Financial Times journalist John Burn Murdoch changed my mind on dual axes charts – even for casual readers! – a bit over the last six years, too. Here's a dual axis chart he created for the FT: https://x.com/AlexSelbyB/status/1529039107732774913
The next article I write on dual axis charts will probably be a "What to consider when you do use them" one.
You believe this. (I also tend to believe it.) But why do we believe it? Are we basing that belief on data? Or on conjecture?
This chart is the first one I've seen that starkly lays out an argument based on data that this effect exists.
1. Why just the Daily Mail? Is that the only paper that matters in Britain, or just the one that happens to correlate?
2. I would expect public opinion to lag coverage in the paper if there were a causal relationship. This graph is over too great a period to really see that, but if the creator wants to convince me, they'd show that.
3. I might expect the lag to differ when coverage is increasing vs. decreasing. Again, if I'm to believe this graph, more context would help.
4. No consideration of other factors that might lead to changes in public concern?
5. No consideration of factors that might lead to *both* an increase in coverage *and* an increase in concern?
I'm sure I could come up with 5 more reasons to doubt this graph if I thought for another 60 seconds...I generally find that a second Y axis creeping in is perhaps an indicator to stop and have a really deep think about what you are trying to achieve. You might try doing a 3D graph for example where x, y1, y2 becomes x, y, z then spin and explore. However you have to remember that y1 and y2 are both dependent on x (by definition) so when you put y2 to a separate dimension, it is not independent from y1 (or is it?)
There are no hard and fast rules when it comes to spin doctoring via graphs, and as the old adage doesn't go: There are liars, damned liars and politicians.
I mean, certainly you have the right to add some color but it comes off like you are saying to ignore the article entirely in favor of your alternatives.
Besides, it's ok if the graph takes a bit to digest, other wise you can just keep printing the same three graphs over and over merely renaming the axis.
For readers with more interest or who are numerate in their day jobs (engineers, finance, or economists), dual axis charts can often be a great choice.
This is better graph style advice from the Economist, which includes good dual axis examples and one bad one and how to correct it. https://medium.economist.com/mistakes-weve-drawn-a-few-8cdd8...
Since we are engineers or founders trying to deal with very complex systems, adding detail and clarity like the Economist or Edward Tufte does is the better way to go.