News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Small reactors don't add up as a viable energy source by yxhuvud on Sunday May 12, 2024 @11:54AM (#40335412)
Are there no rains in western Canada? Why is hydro not an alternative?
Re:Small reactors don't add up as a viable energy source by tonyarkles on Sunday May 12, 2024 @12:06PM (#40335494)
Where I’m at (Saskatchewan) everything is very flat. We have some hydro but all of the “economically viable” hydro resources have been tapped. I worked out the math once on doing pumped hydro storage and the best siting I came up with involved building a massive reservoir in the middle of one of the most beautiful provincial parks we have and putting the downstream low point 80km away.

There’s a really interesting nomenclature thing in Canada with respect to electricity. Every province (except Alberta) has a government-owned power company. If you want to tell whether or not a given province has good water resources for generating electricity you just need to look at the name of their power company: BC Hydro, Manitoba Hydro, Ontario Hydro, Quebec Hydro… all good places for hydroelectricity. SaskPower? Not so much.

We have recently bought into the SMR idea and one of the questions I used to have was “why the hell didn’t we build nuclear 20 years ago here”. The problem, I understand now, is overall grid sizing. You don’t want to have a single power plant that provides more than about 10% of your grid capacity. In SK, our total generation capacity is around 3500MW; a conventional 1+GW reactor would have dramatically exceeded the 10% cutoff. Smaller 300MW reactors provide a much better fit for our grid.

Re:Small reactors don't add up as a viable energy source by DrJokepu on Sunday May 12, 2024 @11:58AM (#40335443)
No rain in winter, the snow won’t melt until much later.
Re:Small reactors don't add up as a viable energy source by yxhuvud on Sunday May 12, 2024 @01:00PM (#40335887)
Same is true here in Sweden, we just have deep enough reservoirs. We also have nuclear, but hydro is also a really big part and as Canada has even lower population density than we do it shouldn't be unreasonable. But perhaps terrain in many areas isn't helpful.
Re:Small reactors don't add up as a viable energy source by kgabis on Monday May 13, 2024 @08:36AM (#40342620)
Even if hydro is a viable option, it's still terrible for the environment.