Re:Neuralink Prime Study Progress Update – User Experience
by mlindner on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @06:20PM
(#40303317)
You say they're doing things that are cheap and trivial, but isn't the major innovation of Neuralink the fact that they're using very fine wire probes? No one else has done this and instead used relatively hard fixed arrays of needles. This causes damage to blood vessels among other things. Neuralink's advantage is they exactly void this type of brain damage.
Re:Neuralink Prime Study Progress Update – User Experience
by aredox on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @06:53PM
(#40303529)
It is not true that "no one else has done this". Do you think neural interface researchers didn't thought of something like that? There are plenty of other electrode designs apart from the "nails board", and none solve the problem I mentioned well enough yet.
Re:Neuralink Prime Study Progress Update – User Experience
by mlindner on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @09:41PM
(#40304469)
Can you mention some? I've never heard of them.
Re:Neuralink Prime Study Progress Update – User Experience
by aredox on Thursday May 09, 2024 @01:39PM
(#40310703)
10 & 8 years ago:
https://youtu.be/Y4fmMVdDf3s?si=17rh9ydWHEwVcdO2
https://youtu.be/RbnRY3eH3AU?si=lskZuSL5PjsufjDw
6 years ago: https://youtu.be/nM973fDmD6E?si=YY02bo9fHNG_HNXy
11 months ago, but Lacour's lab was already on it 5 years ago: https://youtu.be/Qsvo_O4-amg?si=T1qucWm0vEN9jrNU
Lacour's lecture 8 years ago: https://youtu.be/Qsvo_O4-amg?si=T1qucWm0vEN9jrNU
(She's at the Wyss institute in Geneva)
2 years ago: https://youtu.be/aL7zEsfkibg?si=GkF6ll7rUDHSrcvl
Re:Neuralink Prime Study Progress Update – User Experience
by brcmthrowaway on Thursday May 09, 2024 @11:12PM
(#40315164)
What brain startup has the right approach?
Yes Yes
Neuralink is putting the cart before the horse: none of what they are doing here are the true challenges of neural interfaces, which are:
-either neurons move away from the stress caused by the probes
-or neurons are killed by the probes.
The lifetime of neural probes due to this problem is under a year, and let me remind you these direct probes need to be drilled into your skull. Neuralink is not solving anything: they are scoring cheap publicity points by doing something (signal analysis) nobody has done that much before, because it is too early to do it
These guinea pigs will be worse off after neuralink will have (ab)used them for this publicity stunt.