News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by user90131313 on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:26AM (#40334260)
This is called capitalism and I really don't understand how people that tweet this think what economic reality is in the world and USA ? If only they could read and understand.
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by translucyd on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:32AM (#40334318)
Because people don’t understand what capitalism is, only what it was. The most ironical part is that the ones who predicted what is going on are the communists.
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by mordae on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:45AM (#40334415)
Agreed. (Pun intended.)

Capitalism seemed to work for a while only because it has been tempered with socialists fighting back hard and incentives being aligned for a while (build more high-tech, time-saving stuff like fridges).

Now when the market has saturated with time-saving goods, capitalism needs to widen the divide between workers and owners more and more just to keep going.

Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by wernercd on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:54AM (#40334496)
Capitalism did work. Socialism has never worked. Capitalism still works. Socialism still doesn't work.
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by surajrmal on Sunday May 12, 2024 @12:35PM (#40335695)
Absolute capitalism doesn't work. Every modern economy is its share of socialist policy. The question today isn't whether you support socialism, but rather where you draw the line.
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by wernercd on Monday May 13, 2024 @07:20PM (#40349730)
True... but we've never had absolute capitalism. Just like we've never had absolute communism. Absolute socialism. Absolute monarchy. etc.

What we have is imperfect capitalism vs imperfect communism vs imperfect socialism vs ...

The reality is that imperfect capitalism, despite its flaws, is better than the alternatives, despite the attempt to ignore their flaws.

Because that's the only way you can argue socialism is better... is arguing the idea of socialism vs the reality of capitalism.

We can discuss the "line" that gets drawn but when that line crosses from one system to the other? We can absolutely judge Capitalism vs Socialism vs Communism.

Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by chownie on Sunday May 12, 2024 @10:20AM (#40334695)
Outside of the US does this actually convince anyone? Just repeating the hymn?
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by HDThoreaun on Sunday May 12, 2024 @02:09PM (#40336300)
Capitalism has raised billions of people out of poverty. Yes, the people who are no longer starving are happy to no longer be starving. Communism on the other hand usually leads to mass famine. Even nordic democratic socialism is falling apart. None of the systems are perfect, they are all hampered by power hungry leaders. Capitalism clearly seems to be the best option.
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by wernercd on Monday May 13, 2024 @07:18PM (#40349713)
"outside of the US" its still true.

Outside of the US, do people think that truth can be changed because you aren't in the US? Just deny literally 100+ years of history?

The only way Socialism works is in The Utopia that's never existed.

The real life examples of socialism are authoritarian nightmares. Thinking that outside of the US this isn't still true is an... interesting... attempt to deny history.

Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by wernercd on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:53AM (#40334483)
and the problem is the predicted solution from the communists is worse.

You can sit and scream "companies are going to become mega corps and kill us all!!!"... but then when you scream "the solution is government ownership of everything, that will save us all!!!" you lose credibility.

For reference: All of human history and the real world results of socialism/communism/marxism.

The real truth is people understand what capitalism was... what it is... and understand that despite the issues? The alternatives are worse.

Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by LightBug1 on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:27AM (#40334276)
It's companies at the scale of governments - which is a distortion of capitalism.
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by voisin on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:30AM (#40334301)
Then vote for government that doesn’t allow companies to grow to government scale. Western antitrust regulations are not being enforced properly and it is to everyone’s detriment.
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by LightBug1 on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:33AM (#40334327)
So you agree with the distortion. Thanks.

I agree with what you said also, to a certain extent. But then we go down the path of: is there anyone with enforced antitrust on their manifesto? Considering the overwhelming lobby influence of 'government scale companies', will there ever be? I'll suggest: no.

Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by trust_bt_verify on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:51AM (#40334469)
I don’t think they stated that they agreed with the ‘distortion’ statement. They only stated that if you believe that is the case, the government would be the one who should regulate that distortion out of existence.

I personally don’t believe this is a distortion of capitalism as much as it is just a later stage of capitalism’s inevitable self destruction.

Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by LightBug1 on Sunday May 12, 2024 @10:37AM (#40334820)
I know. I was just trying to find common ground. Forced, but in this day and age you almost have to ...

On the latter point, perhaps you're right. The key is whether it's inevitable or not. I don't profess to know.

Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by MuffinFlavored on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:29AM (#40334292)
Is it thought that "the creators of capitalism" didn't think through what would happen "late stage" and we are dealing with a "never before in history" mutation of that?
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by spookie on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:52AM (#40334475)
You could say the same for all economic ideologies. This is why you need checks and balances along the way.

Some are more prone to human flaws than others, but the real issue is almost always how greed has found ways to circumvent the methods in place to not allow these mutations to occur.

As always, take "pure" ideas with huge amounts of salt.

Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by voisin on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:32AM (#40334311)
Capitalism evolved. That’s like saying “did the first settler of Chicago not think through the future problem of crime?”
Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by mordae on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:50AM (#40334458)
No, capitalism is distortion of free markets. Capitalism literally means preventing workers from keeping the profits, replacing then with a flat wages.

Markets are an important force of progress, capitalism is feudalism all over again.

There is no real negotiation going on between employer and employees. If you don't believe me, ask any HR person whether they allow custom contracts.

Re:Google gave investors a $70B buyback,and laid off 12,000 ... by metacritic12 on Sunday May 12, 2024 @09:38AM (#40334360)
That Google is a monopoly that should be a broken up is a whataboutism.

It's intrinsic in capitalism that firms often increase in value as they fire works.

Your values determine whether that's a feature of a flaw though.