News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by gghhjjy on Sunday May 19, 2024 @05:22AM (#40405538)
Out of curiousity, when was the last time hacker news featured an article about the negative impacts of Islamic teachings on women’s accomplishments? An algolia search shows Mormons are discussed here more often. I find this fascinating considering there are literally 100x as many Muslims on the planet.
Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by sneak on Sunday May 19, 2024 @05:38AM (#40405620)
HN is very US-centric, owing to the location of Silly Valley and big tech.

Utah, LDS central, is right on the other side of Nevada from California, and California and the Bay Area is the nearest interesting/fun place for those fleeing SLC.

It makes sense.

Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by lupusreal on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:10AM (#40405774)
There are about as many Muslims as Mormons living in California and San Francisco. Both are about 1% of each.

That makes them about as rare as Eastern Orthodox, who I rarely hear anything about, half as common as Hindus, ten times less common than Evangelical Protestants in San Francisco... I think it's fair to say that HN has a minor obsession with Mormons that cannot be explained merely by their prevalence in Silicon Valley.

(For what it's worth, I am an atheist and have no Mormons in my family.)

Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by playingalong on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:25AM (#40405843)
In absolute numbers they might be the same.

Not being American myself, my hunch is that the Mormons in CA might be well established, subsocieties with long traditions. And the Muslim people might have more of single first-generation immigrants.

Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by lupusreal on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:32AM (#40405867)
My hunch is there are more of those first generation Muslim immigrants working in the CA tech industry than there are Mormons, but I don't have data on that either way.
Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by relaxing on Sunday May 19, 2024 @02:15PM (#40408714)
Mormons are organized as a political and economic force in nearby Utah, hence the interest. They also try to wield power outside the church, as when they funded CA Prop. 8 and AZ Prop. 102, nationwide political campaigns, etc.

If you want to see HN address Muslim issues in the US, search “Sharia”.

Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by seanhunter on Sunday May 19, 2024 @05:55AM (#40405699)
If you know of such an article why don’t you post it rather than this whataboutism?
Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by gghhjjy on Sunday May 19, 2024 @05:58AM (#40405716)
Simple. Because I don’t think either article belongs here. The decision to stay home with children or work is something almost everyone struggles with. This isn’t unique to Mormonism as the author imagines it is. This is just a complicated way to complain about religion, which is not what hacker news should be used for.
Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by bobs_salsa on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:39AM (#40405892)
Then you should’ve said that first instead of beating around the bush with the what-about-ism.

The author is discussing the impact a society/institute can have on an individuals choices later in life through the lens of their experience within Mormonism. They never attempt to gatekeep that it’s a unique thing Mormons go through. Ultimately she discusses a topic that encompasses all STEM industries at the moment, which is equal opportunity and free choice. As a result I’d argue it’s very topical for HN irrespective of the religion.

Re:I Might've Been a Rocket Scientist (Like My Dad), but I W... by crummy on Sunday May 19, 2024 @06:16AM (#40405794)
Do you think this article is primarily complaining about religion?