News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by makeitdouble on Monday May 06, 2024 @09:54PM (#40281474)
Proton Mail is in the title because it's where they went first, but the actual identification (real name, phone number etc.) seems to come from Apple on request for info related to the address.

In this case the email address was the lead, but I wonder what other info would be enough to get the phone provider to spill the beans. For instance would an IP address used at a specific time be uniquely identifying if it was VPNed by Apple at that moment ?

Or a Google Ad cookie that could get correlated to other devices showing similar behavior (the same way Google tracks households or related accounts) ?

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by fbdab103 on Monday May 06, 2024 @09:56PM (#40281487)
While an IP address is not an identity, it can still zero in on a location. I suspect governments and ISPs all keep historical logs of who was assigned what address.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by srockets on Monday May 06, 2024 @10:07PM (#40281560)
An IP address in itself is not an identity, but it can be easily resolved to one. This is why IP address are considered PII, and are handled like such by any competent security organization.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by fiso64 on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:21AM (#40286803)
>but it can be easily resolved to one

Do you have any source to back that up? Last I heard a random person or company won't have a way to find out the real identity given just an IP in general.

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by paledot on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @11:09PM (#40293976)
But the threat actor in this case is a state, which does have that ability. (And data brokers of varying degrees of shadiness can and do provide this info to anyone for a price.)
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by srockets on Tuesday May 14, 2024 @01:47PM (#40357886)
Per multiple opinions I got from people whose job was to advise me on the matter, a 2016 ECJ ruling[0] suggests that it doesn't matter if a provider can find a person from their IP address or any other detail, but that there exists a scenario where it is possible.

I am not sure how the CCPA treats IP address, but unless you're at Google or Facebook, it doesn't matter. Few can afford to build separately for the EU and the rest of the world, and hence err on adapting the strictest interpretation.

--

[0] https://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/TXT/HTML/?uri=CEL...

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by matheusmoreira on Monday May 06, 2024 @11:42PM (#40282139)
> I suspect governments and ISPs all keep historical logs of who was assigned what address.

They do. It's often required by law.

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by VelesDude on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @01:59AM (#40282797)
1 maybe 2KB of storage for the IP addresses of an individual for a year. Of course they are doing it even if accidentally.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by Sayrus on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @04:23AM (#40283453)
You may need a bit more than that. Especially for shared IPs or when using CGNAT as you need which IP and Port-range was used and during what time-range.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by refurb on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @06:15AM (#40283967)
It can be used to identify a location, but not an individual.

I assume it could be easily challenged in court (network was compromised, “i give out my WiFi to anyone who visits my home”) without other supporting evidence.

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by Adrox on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @07:25AM (#40284301)
Not in Germany, where you are responsible for the Wifi access, see hundreds of copyrights fines each year...

Anyway, it puts the persons living in that location on the radar of the police, and other evidence can be collected (For example by getting a warrant and taking all electronics out of the "location").

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by immibis on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @05:12PM (#40302759)
Apparently in Germany you can do public wifi now, but you have to register as a telecommunications provider, and comply with all law enforcement requests to wiretap your wifi.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by BodyCulture on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @06:53AM (#40284145)
It would be great to have the discussion open for people with actual knowledge and experience of the issues.

To keep the discussion interesting, please do not assume or guess, thanks!

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by RachelF on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @12:33AM (#40282363)
Why are ProtonMail keeping this IP and email information in their logs?
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by samjmck on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @12:39AM (#40282400)
The identification came from the recovery email.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by AnonC on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @02:46AM (#40283033)
In a previous case some years ago, a French activist’s IP address was provided by Proton on court order. Proton does store IP address and does provide it when legally demanded to.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by haakon on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @03:43AM (#40283299)
They were legally compelled to add IP logging for that specific user. After this incidence, they went on to obtain a court ruling in Switzerland, where they operate, so that this specific attack cannot happen again. In their blog post about it [1], they instruct concerned users to access their account over Tor.

Of course when Proton say they don't log, we just have to take their word for it. People who don't want that element of trust can use Tor. Personally I believe their story in this case.

[1] https://proton.me/blog/climate-activist-arrest

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by BodyCulture on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @06:56AM (#40284153)
Is it possible now to sign up using TOR? It didn’t work a few years ago when I tried and never visited this website ever again.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by protonmail on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @08:30AM (#40284691)
We've worked on improving it in the meantime, so we recommend that you try again. If you come across any issues, please contact our support team at: https://proton.me/support/troubleshooting?product=account
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by thinkerswell on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:35AM (#40285268)
Yes please report back if it works
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by immibis on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @05:13PM (#40302768)
It works sometimes. Usually, it requires phone number or email verification. This is important for protonmail to maintain a revenue stream as they don't allow multiple free accounts for the same person.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by protonmail on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:01AM (#40306430)
Note that even in those cases when additional verification is requested, the email addresses are not tied to your account - we only save a cryptographic hash of your email. Due to the hash functions being one-way, we cannot derive it back from the hash: https://proton.me/support/human-verification
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by immibis on Friday May 10, 2024 @03:50PM (#40323149)
If I'm a targeted journalist and I could be killed if you're lying about that, I won't believe that.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by datadeft on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @05:33AM (#40283763)
Because of legal requirements?
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by tephra on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:31AM (#40285223)
They say quite clearly why in their privacy policy: https://proton.me/legal/privacy (section 2.5: IP Logging).

> 2.5 IP logging: By default, we do not keep permanent IP logs in relation with your Account. However, IP logs may be kept temporarily to combat abuse and fraud, and your IP address may be retained permanently if you are engaged in activities that breach our terms and conditions (e.g. spamming, DDoS attacks against our infrastructure, brute force attacks). The legal basis of this processing is our legitimate interest to protect our service against nefarious activities. If you enable authentication logging for your Account or voluntarily participate in Proton's advanced security program, the record of your login IP addresses is kept for as long as the feature is enabled. This feature is off by default, and all the records are deleted upon deactivation of the feature. The legal basis of this processing is consent, and you are free to opt in or opt out of that processing at any time in the security panel of your Account. The authentication logs feature records login attempts to your Account and does not track product-specific activity, such as VPN activity.

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by lkdfjlkdfjlg on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @07:03AM (#40284185)
> Proton Mail is in the title because it's where they went first, but the actual identification (real name, phone number etc.) seems to come from Apple on request for info related to the address.

Irrelevant to the point. Proton Mail provided authorities with user data.

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by pc86 on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @09:12AM (#40285032)
Please quote from the linked article where it says that (it doesn't).
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by EclipseMantis on Tuesday May 07, 2024 @05:28PM (#40291711)
Are you sure?

> The core of the controversy stems from Proton Mail providing the Spanish police with the recovery email address associated with the Proton Mail account of an individual using the pseudonym ‘Xuxo Rondinaire.’

Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by obelus on Wednesday May 08, 2024 @09:57AM (#40298189)
The recovery email is optional, the rest of the information was provided by Apple.
Re:Proton Mail Discloses User Data Leading to Arrest in Spain by lkdfjlkdfjlg on Thursday May 09, 2024 @05:07AM (#40306457)
No one is talking about the optionality of the information.

We're saying that Proton Mail provided the authorities with user data, which it did.