News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by dannyw on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:36AM (#40343207)
PE realises you can fire most of the team and stop R&D, jack up prices by 50-100% due to lock in, and have something low risk that returns like four times bonds.
Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by makestuff on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:43AM (#40343294)
Yeah slash equity grants for engineers by 20%, and then move into maintenance mode.
Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by throwaway12301 on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:46AM (#40343318)
They'll recap the company, at the expense of IC grants.
Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by makestuff on Monday May 13, 2024 @10:03AM (#40343516)
Does that mean dilute the cap table and then suddenly the PE shares are equivalent to like 4 employee shares or something? Or the PE shares have some special dividend that the employee ones do not?
Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by throwaway12301 on Monday May 13, 2024 @11:37AM (#40344521)
PE will "buy" you out of some of your unvested shares. And they offer new ones, possibly way out of the money to try and keep people around. When it happened to me, I lost like 60% of my unvested shares, which would have been worth way more long-term, than the short-term gain they forced.
Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by pclmulqdq on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:37AM (#40343226)
What R&D was Squarespace doing over the last 10 years?
Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by dartos on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:40AM (#40343256)
All software companies have R&D going on constantly.

“How do I push this user metric” “How do we increase conversion” “How can we increase conversion for our customers” “Can square space be easier to use”

Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by pclmulqdq on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:51AM (#40343382)
Software people massively over-classify their work as "R&D" when most of it is basically the equivalent of tuning or plumbing. R&D involves at least a little bit of the "R" part, which usually means some risk that the work is worthless. If you are just doing the development part, which is what you are doing when you ask the question "how do I push this metric?", private equity is usually happy to fund that.

I generally wouldn't classify those (except for maybe the last one if you are developing fundamentally new user interfaces) as actually being R&D.

I also know that the IRS classifies software development as R&D, but we all know those are not the same thing in reality.

Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by lesuorac on Monday May 13, 2024 @11:02AM (#40344138)
> I also know that the IRS classifies software development as R&D, but we all know those are not the same thing in reality.

I think you may have spent too much time writing software to notice how R&D it is.

You can pick whatever citation you want [1] but writing software is a very risky endeavor (in terms of ROI).

"Generic IT" or SRE is really not R&D. If your solution to a bug is to "reboot" the device; that's an operational fix. If your solution is instead to read a stacktrace and write some code; that's R&D.

[1]: https://www.google.com/search?q=most+software+projects+fail

Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by pclmulqdq on Monday May 13, 2024 @11:16AM (#40344294)
Setting up shopify integrations, building a domain name registrar, and writing new web templates is not R&D. It carries no technical risk and the product is already known to be valuable. The only chance of failure is that you build it and nobody comes to buy because there's no reason to choose you over all the other people offering the same thing.

I am sure that most software projects fail, but I am also sure that as a software developer, almost all of your work ends up in production. Sure, you will have minor technical setbacks, but not on the scale of actual R&D projects. In contrast, people doing R&D in pharma or other similar fields will spend months or years working on a single project that doesn't go anywhere because it is too hard. The same goes for civil engineers building bridges, for example: the work is highly technical, but it is not R&D.

I very much disagree with you that pushing a 10-line bugfix is anywhere near R&D. There's no uncertainty, and there is no research.

By the way, the act of thinking or problem solving does not make your work R&D. If it did, retail workers and construction workers would be doing a lot of R&D, too.

Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by dartos on Tuesday May 14, 2024 @08:15AM (#40354357)
> In contrast, people doing R&D in pharma or other similar fields will spend months or years working on a single project that doesn't go anywhere because it is too hard.

So does your argument boil down to “software moves faster than the sciences, so it’s not R&D?”

Initial development isn’t R&D. Like you said, setting up a webpage and hooking up payments isn’t R&D.

After a product is established, future work is R&D. A cycle of desired outcome, hypothesis for how to get there, and successive implementations until something sticks or the project fails and the hypothesis is proven wrong.

Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by pclmulqdq on Tuesday May 14, 2024 @05:59PM (#40360637)
No, it's not about things moving fast. It's about projects carrying specific kinds of risk and developing a specific kind of output. Namely technical risk and intellectual property.

Technical risk is the risk that your technical development won't pan out. I'm not referring to schedule risk - the risk that it will take longer than you thought - but actual risk that it will never work at all. Intellectual property is a durable, hard-to-copy advantage over your competition.

Pharma is a great example because it is a very pure form of R&D - you find a drug, test the shit out of it, those tests mostly go negative, and if you succeed, you have a formula and a manufacturing method that lets you charge extortionate rates. Most software work is not like this at all.

And no, ongoing future work is absolutely not guaranteed to be R&D. If anything, it is the opposite: most startups begin with R&D - creating an uncertain product with a (hopefully) durable advantage - and move out of doing R&D as they mature and the competition catches up. That is generally the lifecycle of companies that develop new product categories, from Singer (the first company to produce a sewing machine), to IBM, to Google.

Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by itsoktocry on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:49AM (#40343361)
>All software companies have R&D going on constantly.

I think the question is more like, "what is Squarespace innovating on that we're afraid of losing under new ownership?"

Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by the_sleaze_ on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:50AM (#40343374)
https://www.squarespace.com/refresh

It's not like they've been sitting on their hands

Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by ThrowawayTestr on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:39AM (#40343250)
Their website builder and templates I imagine
Re:Squarespace to Go Private in $6.9B All-Cash Transaction w... by pclmulqdq on Monday May 13, 2024 @09:54AM (#40343416)
What part of a website builder and template engine is fundamentally new and uncertain?

Squarespace certainly does a lot of development, but "R&D" (especially when it comes to things that PE firms will cut) usually means completely new stuff with significant uncertainty in terms of revenue impact.

If Squarespace, for example, had been a significant contributor to HTML standards to make website rendering easier, I would be unhappy about a loss of R&D.