News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by robertlagrant on Saturday May 18, 2024 @11:46AM (#40399940)
> or makes life much shittier for most humans by making most of us obsolete

I'm not sure this is true. If all the things people are doing are done so much more cheaply they're almost free, that would be good for us, as we're also the buyers as well as the workers.

However, I also doubt the premise.

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by justinclift on Saturday May 18, 2024 @12:09PM (#40400078)
> If all the things people are doing are done so much more cheaply they're almost free, that would be good for us ...

Doesn't this tend to become "they're almost free to produce" with the actual pricing for end consumers not becoming cheaper? From the point of view of the sellers just expanding their margins instead.

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by marcusverus on Saturday May 18, 2024 @12:33PM (#40400203)
I'm sure businesses will capture some of the value, but is there any reason to assume they'll capture all or even most of it?

Over the last ~ 50 years, worker productivity is up ~250%[0], profits (within the S&P 500) are up ~100%[1] and real personal (not household) income is up 150%[2].

It should go without saying that a large part of the rise in profits is attributable to the rise of tech. It shouldn't surprise anyone that margins are higher on digital widgets than physical ones!

Regardless, expanding margins is only attractive up to a certain point. The higher your margins, the more attractive your market becomes to would-be competitors.

[0] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/OPHNFB [1] https://dqydj.com/sp-500-profit-margin/ [2] https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MEPAINUSA672N

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by lotsofpulp on Saturday May 18, 2024 @12:51PM (#40400304)
> Regardless, expanding margins is only attractive up to a certain point. The higher your margins, the more attractive your market becomes to would-be competitors.

This does not make sense to me. While a higher profit margin is a signal to others that they can earn money by selling equivalent goods and services at lower prices, it is not inevitable that they will be able to. And even if they are, it behooves a seller to take advantage of the higher margins while they can.

Earning less money now in the hopes of competitors being dissuaded from entering the market seems like a poor strategy.

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by robertlagrant on Sunday May 19, 2024 @12:34PM (#40408039)
The premise wasn't that there weren't competitors already, I don't think. With most things the price is (usually) floored by the cost of production, ceilinged by the value it provides people, and then competition is what moves it from the latter to closer to the former.
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by lifeisstillgood on Saturday May 18, 2024 @01:05PM (#40400379)
Wait what? I was just listening to the former chief economist of Banknof England going on about how terrible productivity (in the UK) is.

So who is right?

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by michaelt on Saturday May 18, 2024 @03:43PM (#40401465)
Google UK productivity growth and you'll find a graph showing:

UK productivity growth, 1990-2007: 2% per year

UK productivity growth, 2010-2019: 0.5% per year

So they're both right. US 50 year productivity growth looks great, UK 10 year productivity growth looks pretty awful.

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by justinclift on Saturday May 18, 2024 @06:27PM (#40402616)
> The higher your margins, the more attractive your market becomes to would-be competitors.

Only in very simplistic theory. :(

In practical terms, businesses with high margins seem able to afford government protection (aka "buy some politicians").

So they lock out competition, and with their market captured, price gouging (or close to it) is the order of the day.

No real sure why anyone thinks the playbook would be any different just because "AI" is used on the production side. It's still the same people making the calls, just with extra tools available to them.

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by robertlagrant on Sunday May 19, 2024 @01:04PM (#40408239)
This is also pretty simplistic. All the progress that's made on a variety of fronts implies that we don't have loads of static lockin businesses that bribe bureaucrats.
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by justinclift on Sunday May 19, 2024 @03:04PM (#40409024)
The ones controlling AI these days seem to be of that type though. :(
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by marcusverus on Friday May 24, 2024 @08:58PM (#40471833)
Literally every imaginable economic prediction could be countered with this argument: "That won't happen if the government legislates to prevent it!"

Weird that the field of economics just keeps on existing.

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by confidantlake on Saturday May 18, 2024 @11:55AM (#40400000)
Why would you need buyers if AI can create anything you desire?
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by flashgordon on Saturday May 18, 2024 @12:22PM (#40400146)
In an ideal world where gpus are a commodity yes. Btw at least today ai is owned/controlled by the rich and powerful and that's where majority of the research dollars are coming from. Why would they just relinquish ai so generously?
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by brandall10 on Saturday May 18, 2024 @12:52PM (#40400306)
With an ever expanding AI everything should be quickly commoditized, including reduction in energy to run AI and energy itself (ie. viable commercial fusion or otherwise).
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by flashgordon on Saturday May 18, 2024 @04:59PM (#40402066)
That's the thing I am struggling with. I agree things will exponentially improve with AI. What i am not seeing is who will actually capture the value. Or rather how will those other than rich and powerful get to partake in this value capture. Take viable commercial fusion for example. Best case it ends up looking like another PG&E. Worst case it is owned by yet another Musk like gatekeeper. How do you see this being truly democratized and accessible for the masses?
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by brandall10 on Saturday May 18, 2024 @11:01PM (#40403877)
The most rosy outcome would be benevolent state actors control it, and the value capture is simply for everyone as the costs for everything go to zero (food, energy, housing, etc). It would be post-capitalist, post-consumer.

Of course the problem is whether or not it could be controlled, and in that case, the best hope is simply 'it' being benevolent and naturally incentivized to create such a utopia.

It's funny how tied humans are to current ways of operation given our vast history... we're trying to figure out how to hold onto an idea that's about a century old, Keynesian economics, that made sense during the dawn of the industrial revolution, was supercharged by the information age, and apply it forever forward.

We have something else possibly upon us that requires another grave, much more forceful shift if a super-intelligent, sentient AGI emerges. It's silly to think we'll have an even more supercharged version of our current reality given that nearly all jobs (outside of possibly entertainment) will be wiped away.

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by robertlagrant on Sunday May 19, 2024 @01:05PM (#40408243)
Why would the cost of housing go to zero?
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by martyfmelb on Saturday May 18, 2024 @12:08PM (#40400064)
Bingo.

The whole justification for keeping consumers happy or healthy goes right out the window.

Same for human workers.

All that matters is that your robots and AIs aren't getting smashed by their robots and AIs.

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by pixl97 on Saturday May 18, 2024 @01:27PM (#40400500)
Where are you getting energy and land from for these AI's to consume and turn into goods?

Moreso, by making such a magical powerful AI as you've listed, the number one thing some rich controlling asshole with more AI than you, would be to create an army and take what they want because AI does nothing to solve human greed.

Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by pants2 on Saturday May 18, 2024 @03:35PM (#40401417)
Up to the point of AGI, most productivity increases have resulted in less physical / menial labor, and more white collar work. If AGI is smarter than most humans, the pendulum will swing the other way, and more humans will have to work physical / menial jobs.
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by smcin on Monday May 20, 2024 @06:26AM (#40414008)
Look on the bright side: they'll stop calling Frank Herbert a visionary.
Re:OpenAI requires NDA for employees to keep equity by thayne on Saturday May 18, 2024 @03:44PM (#40401466)
We won't be buyers anymore if we aren't getting paid to work.

Perhaps some kind of garanteed minimal income would be implemented, but we would probably see a shrinkage or complete destruction of the middle class, and massive increases in wealth inequality.