and cons for anywhere you might choose to live ... and within the U.S., there's a huge variation in things like violent crime and gun violence from city to city (or in the rural areas).
I'm in the U.S. and I can tell you that I don't like the direction our government is heading. And after typing that, I'm not expecting the police to show up (though I am expecting the comment to appear on HN).
I'm happy to hear that the Chinese are so happy (and safe, etc) living in China ... everyone should get a chance at happiness.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by daniel_solano on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @09:47AM
(#4042773)
Just to be clear, this is a report published by the government of China.
I don't have the time to read the whole article, but here's a few thoughts:
Regarding On life, property and personal security, this section is about violent crime in the U.S. Indubitably, violent crime is particularly bad in some parts of the U.S., but is this part of the 'human rights record' of the federal government? In essence, the Chinese government here is implying that the fact that the U.S. government doesn't outlaw gun ownership results in violent crime.
Throughout most of the text, it just strikes me that the notion of what constitutes "human rights" is unclear. Some people believe that human rights are about the recognition of individual liberty and freedom from government intrusion. Others believe that human rights are about achieving equality and freedom from want. The Chinese government is certainly sympathetic to the latter definition, at least in this report. While this is a point of view favoured by many, in the U.S. the former view of human rights is still strong.
Finally, some of the points made by the Chinese are simply symbolic. For example, they criticise the U.S. for not ratifying the "Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW)". That is true, but the U.S.'s laws and enforcement are considered better than China with respect to CEDAW.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by ktizo on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @07:39AM
(#4042343)
I sort of like this finger pointing and "Yeah? Well you're no better..." approach to international diplomacy. You never know, it might end up in a round of ethical one-upmanship that goes beyond mere words. Not that I'm holding my breath.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by adventureful on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:08AM
(#4042408)
Right now the most important difference is that in the US you still have democratically elected representation and a substantial freedom of speech component. So long as you have that, you have the potential to change the system peacefully through argumentation / debate / voting etc.
Is Obama a terrible President? A great President? Debate it endlessly, but he was elected by a massive wave of popular support in a democratic fashion, beating an opponent (Clinton) that vastly outmatched him in theory.
Doesn't mean the US isn't still going to continue driving right off the cliff, but with those pieces in place, it'll be nobody's fault but our own if we don't take the opportunity and remaining critical freedoms to reverse course and fix the system peacefully.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by Morg on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:29AM
(#4042467)
"you have the potential to change the system peacefully through argumentation / debate / voting etc."
Sure, by voting for one of two parties that have existed for centuries and been sponsored by the same 1% for as long.
You have the potential to watch your fellow americans brainwashed a bit more everyday into accepting their function as modern slaves with less and less benefits and more and more stress.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by adventureful on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:36AM
(#4042489)
The American people can wipe out the parties at their leisure, they have chosen not to. Throughout American history, our parties have changed numerous times, some disappear, some rise, some evolve, and that isn't going to stop.
Americans get to choose. If they choose to be brainwashed as you call it, then that's their volition. If America collapses, it will be the responsibility of the people that they didn't use their voice while they had it.
The Chinese do not get to choose anything. Every time they try - and they have tried - they get violently put down by their own government. In China, nothing like the Occupy movement would ever be tolerated at all, those people would not be allowed to squat on park property and protest, they would not be allowed to march, they would not be allowed to do even a fraction of what they got away with here in the states, and it sure as hell wouldn't all be filmed and put on YouTube for everybody to see.
The various movements of the 1960s and 1970s would have been completely impossible in China. Try holding a rally for free unionization rights in China some time, see how that goes.
Try openly and expressively declaring your religious beliefs. See how much they love that.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by Morg on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @08:50AM
(#4042534)
Yet you wouldn't dare to visit some parts of the ghettos your biggest cities are famous for.
The various movements of the 60s and 70s are completely impossible in the western world now, the brainwashing is far too advanced for that.
Unionization doesn't make sense in communism. It amounts to revolution. Try a revolution in the US and call me back when you've completed your twentieth mandatory cavity search for security purposes.
I don't think you saw much of Gitmo on Youtube, even less today - luckily with the patriot act, anyone who pisses off the govt will get his own personal gitmo experience.
At least China doesn't pretend they respect the human rights - I think that's what the article was about, and fundamentally right.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by thunfischbrot on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @09:04AM
(#4042586)
It seems interesting to me how you (as in you both) continue to argue different points in increasing force. That's not how a dialogue works.
Argue based on issues. Clearly address each issue your 'opponent' raised. Substantiate it with facts. Link to reliable sources if possible. Point out weak points in your own argument and why you think your general point still stands. Don't commit logical fallacies (see http://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ ).
Both of you raise valid points. Engaging in a discussion would probably make us all better off in the end. Currently I can only read "your country is stupider than mine!".
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by adventureful on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @09:28AM
(#4042690)
The problem with that is: I haven't said China is a shitty place or a wasteland. I happen to like China, and I happen to love America and live there. It's absolutely in no way about saying China is worse or better, it's about pointing out the ignorance in claiming China is a vastly superior place to live.
I'm willing to be objective about America and China's faults. The problem with the person I'm arguing with, is that that person is not willing to be objective about China's faults, and is more than willing to be biased about America's faults.
In my observation, most first world countries have the same societal problems that America does (or some modest variation), the big difference is whether they're publicized heavily or not. For example, America gets accused of being a highly racist nation: well, how racist is Japan? How about African racism? How about antisemitism in France? How about the Muslim ghettos in France? How about the extreme xenophobia in many nice European nations? Nobody likes to talk about that, and Americans are mostly ignorant of it, but it's all over the BBC's news reports regularly.
Re:Human Rights Record of United States in 2011
by Morg on Wednesday May 30, 2012 @09:41AM
(#4042750)
Indeed.
I believe we totally agree him and me on the main point: neither China nor the US have a clean record and they're more or less each as dirty as the other.
For those of us who keep track of US news, it's pretty obvious that the human rights situation there is "variable", to say the least. You rarely hear about people being wrongly killed by the police in Europe, whereas in the US it appears to be relatively frequent. As for freedom... let's not go there. The easily manipulated US government is probably the single most important political force for evil in the fight to protect our rights online.
Anyway, so, totally off-topic, but a smart approach from China...
Consider that, in the US, people were able to protest and stop SOPA and PIPA from coming to pass. In China, the government controls the entire internet. It's actually debatable that we could be having a similar conversation about the government, on a site like this one, were we in China right now. The U.S. detains certain people without warrant or trial in its misguided "war on terror." But the PRC can detain any of its citizens, at any time, for any reason, and often does.
It's interesting to consider the hypocrisies and inconsistencies of our own government and society. I'm all for it. But we shouldn't lose sight of reality.
In the US the government controls the entire internet, as well as every information every company holds, including facebook, twitter, google and apple - as well as Intel and Microsoft.
The PRC and the US both have "legitimate" ways to detain any citizen or non-citizen at any time, for any reason, and often do.
I would like to insist that there is NO difference on that specific point since the patriot act.
SOPA and PIPA aren't govt related, they're big content's attempt at having it's own control channel over the internet.
By the way, you forget the positive aspects of China, like those emphasized in the article: In a communist country, there's real security.
My grandparents were in USSR in the 70's, and many like them said they had absolutely NO FEAR AT ALL letting their kids play outside.
That's right dream on. You'll never get that in the US, unless you have your own security.
Then how come Hacker News exists and I can say what I want here?
Try that in China some time =)
You obviously have extremely little first hand experience with America. Look up the crime stats for Boise, Idaho some time on city data. America is an extraordinarily diverse nation, the most diverse nation in world history to be exact, and it has every sort of living style and environment you could want to choose from.
Don't like the crime in Chicago, move to a safer city at your leisure. Seattle is beautiful, and so is Austin TX. Don't like Florida? Move to Virginia. Don't like Vermont, move to NYCity. Don't like NYC? Move to San Francisco. Don't like urban, America is massive and extremely low population density, so move rural. And on and on.
Also, your urban/population density points would apply to China.
Neither are relevant to the topic and nor is this whole article HN-worthy tbh, though China's retaliatory actions here are interesting. :)
You'll note that in no way have I said China doesn't have exactly the same, safe rural areas, or even safe urban areas.
What I said is: America does have those things. My response was to point out that the notion of America being nothing but a giant crime wave or an extraordinarily dangerous place is pure myth. The reality is: America has just about everything, pick what kind of life you want accordingly, and pursue it.
And Morg: the points about Europe would be interesting, except most of Europe allows exceptionally little immigration. So how can outsiders even consider benefiting even if it were the safest place on earth crime wise?
Look up the immigration rates for: Denmark, Finland, Sweden, Germany, Switzerland, Belgium, Norway, etc. I'm sure you already know this however. Then look up America's extreme immigration over the past 100 years. How do you think 20% of our population got to be hispanic? We have a long history of allowing a relatively high amount of immigration (particularly compared to the rest of the world). It's how we become the world's melting pot.
It's not easy to get into America, but it's radically easier than becoming a citizen of most European nations just based on the extremely limited numbers they allow in.
Racism imho is one of the minor issues though, I'm far more concerned by the police state aspects of the US than the cultural details (such as everyone is fat woohooo).
And if you want to talk about shadow immigration, or people that fall through the cracks, Europe has plenty of that. You must know that. Take a look at the African immigration in France and Spain over the last 20 years, and then look at how many are under the radar. Europe also gets a massive amount of abuse from immigrants that leech off the social systems and never work and contribute properly, which is helping to make the looming EU bankruptcy even worse, which is amping up the rapidly rising xenophobia currently going on Europe, such that the Nazi Party is rising in Greece, and the extreme right is gaining in many nations.
The whoohoo on your fat comment certainly betrays to the flippant nature of it. 26% to 27% of people in the UK are obese, in America it's about 33%. Australia and New Zealand is around 24% to 25%. Chile is 25%. Ireland is 23% to 24%. Canada is 25% obese as well. Mexico is about the same as America on obesity. Clearly the problem is greatest in America, but it's hardly alone in the obesity problem.
If you've ever read the book, The China Study, you obviously understand why these countries have such obesity and higher cancer rates that, for example, China has traditionally avoided. However, now China is gradually switching to a killer western diet, particularly among the affluent, and they're seeing skyrocketing obesity and heart disease rates.
You're concerned about the police state aspects of America? So am I, I live here, and it's very disturbing. China is a police state almost by definition, but that doesn't seem to concern you at all. And the police state is rising all over the place, take a look at some of the police state actions and laws being passed in Britain where you practically can't step out your front door without showing up on a cctv.
What I mean is if we're going to talk about countries, we take country-wide data and not cherrypick.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_population
So given the population trails behind China and Europe, human rights in the US don't look that rosy (neither does the UK for that matter). I mean the US has for some time had the largest prison population on the planet. I'm just putting that out there as well, and try to understand what you are getting at?
While this is all propaganda and the article clearly avoids some details, the truth is the situation is really bad and Chinese people have no reason to look up to the US, as much as US people have no reason to look down on China.
Right now, as an European, I'd rather live in China than in the US.
There's a very good reason Chen Guangcheng desperately wanted to escape China.
China has every bit the racism and nationalism problems that America has. Ask China what they think of the Japanese some time.
China is surely very willing to leave the peaceful, successful nation of Taiwan alone, right? It's not like they have any intention of brutally, viciously conquering the island when it's convenient, invading and murdering its people all in the name of reclaiming land that acted as a safe haven for Chinese fleeing from the genocide of Mao (Mao having killed tens of millions of his own people).
China is massively belligerent and violent. Should we free Tibet? Oh right, Tibet doesn't really exist any more because they gradually cleansed the entire country of its people and culture.
China has radically worse inequality, 3/4 of a billion people living on $1 to $2 dollars per day, half a billion people without proper access to sanitary drinking water or indoor plumbing. China still has half of the poorest 10% of people on the entire planet, meanwhile they're printing billionaires along the eastern coast.
China has no systems comparable to medicare, medicaid, or social security. As faulty as they may be in the US, China doesn't even have a real social safety net at all.
Chinese workers have absolutely zero rights, and there are no rights to unionize.
China has almost zero property rights at all.
There is no right to democratic representation in China.
There is zero freedom of speech in China.
China is even more violent, with mass executions in large stadiums just to clear out crime numbers, regardless of whether those executed are in fact the guilty. 5,000 people were slaughtered execution style in 2009 alone, roughly 50,000 people per decade are killed in execution fashion by the Chinese Government. Texas by comparison executes about 25 people per year, and that gets endless press.
China routinely locks down entire villages. Over 200 riots were reported last year alone. They shut off all access to the external world, and proceed to haul off the trouble makers to gulag camps for political prisoners.
The propaganda that China doesn't have half the problems of the US is complete bunk.
The life expectancy of the average Chinese citizen has increased by about 3 years since 1990 to 71.4 which is 5 years (or there about)above the world average and 6-7years above the average level in developing countries. The US health care system is a joke in many other countries so you cant say that it comes anywhere as close.
I can say that having friends/family that have lived/worked Europe/UK, China and the US and I would say that the US is probably the very worst place out of the lot when it comes to basic freedoms. When I think of propaganda, no one does it better than the good old US of A.
China having lifted 400 million of its people out of poverty is based on a $1 per day rate of poverty. And it says nothing to the fact that they still have 3/4 of a billion people living on $1 to $2 per day, which is what I said and it is accurate. Would you like me to provide you with the most recent WHO and UN numbers? Are you not aware of what they actually are?
My information is not bunk or out of date. Here, a story about China raising the rural poverty rate from $0.55 / day or less to $1 per day or less. Sure sounds like they have no extreme poverty problems eh:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-asia-china-15956299
You say the US health care system is a joke? China doesn't even have a real healthcare system for the bottom billion of its people, and it doesn't have a social safety net at all.
America's life expectancy is nearly 10% higher than China's, despite our obesity and heart disease problems.
Your ad hominen attack on America's basic freedoms is baseless. China is literally a police state, by definition their basic rights are violated 24/7, as they have no freedom of assembly, no freedom of the press, no freedom of speech, no freedom to unionize, no freedom to protest, no freedom to vote democratically, no freedom of religion. So you're inherently and obviously wrong.
Not like Western countries didn't invade Iraq, Afghanistan and Libya to put governments that favor them instead.
The japanese and the chinese is an entirely different story that would take books to cover, it isn't quite relevant as I don't remember the mexicans brutally invading the US of A.
Furthermore medicare and that kind of crap is rapidly becoming better than what's available for free in the US, do remember China comes from much lower and will most likely improve a lot still, while the US is clearly in decline.
So as much as you're correct in pointing out that China has its own issues, they're not the same issues, and some people will rightfully choose China over the USA.
As a modestly rich European, I think my family would be much safer in China than in the US, and overall the Europe is still much better than both.
Saying those countries have been claimed by China is outrageous to put it lightly, and then saying to get over it is even more obscene. Tell the Iraqis to just "get over" the last ten years, see how that goes.
You're only safer in China if you never say anything.
And that's not even true anyway, because America is so diverse there are countless areas to live, of all variations, that are completely safe. The problem is, you're ignorant of America.
America's motto is not "rape countries for oil" - it's not "censor the internet" and it's not "IP infringement is more important than violence".
The thing is, both countries are really bad, and I don't believe anyone american or chinese can simply say that one country is better than the other.
Yes there are awesome places everywhere, including where I live or in the USA or in China for that matter.
I'm in the U.S. and I can tell you that I don't like the direction our government is heading. And after typing that, I'm not expecting the police to show up (though I am expecting the comment to appear on HN).
I'm happy to hear that the Chinese are so happy (and safe, etc) living in China ... everyone should get a chance at happiness.
I don't have the time to read the whole article, but here's a few thoughts:
Regarding On life, property and personal security, this section is about violent crime in the U.S. Indubitably, violent crime is particularly bad in some parts of the U.S., but is this part of the 'human rights record' of the federal government? In essence, the Chinese government here is implying that the fact that the U.S. government doesn't outlaw gun ownership results in violent crime.
Throughout most of the text, it just strikes me that the notion of what constitutes "human rights" is unclear. Some people believe that human rights are about the recognition of individual liberty and freedom from government intrusion. Others believe that human rights are about achieving equality and freedom from want. The Chinese government is certainly sympathetic to the latter definition, at least in this report. While this is a point of view favoured by many, in the U.S. the former view of human rights is still strong.
Finally, some of the points made by the Chinese are simply symbolic. For example, they criticise the U.S. for not ratifying the "Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Discrimination against Women (CEDAW)". That is true, but the U.S.'s laws and enforcement are considered better than China with respect to CEDAW.
Is Obama a terrible President? A great President? Debate it endlessly, but he was elected by a massive wave of popular support in a democratic fashion, beating an opponent (Clinton) that vastly outmatched him in theory.
Doesn't mean the US isn't still going to continue driving right off the cliff, but with those pieces in place, it'll be nobody's fault but our own if we don't take the opportunity and remaining critical freedoms to reverse course and fix the system peacefully.
My eyes are in no way closed, and what you said is not a valid retort, it's proof that you have nothing to say.
Sure, by voting for one of two parties that have existed for centuries and been sponsored by the same 1% for as long.
You have the potential to watch your fellow americans brainwashed a bit more everyday into accepting their function as modern slaves with less and less benefits and more and more stress.
Americans get to choose. If they choose to be brainwashed as you call it, then that's their volition. If America collapses, it will be the responsibility of the people that they didn't use their voice while they had it.
The Chinese do not get to choose anything. Every time they try - and they have tried - they get violently put down by their own government. In China, nothing like the Occupy movement would ever be tolerated at all, those people would not be allowed to squat on park property and protest, they would not be allowed to march, they would not be allowed to do even a fraction of what they got away with here in the states, and it sure as hell wouldn't all be filmed and put on YouTube for everybody to see.
The various movements of the 1960s and 1970s would have been completely impossible in China. Try holding a rally for free unionization rights in China some time, see how that goes.
Try openly and expressively declaring your religious beliefs. See how much they love that.
The various movements of the 60s and 70s are completely impossible in the western world now, the brainwashing is far too advanced for that.
Unionization doesn't make sense in communism. It amounts to revolution. Try a revolution in the US and call me back when you've completed your twentieth mandatory cavity search for security purposes.
I don't think you saw much of Gitmo on Youtube, even less today - luckily with the patriot act, anyone who pisses off the govt will get his own personal gitmo experience.
At least China doesn't pretend they respect the human rights - I think that's what the article was about, and fundamentally right.
Argue based on issues. Clearly address each issue your 'opponent' raised. Substantiate it with facts. Link to reliable sources if possible. Point out weak points in your own argument and why you think your general point still stands. Don't commit logical fallacies (see http://yourlogicalfallacyis.com/ ).
Both of you raise valid points. Engaging in a discussion would probably make us all better off in the end. Currently I can only read "your country is stupider than mine!".
Interpret the possessive 'your' as you will.
I'm willing to be objective about America and China's faults. The problem with the person I'm arguing with, is that that person is not willing to be objective about China's faults, and is more than willing to be biased about America's faults.
In my observation, most first world countries have the same societal problems that America does (or some modest variation), the big difference is whether they're publicized heavily or not. For example, America gets accused of being a highly racist nation: well, how racist is Japan? How about African racism? How about antisemitism in France? How about the Muslim ghettos in France? How about the extreme xenophobia in many nice European nations? Nobody likes to talk about that, and Americans are mostly ignorant of it, but it's all over the BBC's news reports regularly.
I believe we totally agree him and me on the main point: neither China nor the US have a clean record and they're more or less each as dirty as the other.