Celsius and Fahrenheit is a good comparison. RAL became widespread and nobody sees a reason to switch; but other regions prefer other systems because of how history played out.
RAL is quite old and entrenched. I'm not sure if it "offers" anything in particular but at least over here a ton of colors used in the wild are just RAL codes.
For example, refurbishing a building within a protected area (close to a historic monument is a typical scenario) will require the use of materials (paints, window frames, doors, blinds) coated with a specific subset of RAL colors, selected by a public body to match the intended scenery.
My RAL color fan (got mostly in order to match filament to colors) was $26.
- Pantone recently removed its color libraries from Adobe products to make them an additional subscription of $14.99/month
- Pantone colors are always a subscription on color readers/spectrometers unless you buy X-Rite's high end readers. RAL is available for free on most color readers.
- NCS is a bit between RAL and Pantone in that regard, they sell an affordable color reader (for its full spectrum capabilities) that includes the NCS library, but it is a paid subscription for other readers, albeit cheaper than Pantone.I think I am right in saying RAL is a more open system than Munsell. I think anyone can print their own RAL guide as long as it meets the standard. Can't find a reference
- you can get yourself a fan of RAL Classic colors for $16, which are solid colors that include enough grays, whites and colors to get started and cover all basic needs, and that most industrial/finishing shops already have
- most shops now also accept Pantone PMS C (coated), which cost $260, but Pantone comes from printing and so has no whites, you need to add FHI TPG+TCX (another $260) to get whites. Pantone recommends replacing the fans every 12-18 months before their die age
- Munsell is a "full" color space so as such it is inherently more expensive (even more so that it is now owned by X-Rite), with a rich history in USDA standards, food QA, science and artists. NCS and RAL "Design" also feature "full" color space, most certainly a lot cheaper than Munsell
Cost is important because everybody in your supply chain need to have the color system on hand: designers, marketing, suppliers, QA.Curated colors:
- RAL Classic (216) $16, RAL Effect (490) $70
- Pantone PMS (2,390), Pantone FHI (2,625) each $260
- RAL P1 Classic plastics (100 colors + textures): $2,100
- RAL P2 Effect plastics (200 colors + textures): $2,700
- Pantone plastics (1,755): $9,078
Color spaces: - Munsell (1,600): $1,525 - $1,625 (Munsell book of colors matte - glossy), cheaper subselections of colors based around neutral, soil, plant & rock colors
- NCS (2,050): $210, used a lot in architecture/interior design, from Sweden
- RAL Design (1,825): $160, all its colors are additional to/not in Classic/Design
If you need a few colors, a curated system is more adapted and cheaper, but a curated system with thousands of colors (Pantone) is more expensive and less versatile than a system based on a color space.As you can see the whole RAL catalog/system of color is designed for cost and so that you can start small and expand, and have enough variety at each level + it has nice features that shows its Industrial orientation such as all colors being solid and textured plastics.
RAL catalog has each system building on the other, Munsell is a color space with subsets picked from it for specific uses, NCS is always the full color space, Pantone is a gigantic, somewhat incoherent curated system that started with printing and expanded into fashion & cosmetics.
Munsell is based around different sectors of industry & science, so color subsets availability, design and price dictate that it is uneconomical for other sectors or more general design outside gov standards. E.g. Munsell even has a frozen french fry color standard book! [1]
There are many more color systems and color spaces, but those are the main ones for which there is wide availability of physical color books around the World.
[1] https://www.pantone.com/products/munsell/munsell-usda-frozen...
Hue is the beast in the box. How many other natural phenomena are expressed as terms, not degrees of intensity?
I often imagine how much simpler color science would be if humans did not possess the ability to perceive hue difference. Indeed color would likely be perceived as too simple a phenomenon to warrent scientific enquiry.