Re:'Underwater bicycle' propels swimmers forward at superhum...
by andrewflnr on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @11:02PM
(#40304908)
And everything is always in exactly one easily defined context, right? So for a comment reply we already know the full context just by looking at its immediate parent. That's how nested replies work, right?
Re:'Underwater bicycle' propels swimmers forward at superhum...
by noncoml on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @11:07PM
(#40304941)
Yes..?
Re:'Underwater bicycle' propels swimmers forward at superhum...
by andrewflnr on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @11:12PM
(#40304966)
Really? Go into the next HN thread and see how many deeply nested comments you can make sense of by looking only at their parent.
Re:'Underwater bicycle' propels swimmers forward at superhum...
by noncoml on Thursday May 09, 2024 @12:44AM
(#40305375)
You are not doing HN right if you are only reading the parent
Re:'Underwater bicycle' propels swimmers forward at superhum...
by lukan on Thursday May 09, 2024 @02:14AM
(#40305728)
Yeah, you both seem to agree. The larger context matters.
Re:'Underwater bicycle' propels swimmers forward at superhum...
by andrewflnr on Thursday May 09, 2024 @08:54PM
(#40314498)
Me:
> And everything is always in exactly one easily defined context, right? So for a comment reply we already know the full context just by looking at its immediate parent. That's how nested replies work, right?
noncoml:
> Yes..?
But somehow, also noncoml:
> You are not doing HN right if you are only reading the parent
I give up.
Re:'Underwater bicycle' propels swimmers forward at superhum...
by andrewflnr on Thursday May 09, 2024 @08:50PM
(#40314470)
Correct. Why is that? Apply this logic to the current comment chain, starting from OP.
If there is an article about berries and you say you love blueberries and I reply saying “I hate them”, it in the context of blueberries. It doesn’t mean I hate all berries. And I shouldn’t have to clarify that, since I’m replying to a comment about blueberries.
How else could this work?